Computer Model Science

Patrick Moore;

I soon discovered that trees are just large plants that have evolved the ability to grow long wooden stems. They didn’t do that so we could cut them up into lumber and grind them into pulp; they actually had only one purpose in mind and that was to get their needles or leaves higher up above the other plants where the tree could then monopolize the Sun’s energy for photosynthesis. When foresters create openings or clearcuts when they harvest trees, one of the reasons for doing it is so the new trees growing back can be in full sunlight. Trees are basically plants that want to be in the sun. If trees wanted to be in the shade they would have been shrubs instead, they would not have spent so much time and energy growing long wooden stems.
Forests are home to the majority of living species; not the oceans, nor the grasslands, nor the alpine areas, but ecosystems that are dominated by trees. There is a fairly simple reason for this. The living bodies of the trees themselves create a new environment that would not be there in their absence. Now the canopy above is home to millions of birds and insects where there was once only thin air. And beneath the canopy, in the interior of the forest, the environment is now protected from frost and sun and wind. This, in combination with the food provided by the leaves, fruits and even the wood of the trees, creates thousands of new habitats into which new species can evolve, species that could never have existed if it were not for the presence of the living trees.
This gives rise to the obvious concern that if the trees are cut down the habitats or homes will be lost and the species that live in them will die. Indeed, in 1996 the World Wildlife Fund, at a media conference in Geneva, announced that 50,000 species are going extinct each year due to human activity. And the main cause of these 50,000 extinctions, they said, is commercial logging. The story was carried around the world by Associated Press and other media and hundreds of millions of people came to believe that forestry is the main cause of species extinction.
During the past three years I have asked the World Wildlife Fund on many occasions to please provide me with a list of some of the species that have supposedly become extinct due to logging. They have not offered up a single example as evidence. In fact, to the best of our scientific knowledge, no species has become extinct in North America due to forestry.
Where are these 50,000 species that are said to be going extinct each year? They are in a computer model in Edward O. Wilson’s laboratory at Harvard University. They are electrons on a hard drive, they have no Latin names, and they are in no way related to any direct field observations in any forest.

Moore was a founding member of Greenpeace.
h/t Sheldon Kotyk.

Pollster: Majority Of Canadians As Misinformed As He

Last week Charles Adler interviewed Michael Marzolini from Pollara. What caught my ear was the pollster’s editorializing that Canadians were concerned about our economic prospects – due to sluggishness of the US economy and what we “saw for themselves” (or words to that effect) of the gloomy employment situation south of the border.

Canadians’ concerns that the U.S. economy will worsen in 2007 has body-checked Canada’ four-year trend of ever-increasing economic optimism, according to a new national poll released this morning by Michael Marzolini, Chairman of POLLARA Inc., at a breakfast meeting of the Economic Club of Toronto.

I waited for the followup – qualification by Marzolini that those perceptions are largely inaccurate and that the US economy continues to outperform our own. That didn’t happen. Instead, what followed was more evidence that we in Canada are routinely fed “findings” by pollsters who are negligently uninformed, analysed by media too lazy to confirm whether the premises – much less the conclusions – are valid.
Of course, he’s not alone;

The Canadian Chamber says Canada’s average annual real GDP growth will be 2.8 per cent in 2006 when all the numbers are counted, but that GDP growth will slow to 2.4 per cent in 2007. There are several factors for the projected slowdown, but key is lower U.S. demand for Canadian exports as a result of continuing economic weakness south of the border.
The Chamber projects that the Canadian economy will limp home as 2006 concludes, struggling to reach 2 per cent growth in the final quarter.

I cite that source not for the Chamber’s take on expectations or opinion on American prospects, but for the figure of 2.8% growth rate in the Canadian economy for 2006. Now, let’s look at that struggling American economy.

Economists are hastily upgrading their forecasts for the US economy after a series of surprisingly strong reports suggesting the so-called “soft landing” may be over and growth is accelerating.
Over the past week, surprises have come in stronger-than-expected reports on US job creation, the trade balance and retail sales — all key contributors to economic activity.
Lehman Brothers chief US economist Ethan Harris on Friday boosted his forecast for fourth quarter 2006 growth to an annualized rate of 3.3 percent, a leap from the firm’s prior call for just 2.0 percent growth.

And all those jobless workers?

The latest data showed US employers added a healthy 167,000 new jobs in December, with unemployment holding at a low 4.5 percent. Average wages were up 4.2 percent annually.

That’s right – the national rate in the US is still 1.5% below that of Canada’s 30 year lows.
What most are aware of however, is that our economic growth isn’t evenly distributed. Unemployment rates in Calgary are around 2% at the moment, while Quebec’s contribution to those “lowest jobless numbers in 30 years” is 7.5%.
Now, over to Joan Tintor, who interrupts the 24 hour coverage of global warming to provide this little-reported bookend.

Ontario slips into negative growth in third quarter; GDP minus 0.1 per cent
[…]
This is Ontario’s first quarter of negative GDP growth since the SARS-induced recession of 2003. Before that, the last negative-growth quarters were in 1992. It’s certainly the first negative growth on McGuinty’s watch.

News which is sure to send media outlets back to the pollsters to ramp up the message that the “sagging” US growth and employment rates are dragging our “more bouyant” Canadian economy down.
(More data)
Update – Michael Marzolini responds in the comments.
Related – “You gotta love Decima, if they didn’t exist the Liberals would have to create them.”

“The Dose Makes the Poison”

Once upon a time anyone with a basic education learned that the dose makes the poison. That is, no matter how harmless a chemical may seem, at high enough levels of consumption it becomes toxic. (And the corollary is one should not be too concerned about highly toxic chemicals if they are in sufficiently tiny amounts).
Alas, that lesson appears to have been learned too late for this unfortunate woman who died in a water drinking contest.
Yes, as a matter of fact, there is a toxic dose for water.
Update: I would be remiss in my duties if I didn’t take this opportunity to link to the valuable Dihydrogen Monoxide Research Division, an organization at the forefront of publicizing these sorts of dangers.

“Wake up, gentle reader”

Polygamy follows “multiple parentage” as night follows day. It likewise followed from “same-sex marriage” — for if the institution cannot be restricted to one man, and one woman, how otherwise can it be restricted? At the time Paul Martin’s Liberal government was rubber-stamping the decision of the same Ontario Appeals Court, to create same-sex marriage in Canada, we received blustering assurances that marriage would always be restricted to “two persons” — even as the bureaucrats in Mr Martin’s own justice department were telling him that legal recognition for polygamous marriage was being made inevitable. Last week’s “three parent” court decision simply hurries that process along.

Who’s The Leader Again?

Last evening’s Global news coverage of the Liberal leader’s stop in Regina described Ralph Goodale’s actions around Stephane Dion as akin to that of a “campaign manager”. That was a nice way of putting it. I noticed something else – as Dion begin to take one reporter’s question, Ralph quickly inserted himself between the Liberal leader and the microphones and answered it for him. (If anyone can find a clip of that, let me know).
What was Dion saying, and why was Ralph in such a hurry to shut him up?
The Global segment ended with Goodale at the speaker’s podium with Dion standing behind him looking on.
Meanwhile, we have ourselves another “independent farmer” sighting! Check out this passage from the Canadian Press version carried in CTV’s online report of the Regina stop;

Dion said he believes there is the capacity to mandate a 10-per-cent biofuel content in gasoline by 2010 rather than the five per cent the Conservatives are currently proposing.
“I think the strong reaction has been yes, it is possible to deliver it,” Dion said.
That won favour with Lonny McKague, an farmer from Ogema, Sask., who said he considers himself a Liberal supporter.

Well, credit Tim Cook of CP for at least asking. The farmer from Ogema, Sask. was also interviewed in both the CTV and Global televised reports, but with no mention of his political leanings.
“Liberal supporter”, indeed. Lonny McKague ran as the Liberal candidate in the federal riding of Souris–Moose Mountain in 2006.
JAN 17 UPDATE: CP responds to a reader’s complaint.

They Bought Him For “Peanuts”

“It’s hard to read…”

Alan Dershowitz’s denunciation of former President Jimmy Carter without getting a sinking feeling. Dershowitz summarizes the huge sums which investigative journalists now say Jimmy Carter received from Arab and Islamic sources. And they are considerable. The Saudis bailed out his peanut farm in 1976. The infamous BCCI and Saudi billionaire Gaith Pharaon actually helped with the startup funding of the Carter Center. Carter himself is quoted fulsomely thanking Sheik Zayed bin Sultan al-Nahyan, the long time ruler of the UAE, for donating half a million dollars. From what is known Carter has received tens of millions of dollars from Arab and Islamic sources. And that, argues Dershowitz, is behind the former President’s tireless campaigning against Israel. He says so in the most brutal and accusatory terms: “Carter … has been bought and paid for by anti-Israel Arab and Islamic money.” But it is one of Dershowitz’s sources, Dr. Rachel Ehrenfeld, who provides the most food for thought: “seems that AIPAC’s (American-Israel Political Action Committee) real fault was its failure to outdo the Saudi’s purchases of the former president’s loyalty”. The sinking feeling is the realization that this is what political viewpoints might come down to.

In 2004, the former President publicly accused Georgia Democrat Zell Miller of “unprecedented disloyalty” – for the crime of speaking at the Republican convention.

Reader Tips

From the comments – “David Suzuki is doing a series of interviews on The Weather Network. The big news here is, Chris Sinclair invites our feed-back. “ E-mail: (the boss at TWN)”
The Party of Nothing – for the troop increase before they were against it.
I do believe Stephen Harper’s communications team includes a Director of Helping Jack Layton Say Really Stupid Things Before The TV Cameras. (Note that you must read to the bottom of Rosemary “if you can’t report – speculate!” Thompson’s item to discover the words “trade mission”.)
An uncanny resemblance.
Add yours in the comments.

A Way With Words

While his pronunciation of the English language may be as mangled as a cat in a combine, Stephane Dion does show a knack for tapping into long held Western Canadian metaphors…

“I’m not there to kill the growth, I’m there to make the growth sustainable,” he said. “I don’t want to kill the milk cow. But I want to make sure that the milk will still be good and there for our grandchildren.”

Just as it was for his grandparents.

“The Youthquake Problem”

Strategy Page

Medicines and medical practices (particularly improved water and sanitation) led to a similar baby boom in the developing world in the latter half of the 20th century. Heinsohn demonstrated that when 30 percent or more of a population is aged 15-29, you have too many young men with bad attitudes, and the result is a jump in crime, terrorism and civil unrest. Heinsohn showed that in 90 percent of the 67 of the countries that have the 30 percent “Youth Bulge” (as demographers put it) you have massive unrest. Moreover, 13 of the 27 nations with the largest Youth Bulge are Moslem. In fact, most of the Youth Bulge is found in Africa and in Moslem nations.
Heinsohn also points that many historical upheavals were attributable, at least in part, to the Youth Bulge. These would include the American and French Revolutions and many other uprisings in places like Ireland and Latin America. The current growth of Youth Bulge can largely be blamed on Western efforts to improve the lives and health of people in the developing world. No good deed goes unpunished.

When It’s Already Illegal To Shoot People

The creation of lesser offences for would-be shooters is unlikely to have much effect on the body count bottom line. But, why let common sense be your guide, when there are so many willing to study such matters!

The panelists considered 51 published studies examining seven different kinds of laws, including bans on specific firearms, restrictions on who may own a firearm, and waiting periods for gun purchases. They “found insufficient evidence to determine the effectiveness of any of the firearms laws or combinations of laws.”
In other words, after more than half a century of local, state, and federal gun control legislation, we still don’t know whether these laws do what they’re supposed to do. The report’s most consistent finding was inconsistent findings: Sometimes gun control is associated with reduced violence, and sometimes it’s associated with increased violence.
The world is messy, and it can be difficult to control for all the relevant variables when you’re trying to determine the impact of a particular law. Not surprisingly, the CDC panel calls for more and better research, and it cautions that “insufficient evidence to determine effectiveness should not be interpreted as evidence of ineffectiveness.”
But it’s scandalous that politicians have been legislating in the dark all these years, promising that the gun control solution du jour would save lives when there was no evidence to back up such claims. If gun control laws have any positive effect at all, it must be pretty modest to have escaped documentation so far.

Read it all. Via Glenn Reynolds who observes; “If a drug company were as cavalier about science as these people are, its executives would all be in jail.”.
To which I’ll add – if the news industry that reports these studies were as cavalier about … oh, nevermind.

It’s Not Easy Being Green

The faint hint of chartreuse climbing Jack Layton’s cheeks is not a reflection.

Leader Jack Layton’s call for tough emissions standards for new vehicles has hit a speed bump, with Canada’s biggest auto union warning the move could cost the struggling auto sector “thousands of jobs.”
Canadian Auto Workers president Buzz Hargrove says he was “taken aback” by Layton’s comments and rebuked the federal leader for not consulting with union leaders before making his demand for the new standards.
“It would have been helpful for you to have first consulted with the CAW on this important question before making your statement,” Hargrove wrote in a letter to Layton released yesterday.

And in other Jack Layton news – reaching out to Canada’s leading online anti-semitic community to help get their message out to Canadians should be just what the doctored ordered.
Update;

This should give Crawls with Caffeine and company more to blog about now that the NDP and Liberals are also “illegally colluding with bloggers in violation of the Elections act”. There’s never enough tinfoil around when you need it.

The Blizzard of ’07

As central Saskatchewan continues to dig out from this thing, a few readers have sent photos. Some of the best are here. Most of the weather geeks have agreed that it’s the worst such event since 1955. (Three people lost their lives – all of them after leaving their stranded or rolled vehicles.)
I finished my own shoveling yesterday by tackling the driveway. It was as deep as my hip in some places, thanks to the caragana hedge. This is old fashioned blizzard snow – not the fake fluffy stuff. It’s hard packed and comes apart in the shovel in big, heavy chunks. It reminds me of a winter when I was still small enough to ride the Shetland pony – the drifts were about 8 feet high in the windbreak west of the farm that winter, and I could ride him across their tops.
Despite being featured by Peter Mansbridge a few nights ago under the subtitle of “Canada’s Weird Weather”, there’s nothing out of the ordinary in any of the weather we’ve seen this year. Not in my experience, at least. I was reminded of a piece that was published about 20 years ago in our local history book (one of many that were published at the time). I’m going to quote a portion of The Post War Era, by Chick Childerhose, for historical context and typing exercise.

Springtime. In the Saskatchewan I remember, May was my month. That was when the snow began to melt, the ground slowly reappeared and water flowed into the low-lying places. Imagine a sunny day in early May, 1947, Jack Purdy had opened his beer parlor for business and the early “regulars” had gathered. Discussion on world, national, and local problems was abruptly suspended by a shout from the door: “Hey! There’s a bunch of guys from Carlyle punching through the big drift at Ritchie Askins’.”
The ten-mile stretch of Highway 13 between Carlyle and Arcola had been closed since before Christmas. Now, according to our wild-eyed informant, the yeomen of Carlyle had decided to open it. They had shoveled their way thorough nine miles of drifts and now their convoy of cars and pickup trucks was stalled a mile short of their goal: Arcola.
A madness fell upon us. Whether it was the beautiful spring day and we were “cabin-fever” victims about to be let out of the cabin… I do not know., Yes, I do: it was those guys from Carlyle! They had snuck up on us. They were planning to drive right into Arcola and jeer at us for having to be dug out of hibernation. A rescue, sort of, by better men. The shame, the shame! The Carlyle guys must not be allowed to open our road. This is what caused the near-hysterical abandonment of the beer emporium. Shovels and transportation were what we needed.
Did I mention that the drift in front of Ritchie Askins’ place was 12 feet high? It was. But we couldn’t get to it until we had shovelled our way through a half-mile of four-foot deep, hard-packed drifts that got deeper the close we got to Askins’ driveway. By the time we arrived there, it looked like we were digging a tunnel. Actually, it was a large trench. Only four of us could work at the snow-face. The snow was so hard that we had to cut and lift it out in blocks. These were thrown on the road behind us, and were reshoveled by the second team up onto the banks. A third team rested in relays.
It was during one of my team’s rest periods that the thought occured: What if it was all a joke and there were no Carlyle guys? For so deep and formidable was the snow mountain in front of us, that no sounds of digging could be heard from the other side. I scaled the height and trekked across the top and there they were! First I saw the line of mud-encrusted vehicles, then as I got closer to the edge, the shovellers. Cries and curses. Jokes and taunts. Hilarity. For the madness was on them too, you see.
It took another four hours before the giant snow drift was pierced and then widened enough to permit passage by cars and trucks. We had done it! The road to Carlyle was open! Winter was officially over. Yay! And did we invite our Carlyle “guests” back to town for a beer? Hell no… we left them to complete their quixotic race to Arcola where they drove without stopping to our beer parlor. We piled into our cars and trucks and high-balled it through the incredible mud, slush, water, ruts and remaining snowdrifts to Carlyle. Of course! Straight to their beer parlor.

Stephane Snubbed?

Listening to Adler right now, there’s a story that new Alberta premier Ed Stelmach may have refused a photo-op with new Sustnabul Develpmunt leader Stephane Dion on his swing through Alberta. Stay tuned….
More – via reader “Sammy”, who points to this Edmonton Sun column by Neil Waugh;

“We need to be a bit like Norway,” Dion scolded. Then he tore a strip off young guys heading for the oilsands.
“All these workers living too fast for the easy money in the north,” the prime minister-wannabe blasted as Liberal-appointed senators Tommy Banks and Grant Mitchell looked on. “It’s not good for the economy.”
[…]
Then he outlined his plan to make oilsands developers toe the line, imposing what sounds like massive taxes by basing the fed’s capital cost allowance on how much process water they use and how much carbon dioxide goes up the stacks.
“You say to industry, and the oilsands industry especially, if you decrease the use of water you will have this capital cost allowance,” Dion warned. “If you don’t, you will not have it.” Same with greenhouse gas, he said.
Dion is also a big believer in the dubious carbon trading market – where companies buy and sell hot air to meet their government-imposed emissions targets.He predicted it will be “bigger than the wheat and coffee markets together.” He promised that Canadians will make “mega tonnes of money around the world”.
“It’s not at all a carbon tax,” Dion insisted, preferring to call his proposed revenue grab “environmental tax reform.” Dion rejected the next phase of Stephen Harper’s GST rollbacks. Instead, he prefers to bring in a wonkydoodle set of rebates based on the energy efficiency and greenhouse gas reduction of household appliances and automobiles.
As the battle against global warming was going on inside the cosy university meeting room the weather guy on the radio was reporting minus 23. Meanwhile, back in Quebec, Liberal Premier Jean Charest was announcing his sinister plan to commit environmental vandalism on a vast tract of northern wildland, reverse the flow of the Rupert River system and flood thousands of hectares of carbon absorbing forests at an alleged price tag of $5 billion.
All to produce 900 megawatts of power – which is about what a decent sized Alberta coal-fired plant kicks out. Strangely, the Liberal’s green PM-to-be didn’t say boo about that outrage.

I’ll bet that had them just eatin’ out of his hand.

Danger of Disinformation

On the anti-DDT hysteria:

President George W. Bush’s new international anti-malaria campaign has been greeted with enthusiasm by its victims, but with pseudoscience by commentators.
That is not unusual: Fallacies infect every debate about the environment and affect policy, taxpayers’ money and victims’ lives.

We like to poke fun at the global warming hysterics, but they haven’t killed anywhere near as many African children as the DDT activists.
And a group specializing in exactly that type of disinformation closer to home and making good money at it- As You Sow.

Reader Tips

Still down. You’ll have to amuse yourselves for a while longer.
Update – We’re back in business here, but it’s going to take a while before I’m up to speed and posting again. Thanks Kevin, for filling in.

If the Little Mosque were real

Margaret Wente comments making the Little Mosque on the Prairie more realistically Canadian:

So what would make this show more true to living in Canada? Regrettably, the cute imam would have to go. The redneck radio host would be shut down by the CRTC, and the townsfolk, instead of reacting to the mosque with fear and loathing, would invite everyone in it to join an interfaith group. Instead of calling the terror hotline, the village idiot would chuck a rock through the mosque’s window. A Muslim from Egypt would be tossed into jail indefinitely on secret evidence. The convert to Islam (here played by Sheila McCarthy who only wears her head scarf in the mosque) would be dressed in black from head to foot. And the Muslim versions of Archie Bunker and Meathead would have a hilariously incorrect debate over the existence of that pesky state of Israel.

And the redneck radio host would be fined by the Saskatchewan Human Rights Commission.

Navigation