An article on political blogs that manages not only to avoid meaningful content, it offers up a host of incorrect assumptions;
But for all the political blogs that can be found on the Net, it remains hard to pinpoint with any certainty their impact on voters.
Recent voting patterns indicate turnout among younger Canadians is low and dropping.
How long have we had the “interweb” now? In how many homes? Why does mainstream media continue to stereotype political bloggers and our readers as “tech savvy” twenty year olds?
Here’s a comment that appeared here at SDA a couple of days ago;
Typical CBC leading off with poll showing the Liberals ahead. For the duration, that is the last time I watch any news. I’ll get all my updates on this blog so keep up the good work with your posts. At 77, I have to watch the old b.p.
A surprisingly high number of the visitors to SDA are retired or nearing retirement age – and if the emails I receive privately are any indication, the typical reader here is male, and in their late thirties to early fifties. That’s certainly not the demographic one ordinarily thinks of as the “tech savvy younger generation”.
It’s a misconception held not only by many in media, but by those in political circles, and it results in idiotic prattlings like this by writers dropped into the blogosphere who have no clue what they’re doing, or who their audience really is.
But just because it’s an Internet-savvy generation doesn’t mean blogging is the answer to engaging disaffected voters, said Chris Waddell, a journalism professor at Carleton University who teaches web publishing.
“I’m not convinced anyone reads them other than a small group of insiders,” said Waddell.
“People are not coming home from work at night and deciding they have to read 10 or 12 blogs before dinner in the same way they may read the newspaper or sit down to watch the news.”
Emphasis mine. Who is this man and who’s allowing him to teach your children?
My traffic patterns indicate most people read blogs during the day, often at work (that’s supported by logfile data) with another surge in the early evening.
He adds some of the more effective blogs, especially in the United States, have reached mass audiences – but it’s because reporters from mainstream media pick up on a blog posting.
And there we have it, courtesy of the mainstream media, another “expert opinion” offered by someone who might have saved himself the professional embarrassment by simply admitting he doesn’t know much about the topic.
Blogging is a niche media. Very few political bloggers seek to be all things to all people, no more than most who write political columns in the mainstream media aim to do so. Single bloggers aren’t isolated entities competing with one another, but participants in an ever evolving, open source staff of opinion writers and information providers connected electronically.
One doesn’t compare the traffic of any individual poliblogger to the circulation figures of a city newspaper – the blogger is to the blogosphere what the polticial columnist or financial reporter is to the paper. The web user can pick and choose who he reads and doesn’t read in the same way I skip over columns or sections of the paper I’m not interested in.
But the most serious flaw in the article is that it assumes the transference of opinion and information is one way – from blogger to reader in the same “top down” fashion that mainstream journalism speaks to their consumers.
It’s really the other way around – as a blog develops traffic, the information flow reverses, as readers begin to inform other readers, with the blogger as interpreter and facilitator – functioning, as Hugh Hewitt described it, as an internet guide or “cyber sherpa”.
The impact of blogging on the poltiical landscape doesn’t happen here on these “pages” nor is it measured in my traffic. I don’t write to “sway disaffected voters”.
It occurs when the reader who visits SDA – who follows the links in posts and comments to an Auditor General’s report, to military bloggers in Iraq, who has viewed scanned letters issued from the Finance Department to Adscam players – sends a link to a friend in Nova Scotia, sits down at the table with family, at coffee break at the work place, and someone else raises a subject for discussion that has been framed in the mainstream – such as the war in Iraq, income trusts, Paul Martin’s involvement in Sponsorship. And that person, the blog reader, has information that no one else has heard.
(Update – the comments are confirming my estimate on typical age of SDA readers).