The following appears to be a hoax email. See update below
Four years ago, Jack Layton was elected with an agenda for change and new energy. He had great momentum, and we believed he can take us all the way to government. But sadly, his performance was below expectations. We now find ourselves in an uncomfortable position, with a spiritless leader and a rudderless party machine.
The party needs new energy, again. Dion’s recent election cemented the fact that leadership races ignite and inspire the public. That’s just the fix we can do with right now. And it’s time for new campaigns and issues. Something to electrify the membership once more.
There are many reasons for Jack to go right now:
Loss of credibility. Issues like the environment, child care and Afghanistan have all been supplanted by other party leaders or abandoned by Jack. There is now no issue where Jack Layton leads, and no emerging policy has resonated with the public from him, either.
Scripted Leadership. Unfortunately, Jack Layton has chosen a prepared, reviewed and impersonal style of speaking when addressing the public and the membership. His Leader’s Debate performance came off as flat and bland, though full of rhetoric.
No Lasting Campaigns. The recent Afghanistan campaign conducted by Jack Layton has largely been abandoned, as it has by the rest of the media. Jack Layton has not spoken publicly about Afghanistan in over a month.
Issue-less Elections. Fearing a bad response from the public, Jack Layton chose not to advance any issue in particular in the 2006 election. Aside from the strong argument that the NDP managed to get from the Liberals 1.6 billion in social spending, the general tone against Liberal corruption, a promise on child care, and some vague rhetoric employing the words “health care” and “environment” and who knows what other terms his pollsters approved of, the party stood for nothing.
Ineffective Opposition. Question Period is a time when great attention is paid to the words of the party leader, yet somehow, Layton has not managed to get on top of enough issues to make the evening newscasts and the morning papers. It is unfortunate, but the responsibility lies on Layton’s shoulders.
Uninvolved Membership. It is rare when the membership is asked to help the party, aside from donating to it or campaigning for its elections. A new leader may bring in a de-centralized structure, where movements and party activists can intertwine and campaigns built from the ground up.
New Leaders Emerging. Credible people like Stephen Lewis, Joe Comartin and Libby Davies stand in the wings Layton, and are in a position to mobilize the party. All three are passionate speakers and have what it takes to win the votes and the hearts of the public and beat the Conservatives and the Liberals in the next election.
Dion. The new election of Dion has pushed the Liberals greatly ahead of the Conservatives. At this point, both the Conservatives and the NDP want to wait until better times before they dissolve parliament. This means that we’ll have about a 5 months to elect a new leader, not an impossible timeframe. We don’t have time to wait another 4 years in the hopes that Jack will change. He’s had his chance and now it’s somebody else’s turn.
Centralized Management. The Jack Party spends far too much on unneeded expenses. According to the financial statement filed with Elections Canada, the party administration raised 5.2 million dollars from the party membership last year, but spent 10.09 million dollars on expenses like fundraising (telemarketing companies), as well as “polling” and “professional services” (other privatized, contracted-out work), and of course salaries, office expenses, and travel & hospitality. Under Jack, the party increased its debt by 5.4 million dollars in 2005 despite it not being an election year. From http://www.elections.ca/fin/rep/2005/ndp_2005.pdf
We are the party of Tommy Douglas and JS Woodworth, of unabashed determination and irreconcilable ideals, not of fleeting notions and abandoned goals. Jack, thank you for your work over these four years – but it’s time to move on. Please step down and support a new leadership contest. To write to Jack Layton, email laytoj@parl.gc.ca
To have new energy, we must have new leadership.
Jennifer Bernier, President
Abitibi-Témiscamingue NDP
jnrbernier@yahoo.ca
Critics often accuse me of offering only the viewpoints of conservatives in the Canadian political debate. I trust that this goes at least partway towards a new commitment at SDA to provide balance.
More from Greg Staples– “is [there] another reason why the NDP does not want anything to do with the Blogging Dippers. What could it be? Hmmm, what could it be?”
Plus – “I phone dead people”
UPDATE – Well, I’ve learned my lesson. I try to provide balance, and this is the thanks I get… – Commentors have advised that this email was a hoax. I’m so used to being misled by NDP governments, I’ve lost the ability to tell the real lies from the fake ones.