The Marsh Arabs

The marshes were always a mysterious place, a haven and hideout for rebels, bandits, dissenters. When the Shiites failed in their uprising against Saddam after the Persian Gulf War, many of them sought refuge in these marshes. And the local residents, hating the regime — like most Iraqis — sympathized with them. Saddam decided that the area and the people had to be eradicated.
What happened next is a picture of pure evil; it can scarcely be absorbed. In a massive push called the Third River Project, the regime created dams, dikes, and canals — and dried up the marshes. One new canal was called the Mother of All Battles River; there was also the Fidelity to the Leader Canal.
With amazing speed, this vast wetland became a desert. The plants died, the animals died, water was nowhere. One newspaper report had residents saying that it was as though someone had pulled a plug. Saddam destroyed a full 90 percent of the Mesopotamian Marshlands, establishing a military zone in their place.

But there’s much, much more. The elimination of the marshes caused the people to starve, flee, or die — and Saddam did all he could to make sure they died. He poisoned the lagoons; he shelled villages; he set reedbeds ablaze; he imprisoned, tortured, and executed; and he attacked these Iraqis with WMD — with chemical weapons. He left no technique untried. In August 1993, a British writer and filmmaker, Michael Wood, said that the dictator’s “slow genocide of the Marsh Arabs is nearing its climax.” Yet it had not been so slow, really.

h/t

Birth Of An Ice Cube

It’s not often one gets a chance to pack this much uncontested hyperbole into a news item;

Laval University’s Warwick Vincent, who studies Arctic conditions, travelled to the new ice island and couldn’t believe what he saw. “It was extraordinary,” Vincent said Thursday. “This is a piece of Canadian geography that no longer exists.”

Ice is geography now?

Vincent said in 10 years of working in the region, he has never seen such a dramatic loss of sea ice.

And in 15 years of working in this region, I’ve never shovelled so much snow this early in the year. So what?

Scientists said it is the largest event of its kind in 30 years. They point their fingers at climate change as a major contributing factor.

And there they go again. Maybe they meant to say “3,000” years. Or maybe 300? In other words – what is the significance about any event of this type being the “largest” in 30 years and how does that legitimize the assertion that it’s an indication of global climate change? Are we to deduce that an even larger chunk broke free in 1976? Or that – more likely – data is insufficient prior to the mid-1970’s to make any meaningful comparisons.
Despite the article’s mention that this chunk of ice “travelled west for 50 kilometres until it finally froze into the sea ice in the early winter”, Mr. Vincent seems nearly inconsolable;

“We’re seeing the tragic loss of unique features of the Canadian landscape,” Vincent said, adding the global climate is crossing an unprecedented threshold.
“There are microscopic organisms and entire ecosystems associated with this ice, so we’re losing a part of Canada’s natural richness.”

It’s a good thing Dr. Vincent wasn’t around to witness the effects of the North American megadrought of the 1600’s. He’d have positively had a bird. In the comments, Cal2 makes this wry observation;

11000 football fields sounds way worse than 20 square miles […] just for comparison the area of Calgary is 300 square miles.the area of Red Deer Alberta 25 square miles or 14000 football fields.

Arctic weather map (It’s -36C in Alert this morning).
Back to our article. Just how did they learn of the momentous event? No one was on hand to observe it. Scientists “reconstructed” it “using high tech monitoring devices, including satellite images”. Presumably, the same ones that were in place prior to 1906, to enable widely quoted scientists like Dr. Vincent to place his “10 years” of regional observation in the broader climatological context.
With all due respect to the climate cultists – while it ensures the media attention you crave, the use of alarmist terminology like “tragic” and “unprecedented” to describe an ice cube floating in the arctic ocean isn’t likely to sway skeptics already desensitized to sensational overkill.


Related – Residents of Nunavut don’t seem as concerned about the polar bear population decline as the armchair activists are. In fact, they’d like to keep shooting them, thankyou very much.
Also related – The FCPP is hosting a lecture with historical climatologist, Tim Ball on January 27th in Winnipeg.

Europe’s Pro-Jihad Position

Caroline Glick refutes the contention that Iran is allowing its oil producing infrastructure to decline so precipitiously that the ability to carry out threats may be waning.

Last year Iran signed a $70 billion deal with the Chinese to modernize its oil and gas fields. Iran also signed an oil deal with Venezuelan leader Hugo Chavez that guarantees its fuel imports will be sanctions-proof.
To make itself immune from the effects of economic sanctions or a possible naval blockade, Iran is building two new oil refineries. It is also moving its transportation sector from oil to natural gas. With the second largest natural gas reserves in the world, an Iranian transportation system which runs on natural gas will be immune to foreign sanctions. Furthermore, by modifying its gas stations and private cars to run on natural gas, Iran is freeing up its oil refineries to produce jet fuel for its air force.
Through these massive economic projects, Iran shows clearly that it is placing its economy on long-term war-footing. It will do whatever it takes to ensure it is equipped to acquire nuclear weapons and maintain its control over the global jihad.

That’s just the underpinning, however. The question – again – comes back to who’s on who’s side. Old allies seem to have chosen;

Unfortunately, in today’s world, apparently nothing breeds condemnation and hatred more than military victories against jihadists.
The Organization of the Islamic Conference has called daily for an Ethiopian pullout from Somalia. So too, the Arab League demands that Ethiopia retreat. With their people on the ground retreating with the ICU [Islamic Courts Union], as has been their consistent policy towards Israel, so in Somalia the Arabs and Muslims wish to win at the negotiating table what they cannot achieve on the battlefield.
In this pursuit, they enjoy support from a familiar quarter. Five days before Ethiopia invaded Somalia, the EU attempted to mediate the conflict in a manner that would prolong and legitimize the ICU’s control of Somalia.
On December 20, EU mediator Louis Michel shuttled between Baidoa and Mogadishu. Later that day he triumphantly announced, “There is a strong, good will by both parties to resolve this conflict with political dialogue.”
When word of the Ethiopian invasion got out, Michel – like his associates in the EU Secretariat – moved immediately to condemn Ethiopia. Sunday he said, “I condemn in the strongest terms the escalation of the conflict in Somalia into an all-out war and appeal for all Somali sides to cease immediately all hostilities. I express my deepest concern on the reported involvement of foreign forces in Somalia and urge all external players to refrain immediately from intervening militarily in Somali affairs and provoke further violence.”
Last week, as he engaged in his shuttle diplomacy, Michel pointedly did not take a public stand regarding the ICU’s declaration of jihad against Ethiopia or its announcement that it would target any UN-peacekeepers that entered the country.
Israelis routinely assume that Europe’s pro-jihadist policy towards the Palestinians is a result of anti-Semitism or anger over Israel’s military victory in 1967. But the EU’s treatment of Ethiopia and the TFG indicates that Brussels’ hostility towards the Jewish state is part of a much further-reaching policy. Europe’s pro-jihad position toward the war in Somalia indicates that its support for jihad is over-arching rather than limited to specific battlegrounds. So what we learn from the Qatar conference and the war in Somalia is that a tripartite alliance of Iran, the Arab world and Europe upholds the cause of jihad not merely against Israel and the US, but globally. It is clear that the Iranians are the most dangerous part of the three-headed jihadist Hydra. Like the Arab despots, the Europeans are provoked by cynicism. While the Arab dictatorships embrace jihad to safeguard their regimes, the Europeans support the jihadists in the hope that their support will deflect jihadist violence away from them.

Related – another summary of the problem facing Israel.

Saddam Swings (Updated)

Like a pendulum do….
Anyone know where a blogger can git one of them there fancy countdown clocks?


Bumped to top

Dec.29 Updates: Some of the response to this news is curious, if not downright illogical. “Executing Saddam won’t improve the situation in Iraq” would be one way to sum up the argument. The New York Times dives head first into the realm of absurdity, arguing the execution doesn’t “nurture hope for a better future” – as though allowing the spider-hole dictator to escape a legally delivered sentence to taunt his victims under state protection for the remainder of his days would signal some turning of a corner in Iraqi justice.
Well, executing Saddam has nothing to do with “improving” Iraq (though it’s hard not to argue that his demise would do so by default). Executing Saddam has to do with delivering justice to a mass murderer on behalf of his victims.
Jules Crittenden reflects on his time reporting from Iraq;

So now comes the part where a monster, reduced to a ridiculous cranky old man, will have a rope put around his neck and take his drop. For civilized people it is impossible not to feel some empathy with any man’s mortality in the cold moment of execution. In my house we have a joke. Saddam doesn’t like Fruit Loops. More for us. Now, No Fruit Loops guy is going to get it. Even more for us.
We all know the enormity of his crimes, and many of us know men and women who are dead because of him. But the only satisfaction I’ll feel with his death is to know that there is still justice that is carried to termination and not cynically subverted in this world. It is only more death on top of death after that.

More Updates – Word behind the scenes is that Saddam’s time is best measured in hours, not days.
Waiting… at Iraq the Model.
Post mortem note – And… the book is closed on one former murdering dictator. CBC made some noise about the haste of the execution, depriving the Kurds of their day in court. Apparently, nobody in their research department stumbled upon the fact that Hussein was nearing the magic age of 70, and the “get out of noose free” card that comes with that under Iraqi law.
Confederate Yankee’s source places the main event “at 4:22 AM… and every media source on the planet is wrong about the 6:00 AM execution.”
Video.
New- WMD found and neutralized, in Iraq.

Reader Tips

Good riddance;

‘Kingsley should have been fired years ago,” says NCC vice president Gerry Nicholls. “He was not a disinterested bureaucrat. Kingsley had an ideological axe to grind and he used his powers to go after groups he didn’t like.’

This column by Colby Cosh “Does America need a Foreign Legion?” might make for compelling argument – if it weren’t undermined by the facts. (link fixed) Update: more factual rebuttal in the comments.
“The AP and E&P have teamed up to perpetuate a lie.”
Senator Joe Lieberman has returned from Iraq;

[L]et there be no doubt: If Iraq descends into full-scale civil war, it will be a tremendous battlefield victory for al-Qaeda and Iran. Iraq is the central front in the global and regional war against Islamic extremism.

Aw, shucks, Jason. 🙂
Use this thread for your news tips and blog posts.

“The Blog Mob: Written By Fools To Be Read By Imbeciles”

The journalist who wrote those words is interviewed – by radio talk host and blogger, Hugh Hewitt.

Hugh Hewitt: We go back to what you said just before the break, that the quality of commentary and analysis is better in mainstream media than it is in new media. Are you familiar with the work of Eugene Robinson at the Washington Post?
Joseph Rago: Yes, I am.
HH: Do you think it’s serious?
JR: No, I don’t.
HH: Are you familiar with the economic analysis of Paul Krugman at the New York Times?
JR: I am.
HH: Do you think it’s serious?
JR: And you know, you can run through…
HH: I’m going to (laughing)
JR: You can tick off Maureen Dowd and you can tick off all sorts of people at the New York Times…
HH: I think we’ll agree that David Brooks does a good job, right?
JR: Sure.
HH: And Nicholas Kristoff does great reporting from Sudan when he’s there, right?
JR: Right.
HH: But do you think E.J. Dionne is a serious analysis of American politics?
JR: I don’t always agree with him, but I would say yes, he’s serious.
HH: Okay, how about anyone at the Los Angeles Times? Name me anyone at all out there who is serious.
JR: Max Boot.
HH: Max is not…he writes a syndicated column. He writes a column that gets picked up there, but I mean a staff columnist.
JR: I can’t think of one.
HH: There aren’t any. In fact, they’re the worst major newspaper in America for a reason that they’ve worked hard to empty themselves of all discernible talent. If you live in California, then, Joe, are you better served by reading and getting your news from the internet and the blogosphere than by taking the L.A. Times?

Islamist Escalation In Thailand

Islamist terrorism in Thailand continues, (along with the chronic western media disinterest);

Two months after the coup that brought in a government that offered a kinder and gentler approach to solving the Islamic terrorism in the south, that terrorism has gotten worse. Before the coup, terrorists killed about 49 people a month. Now it’s up to 56 murders a month. There are now over twenty bombings a month down there, and about seven school a month are being destroyed. The terrorists continue to concentrate on suspected pro-government Moslems, non-Moslems and government workers. Most of the mountainous back country villages have been terrorized, and “cleansed” of infidels (non-Moslems) to such an extent, that the terrorists can move about openly in daytime.

(Previous entries on terrorism in Thailand.)

Finders, Thinkers and Linkers

At the Belmont Club, a discussion on the architecture of the blogospere that should be required reading for anyone in media (including those involved in the communications machinery of government, military and political parties). It addresses what blogs are, how they function as a system…

Observers have long noticed that blog sites tended to fall into one of three categories: the Finders, Thinkers and Linkers, and these correspond to the structure of the blogosphere. Finders are sites dedicated to capturing direct experiences. Food bloggers, reporters embedded with military units, the journals of expeditions, institutions which monitor foreign language publications — the tourist who posts pictures of a tsunami which has just wrecked his hotel — are all examples of Finders. During the 2006 war between Israel and Hezbollah, one Israeli schoolboy described how he sheltered from rockets in a bunker on his personal weblog. Others captured video of rockets striking their neighborhoods. These are all Finders. They perform one simple function: to lift an event above the Horizon and make it visible to the Internet for the first time. The importance of this act cannot be overstated. Glenn Reynolds, in a private conversation, referred to this original reportage, the discovery of the primary fact, as “the Killer App”.
Once an event has been blogged, however obscurely, it becomes potentially accessible to one of the countless eyes, both human and robotic, which pore over the Internet in search of facts to bolster or demolish an argument. Monitoring websites is a task made easier by the widespread adoption of a protocols like RSS which belong to class of formats which alert watchers to updated content, often with a summary of the content itself. Programs which continuously monitor a number of websites for content changes are called aggregators. Amateur and professional specialists use these and a variety of other tools to scour the web looking for new trends and facts to bolster their models. Some are industry analysts; others are academics; still others are open-source intelligence gatherers. Some are amateurs. Collectively they may be called the Thinkers. They are the people who find the stories in the raw data.
One classic example of a blogger acting as a Thinker was how Flopping Aces tracked down and finally debunked the existence of AP source “Captain Jamil Hussein”, who was widely quoted by the wire service as an expert on the atrocities in the Baghdad area. Using Internet search tools and email, Flopping Aces gathered enough detail to make him suspect that that “Captain Jamil Hussein” was an all too conveniently present and quotable to be plausible. Following his hunch, Flopping Aces soon discovered that American officials in Baghdad had never heard of this widely quoted AP source. He wrote up his findings and preciptated a storm. Eventually, Hussein’s existence was categorically denied by the Iraqi Ministry of the Interior, leading to demands that the AP retract stories based upon the phantom Captain. To this day the Associated Press has not produced the person or even the photograph of their star source, and a search for him finally involving CNN has not turned him up either.
[…]
Now we come to the Linkers. Although Flopping Aces was a widely read blogsite, its traffic alone was incapable of generating the attention to necessary to challenge the mighty Associated Press. But the impact of the Flopping Aces analysis was soon magnified by the hierarchical structure of the blogosphere, a structure we glimpsed by running queries in Technorati. Following Flopping Ace’s trailblazing efforts, posts casting doubt on the existence of “Captain Jamil Hussein” began to appear at even larger sites like Instapundit and Michelle Malkin’s, sites which specialize in spotting trending stories and spreading them around. These bloggers are often called the Linkers. Blogsite after blogsite, following the lead of the Linkers, began to pile on to the case of “Captain Jamil Hussein”, and added their traffic to the growing chorus. Finally the signal jumped across the gap into the mainstream media and the political world. One blogger — one Thinker — had forced the mighty Associated Press to respond to the question of whether it was making its sources up.
The entire process can be summarized in the flowchart shown below. First a veritable army of collectors (the Finders) report events on their weblogs. This pushes events above the Horizon. These events in turn become visible to the Thinkers, who are often specialist analysts in particular beats. The Thinkers are often the first to detect a significant trend; trends that are sometimes ignored or overlooked by the mainstream media which is busy with its own editorial priorities. Sometimes the Thinkers find a glaring flaw in an existing news story which resets the narrative. In a variety of ways, the Thinkers weave facts into a story, and particularly striking memes are amplified by the Linkers until it engages the public consciousness.

…and where the future may lie. (A must read for newer bloggers as well.)

Order Of Some Canadians Are More Politically Appreciated Than Others

I did not know this;

Don Cherry is a Canadian icon but remarkably Don Cherry is not a member of the Order of Canada.
How could that be? Who is more Canadian? I was surprised about this. Well sort of. He is as loud a patriot as there has ever been but he’s also been a thorn in the side of the Liberals who have ruled this land for much of its 140 years.
But with Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper in office now there are some hoping the tide will change and a few right-wingers will get a shot — with Don Cherry at the top of the list.
While they are at it maybe they can include a few well deserving Sun columnists, too. How the Toronto Star’s Michele Landsberg and the Globe and Mail’s Jeffrey Simpson are members of the order and Sun legends Peter Worthington and Doug Fisher are not, says everything you need to know about how unfair the process is.
Worthington and Fisher are Canadian veterans who served in World War II and legendary journalists who have 120 years of newspaper experience between them. I haven’t found any military service records for Landsberg or Simpson. They must have had other connections.
Cherry’s connection is his fans, regular Canadians, and an underground campaign to see that he gets his due has popped up. “Don Cherry epitomizes and is representative of the freedoms we as Canadians enjoy, the freedom of speech,” said Toronto Police video services manager John Sandeman. “He does what government’s strive to do, unite Canada.”
Sandeman sent over an e-mail yesterday hoping to get people to fill in the form and send it to Ottawa. Let me know what you think or call the Governor General’s office at 1-800-465-6890, e-mail info@gg.ca or write to Rideau Hall, 1 Sussex Dr., Ottawa, Ont. K1A 0A1.

Via National Newswatch (which is getting better by the day).
UPDATE – Maybe we should just pool our pennies and buy him one.

Old MacDonald Had “Generous” CWB Sponsorship

We have another pro-Wheat Board “independent farmer” spotting in media! Via reader “Dennis”;

In today’s Winnipeg Free Press, page B10, there is a story about a poll taken in Winnipeg regarding the wheat board. Prominent in the story is a photo and some quotes from “Starbuck area farmer Chuck Fossay”, who is quoted as approving of the single desk, and whom the article describes as “…not giving up hope.”
Mr. Fossay says, “There’s always the possibility of a federal election in the new year too. Stephan Dion said he supports the single-desk system, he’s willing to let farmers decide…”

If you don’t know anything about Chuck Fossay, it seems as if the article considers it too much of a chore to help you out. However, Chuck happens to be a neighbor of mine. He’s a past Vice-President of Keystone Agricultural Producers, an organization that is well-known for its vociferous support of the single desk, and who counts the Canadian Wheat Board as a “generous sponsor” of the organization. (This info can be found on the KAP website). At present, Chuck Fossay sits on KAP’s grains and oilseeds committee.

EE, I, EE, I, O!

The article, as well, did not ask Mr. Fossay if he had any political affiliations. While I don’t think he holds any official title in the Liberal Party of Canada, I do know that in the last federal election he was seen touring with the Liberal candiate in Portage-Lisgar. The Free Press might have at least asked.

Or maybe they already knew – it’s not as though references to Mr. Fossay are hard to find.
And while we’re on the topic of the curious incuriousity of today’s journalists, this email from Tamara King was received by a reader who pointed out that the “independent farmer” she quoted at a pro-CWB event in this Winnipeg Sun item just happens to be President of the Brandon-Souris Liberal Riding Association;

Thanks for your email. Apologies for the delayed reply; I work shifts. I was made aware of your email today.
The term “independent” producer was meant to show that he’s not the head of a large corportation.
That’s what he told me, so that’s what I wrote.
I would like to point out – I did include the detail about him attending that Grit gathering, which shows he’s political.
Apologies if those elements came across poorly.
As a news reporter – one who covers crime, mostly – I was simply trying to convey what occured at Dion’s stop in Winnipeg, not make a wider commentary on the future of the industry.
Regards,
Tamara King

“That’s what he told me, so that’s what I wrote.”
You know, I think that would look really nice on a plaque.
Update Another incurious journalist – Bill Doskosh of CTV comments on the breakup of the Australian Wheat Board monopoly – a factoid he only stumbled across on Dec.23rd. He doesn’t let lack of familiarity interfere with conspiracy mongering, however;

Hmm, so another Conservative government in the Land Down Under — one whose leader is close to Prime Minister Stephen Harper — wants to end the monopoly of the Australian Wheat Board? And the Conservative government of Canada, whose leader is close to Australian Prime Minister John Howard, wants to end it here?

Doskosh displays no apparent knowledge of the AWB involvement in paying millions kickbacks to the Saddam Hussein regime under the UN Oil-For-Food scam. or that it’s the fallout from the scandal that has prompted the move.
Well, Canadian journalism as a whole has been curiously incurious about the UN scandal, so Doskosh’s ignorance is to be expected, I guess. Perhaps the idea of investigating all those Canadian connections at the highest levels of the UN, (and their relationships to certain Liberal prime ministers) was just so overwhelming they didn’t know where to begin.

“Journalists should know better by now”

Josh Trevino;

The Ethiopian invasion of Somalia proceeds apace, and from all reports, it proceeds at a much faster clip than anyone — including me — expected. Western journalism is struggling, and failing, to keep up.
[…]
[D]etails are sparse: journalism fails where journalists fear to tread, and so we are reduced to reading propaganda releases from the opposing sides — see, for example, and in an indication of the rather different values in this part of the world, Ethiopian Prime Minister Meles Zenawi bragging about the fatality rates amongst Islamist casualties — and the reports of the few Westerners on the ground. In Somalia’s case, the latter are mostly European aid workers and the odd United Nations official. Naturally, their reportage focuses upon things that affect them, and the wishes of the men with guns closest to them. Thus media from Islamist-controlled Mogadishu cites as its only two sources the Islamists — and the International Committee of the Red Cross. And so we see in the Washington Post unsourced passages telling us: “Aid workers said … thousands of civilians battered by drought, floods and now by rockets and mortars continued to flee villages in droves.” Worse: “United Nations officials warned of a dire humanitarian crisis inside Somalia, while fears remained high that Ethiopia’s campaign could have disastrous consequences across the Horn of Africa.”
This is absurd on several levels, beginning with the implicit contention that Somali suffering is only now beginning, and that the conquering advance of the Islamists there did not itself bring some measure of woe. Somalia is a wretched country, plagued with war, disease, anarchy and famine, and has been since the disintegration of the Siad Barre dictatorship fifteen years ago. (Even under Siad Barre, it was mired in decades of war and cruel repression.) The standard aid-worker/UN narrative — that this or that military action will result, or is resulting, in a “dire humanitarian crisis” or “disastrous consequences” — is therefore even more ridiculous than usual. (Recall, if you will, the predictions from the same quarters of a massive refugee/humanitarian crisis in Afghanistan prior to America’s invasion of that Islamist-ruled land.) In the spirit of fairness, we should allow that worrying about these things is their job; but one wishes they had evidenced similar concern over the Islamist ascendency prior to the Ethiopian intervention. That they did not is doubtless motivated by two factors: first, that the Islamists would kill those who complained overmuch; second, that the Ethiopians, being nominally Christian and supposedly American-backed (this last now based upon State Department statements), are more intellectually and socially acceptable targets to that particular set. (For vignettes of the average aid worker’s mindset on the United States in particular, see here.) As if on cue, erstwhile UN functionary Salim Lone arises in the pages of the International Herald Tribune to blame the whole mess on America — and to declare that the cure for Somalia’s woes was the salutary embrace of a vicious Islam.

Go read the whole thing – if only to understand just how much disregard you should hold for the so-called “reporting” of this conflict.
Dec 28 Update on the progress against the Islamist Courts, including information on the US support, at Strategypage.

The U.S. was apparently providing the Ethiopians with satellite and aircraft photos of Islamic Courts positions. The U.S. has a large counter-terror force to the north, in Djibouti. The U.S. may be supplying Ethiopia with cash (to pay for all the gas the Ethiopians are burning in their operations). For years, the U.S. has been training Ethiopian troops for operations like this.

Helps explain why they seem so good at it.

Hannah and Cedar Hawach – Updated

I reported this story back in August, via Moldy Peaches;

An old friend – in Calgary – from high school had her little girls taken from her. It appears the girl’s father took them overseas and has no intention of returning. The father, Joseph Hawach, is Lebanese and lived in Australia for several years. He is expected to take them to either Australia or Lebanon. Joseph Hawach is travelling with his mother Gladys Hawach. The little girl’s names are Hannah and Cedar Hawach.

It was local news for a few days, then dropped off the map. Today, it’s gone international;

Wollongong father of one Brian Corrigan and David Pemberton, a former New Zealand special forces member, face up to 15 years in a Lebanese jail after leading a five-man team to reunite Melissa Hawach with daughters Hannah, five, and Cedar, three.
As well as holding Canadian and Australian citizenship, Hannah and Cedar are considered Lebanese citizens, giving their father Joseph rights to their custody under Lebanese law.
Missing Children’s Society of Canada executive Rhonda Morgan said on Monday that the five men did only surveillance work and were not involved in the seizure last Wednesday of the girls from the car park of a hotel in the resort of Jounieh.
Ms Morgan said the two Australians and three New Zealanders offered their services to Ms Hawach, whose father Jim Engdahl is the president and chief executive of Great Western Minerals Group and a former vice-president of Barclay’s Bank in Canada.
However, Lebanese police sources said yesterday that Mr Pemberton, the alleged team leader hauled from a plane at Beirut airport with Mr Corrigan last Wednesday, was initially approached via an email asking him if he wanted the job to rescue the girls, taken to Lebanon by their father at the height of the July-August Israeli-Hezbollah war.

According to local radio, Jim Engdahl (who’s from Saskatoon) called in help from his many business contacts – including the Prince of Dubai. He, daughter Melissa and the girls are reportedly in a safe place, but still in Lebanon. The Canadian Embassy isn’t commenting.
More at the Star Phoenix.

Clawing Back

Troop pay;

As you know, I am at Addis Ababa with TFAA, supporting the African Union in Sudan. This month, someone in Ottawa has decided that our mission should have the Risk Level down graded from Level 2 to Level 1 and have our danger pay reduced. In addition, with Risk level reduced, the tax exemption was gone. This is retroactive to June 2006. Well, the pay system took all the taxes owed in one shot and for my Dec pay, I owed the Feds $11000.00. This is just bloody insane. I have lost 25 lbs in the last four months and got intestinal amoebic infection twice and is constanly on Anti-biotic which leaves this metallic taste in your mouth. At any given time, 60 to 70% percent of the TFAA members are down with something. In october, all members had dystentery, amoeba infection, and one repatriated member had malaria. A replacement MCPL for the clerk who was away on HLTA got Amoeba in the three weekd she was there. Now, that is not including the other aspects of hazzards and isolation typical of a tour. If that is not risk, I don’t know what is…

Reading the comments, my guess is that the relevant MP’s have already been notified. If anyone has more info or an update on this, be sure to let me know.

“We wonder if we’ve oversold the science”

Kevin Vranes’ take on the American Geophysical Union;

To sum the state of climsci world in one word, as I see it right now, it is this: tension.
What I am starting to hear is internal backlash. Sure, science is messy and always full of tension between holders of competing positions, opinions and analyses. That has always been the nature of science, and of course extends to climate science. Tensions come out at meetings, on listservs, on letters pages, and in the press. But these tensions normally surround a particular paper, or a particular question. While much more broadly-based tensions have existed for years on the state of understanding on global warming, they haven’t really been tensions internal to the climsci community, but tensions between the climsci community and interested outsiders.
What I am sensing now is something much broader and more diffuse, something that has less to do with particular components of the science in the field and is much more about how the field is composing itself.
What I see is something that I am having a hard time labeling, but that I might call either a “hangover” or a “sophomore slump” or “buyers remorse.” None fit perfectly, but perhaps the combination does. I speak for (my interpretation) of the collective: {We tried for years – decades – to get them to listen to us about climate change. To do that we had to ramp up our rhetoric. We had to figure out ways to tone down our natural skepticism (we are scientists, after all) in order to put on a united face. We knew it would mean pushing the science harder than it should be. We knew it would mean allowing the boundary-pushers on the “it’s happening” side free reign while stifling the boundary-pushers on the other side. But knowing the science, we knew the stakes to humanity were high and that the opposition to the truth would be fierce, so we knew we had to dig in. But now they are listening. Now they do believe us. Now they say they’re ready to take action. And now we’re wondering if we didn’t create a monster. We’re wondering if they realize how uncertain our projections of future climate are. We wonder if we’ve oversold the science. We’re wondering what happened to our community, that individuals caveat even the most minor questionings of barely-proven climate change evidence, lest they be tagged as “skeptics.” We’re wondering if we’ve let our alarm at the problem trickle to the public sphere, missing all the caveats in translation that we have internalized. And we’re wondering if we’ve let some of our scientists take the science too far, promise too much knowledge, and promote more certainty in ourselves than is warranted.}

Read it all. Via Iain Murray, who also points to this BBC viewpoint by Mike Hulme, director of the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research;

What has pushed the debate between climate change scientists and climate sceptics to now being between climate change scientists and climate alarmists?
I believe there are three factors now at work.
First, the discourse of catastrophe is a campaigning device being mobilised in the context of failing UK and Kyoto Protocol targets to reduce emissions of carbon dioxide.
The signatories to this UN protocol will not deliver on their obligations. This bursting of the campaigning bubble requires a determined reaction to raise the stakes – the language of climate catastrophe nicely fits the bill.
Hence we now have the militancy of the Stop Climate Chaos activists and the megaphone journalism of the Independent newspaper, with supporting rhetoric from the prime minister and senior government scientists.
Others suggest that the sleeping giants of the Gaian Earth system are being roused from their millennia of slumber to wreck havoc on humanity.
Second, the discourse of catastrophe is a political and rhetorical device to change the frame of reference for the emerging negotiations around what happens when the Kyoto Protocol runs out after 2012.
The Exeter conference of February 2005 on “Avoiding Dangerous Climate Change” served the government’s purposes of softening-up the G8 Gleneagles summit through a frenzied week of “climate change is worse than we thought” news reporting and group-think.
[…]
Third, the discourse of catastrophe allows some space for the retrenchment of science budgets.
It is a short step from claiming these catastrophic risks have physical reality, saliency and are imminent, to implying that one more “big push” of funding will allow science to quantify them objectively.
We need to take a deep breath and pause.

More – The media’s lust for “climate porn”.

Navigation