The Unaccountable Mr. Ritter

From the office of Ag and Wheat Board Minister Chuck Strahl, “regarding the inclusion of the Canadian Wheat Board (CWB) under the Access to Information Act as proposed in Bill C-2, The Federal Accountability Act.”

“Canada’s New Government is seeking greater openness and accountability by bringing bodies such as CWB under the Access to Information Act. The administrative costs of the CWB now amount to almost $70 million annually, and farmers should have a way of scrutinizing those costs.
“Bringing the CWB under the Access to Information Act will not require it to release commercially sensitive information. The Access to Information Act protects information that is commercially sensitive.
“The Deputy Information Commissioner confirmed this in his testimony to a Senate Committee last week, yet the CWB demands to know the reason behind any information request.”

In the interest of fairness, I decided to check out the CWB side of this. As it turns out, Wheat Board Chairman Ken Ritter testified (pdf) before the Senate Standing Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs on Sept. 20. I didn’t get very far before something caught my eye;

The CWB has requested the opportunity to meet with the Standing Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs to discuss the Access to Information provisions of the Federal Accountablility Act and specifically, the amendment that has added our organization to the list of entities designated as “Other Government Agencies” that are subject to the Access to Information Act.
Simply stated, our position is that the CWB does not belong on this list. The reasons for this position are numerous. First of all, the CWB is no longer a government agency. In 1998, the structure of the CWB was changed so that it would be governed by an independent board where 10 of its 15 directors are elected by farmers. I have been chair of that board since its inception. The act that created the new CWB specifically states that it is neither an agent of the Crown nor a crown corporation. The CWB is accountable to the farmers of Western Canada who sell their grain through the CWB. Those farmers, not the taxparyers of Canada, pay the corporation’s operating costs. We do not possess government information nor is our information under the control of the Government of Canada.

You see, just three days ago I happened to write a post directing readers to a different document – a statement of defense by the CWB, on a case before the Federal Court (Renova Holdings Ltd. et al. v. The Canadian Wheat Board);

[3] The Defendants seek to strike out the Statement of Claim on the basis that the Board is accountable only to Parliament and that neither the Board nor the Crown owe any duty to or are accountable to the Plaintiffs as producers of wheat.

One presumes the CWB chairman is held responsible for the content of legal documents presented by the Wheat Board to the courts. One also presumes he was under some sort of obligation to be truthful when he testified before the Senate Committee.
So, Mr. Ritter, which is it? Is the Canadian Wheat Board accountable to Parliament or to farmers? Or, as some are beginning to wonder – would you prefer it be neither?
Update – I’ve been very busy today, so no updates – but as usual, there is excellent discussion in the comments, along with a number of other source links on the CWB.

You Can Make This Stuff Up!

When you’re a Winnipeg Free Press columnist;

Now, columnists frequently use their positions to embarrass some employee of a restaurant, clothing store, airport, or other business that fails to give them the respect they’re sure is due to “a public figure”, as Hansen put it.
But this columnist picked a fight with the wrong patsy.
The Liquor Commission promptly fought back with all guns blazing. Starting with videotape of the incident and following with written statements from people who saw and heard what happened.
Oh Oh.

Reader Tips

A “militant middle class” is beginning to arm itself – in Britain.
Shut down the self-serving advocacy groups, and use the resources for real people who legitimately need help, Signs look good for a Disability Savings Plan idea.
In the world of liberalism, all gods are equal.
A reader from Toronto writes;

Subject: Road Stories – The Homefront CFB Edmonton
I have been disappointed in the inept and biased coverage the CBC has been serving up on the war until LAST NIGHT. For the first time Mansbridge, Brian Stuart and company projected a positive, constructive picture of the mission and the men and women involved.
If you mised the CFB Edmonton “Road Story” you should ping your readership and see if anyone taped it. When Canadian soldiers talk about the mission – they are modest, committed and plain spoken. I know of no other example on MSM (broadcast) where ordinary soldiers from western democracies have been permitted to talk about their work so directly.

And good for them. We need more of this – much more.
Add yours in the comments.
And yes, yesterday was my birthday. Thanks for the kind comments and to those who hit the tip jar. As I’m now officially a year older, I decided it was time to change the little portrait on the sidebar. It was getting a bit dated. Hope you like it!

Choosing Our Senate

G&M

Prime Minister Stephen Harper will introduce a bill calling for a plebiscite on the choice of Senate candidates on Wednesday.
He announced the plan at that morning’s Conservative caucus meeting, and said it will form the next plank in his bid to introduce more accountability to Parliament hill.
“This way the Senate will be more accountable, more credible and more democratic,” Mr. Harper said.
“After a century and-a-half, democracy will finally come to the Senate of Canada.”

Update – Someone please check on Jason Cherniak. I think he’s he’s having a stroke.

Michael J. Fox Was Unavailable For Comment

BBC;

Healthy new-born babies may have been killed in Ukraine to feed a flourishing international trade in stem cells, evidence obtained by the BBC suggests.
Disturbing video footage of post-mortem examinations on dismembered tiny bodies raises serious questions about what happened to them.
Ukraine has become the self-styled stem cell capital of the world.
There is a trade in stem cells from aborted foetuses, amid unproven claims they can help fight many diseases.
But now there are claims that stem cells are also being harvested from live babies.

h/t

Good News Is No News

Rusty Shackleford;

…I decided to run a little experiment. I wrote this post this morning. It includes three stories. The first is the car bombing in Baghdad today. The second is a story about Iraqi Police finding a bomb near the Golden Mosque in Samarra. The third is about Iraqi army forces freeing 23 hostages and capturing or killing some members of the cell.
I consider the deaths of the innocent people in the car bombing, “negative news.” I consider the other two stories “positive news.”
I decided to follow all three today and see just who picked them up and who didn’t.

Bjorn Lomborg

Exerpts from an interview with Bjorn Lomborg, author of The Skeptical Environmentalist: Measuring the Real State of the World;

…I think what is happening now is that we are increasingly seeing a tailspin into hysteria over the global warming discussion, where it is almost commonplace to say things are worse than we thought.
It’s at the stage where people are saying its even worse than we thought yesterday, and that it is going to be catastrophic, and chaotic and disruptive – all these kinds of words. This has actually led to one of the lead modellers in the UK to come out and say it’s bizarre that before we had the debate between the climate change skeptics and the scientists, and that now we have the debate between the scientists, who are now becoming the skeptics, and those who are saying it’s all going to end in chaos, when it is going to do nothing of the sort – and this is not what the UN panel is telling us.
Perhaps this is most clear when you look at the movie from Al Gore. Everything he says is technically true. He says for instance that if Greenland melts, sea levels will rise about 20 feet. This is technically true. But of course the very evocative imagery of seeing Holland disappear under the waves – or New York, or Shanghai – leaves the impression that this is all going to happen very soon. Where in fact the UN climate panel says that the sea level rise over the next 100 years is going to be 30 cm – about 20 times less than he talks about. So there is a dramatic difference between what we’re being told and what we’re actually seeing.
[…]
One of the top climate change economists has modelled – and several papers that came out a couple of weeks ago essentially point out – that climate change will probably mean fewer deaths, not more deaths. It is estimated that climate change by about 2050 will mean about 800,000 fewer deaths.
There is a total lack of a sense of proportion about where we are in terms of the environment but also on non-environmental issues, which is of course what I am looking at now with the Copenhagen Consensus, where we try to look at what are the big issues of the world, and where can we do a lot of good, and where can we do a little good. And the bottom line is there are many problems in the world where we can do much more at much lower cost. So presumably, if our goal is to help people, then there are many other things we should do first. If our goal is to help the environment, then there are also many other things we can do first.

Reader Tips

From “pack journalism” to “social orthodoxy” to an “exaggerated tendency toward pessimism”, a Pulitzer-prize winning journalist , and Chairman of Dow Jones says “The Media Is in Need of Some Mending”.
As it turns out, Associated Press has been in the fantasy news business for a long time.
Kofi Annan, translated.

Blah blah blah blah blah, blah blah blah. Sometimes I just like talking. It sounds good, don’t you agree? Here’s a sack of flour, dirty tragic dying person. Someone will be around to study your plight shortly.

Top 10 things Stephane Dion has done for Kyoto.
And don’t forget to vote in the Weblog Awards!
Add your own in the comments.

CPAC Viewers And Opposition Members

From the comments;

CPAC is right this moment carrying the [Canadian Wheat Board] debate in The House on this subject.
In fact Carol Skelton,MP from Saskatchewan suggested that the opposition members go to Small Dead Animals blog and search out the comments.
She made special mention of Larry Webber[sic].

For ease of navigation, click here for a direct link to that discussion.
While you’re here, I recommend you read this one as well, regarding a CWB statement before the Federal court that “the Board is accountable only to Parliament”.

Some Murderous Dictators Are More Equal Than Others

Exhibit A

Cuba’s Revolutionary Armed Forces, which replaced the military that existed before the Cuban Revolution, traces its roots to Dec. 2, 1956, when 82 rebels landed on the island on a yacht — the Granma — that sailed from Mexico.
The Castro brothers were among fewer than two dozen rebels who survived the landing to reach the mountains, where they launched a guerrilla war against then-president Fulgencio Batista. Their revolution triumphed on Jan. 1, 1959.
Fidel Castro purportedly sent a message to those celebrating his birthday earlier this week, telling a crowd of 5,000 supporters at the opening event Tuesday at a Havana theatre that he was too sick to meet with them.
“I direct myself to you, intellectuals and prestigious personalities of the world, with a dilemma,” said a note read at the event. “I could not meet with you in a small locale, only in the Karl Marx Theater where all the visitors would fit, and I was not yet in condition, according to the doctors, to face such a colossal encounter.”
More than 1,300 politicians, artists and intellectuals from around the globe were attending the tribute to the man who has governed Cuba for 47 years, including Bolivian President Evo Morales, Haitian President Rene Preval and Colombian Nobel laureate Gabriel Garcia Marquez.

Noticably absent: any mention of repression, disappearances, political prisoners, jailed journalists, the shattered economy of Cuba.
Exhibit B

He had been taken to a military hospital in Santiago early Sunday after suffering an “acute heart attack” and a buildup of fluid on his lungs, his son, Marco Antonio Pinochet, told reporters.
“We are now in the hands of God and of the doctors. My father is in very bad condition,” Marco Antonio Pinochet, said earlier.
He said that doctors “virtually rescued” his father from death by performing an angioplasty to clear his arteries.
Pinochet has used a pacemaker for several years and was diagnosed with mild dementia caused by several strokes. He also suffers from diabetes and arthritis.
In the past, he has been deemed too ill to stand trial on charges of murder and kidnapping.
Last week, he was indicted and ordered to remain under house arrest for the execution of two bodyguards of Salvador Allende, the freely elected socialist president who was toppled in a 1973 coup that brought Pinochet to power.
Around 3,000 people were reported missing or killed and some 28,000 were tortured during Pinochet’s rule in Chile, which lasted until 1990, when Pinochet transferred power to a democratically elected president.
He marked his birthday last week by issuing a statement in which he accepted “political responsibility” for abuses committed by his regime.

The Washington Post has noticed the Dictator’s Double Standard;

Like it or not, Mr. Pinochet had something to do with this success. To the dismay of every economic minister in Latin America, he introduced the free-market policies that produced the Chilean economic miracle — and that not even Allende’s socialist successors have dared reverse. He also accepted a transition to democracy, stepping down peacefully in 1990 after losing a referendum.
By way of contrast, Fidel Castro — Mr. Pinochet’s nemesis and a hero to many in Latin America and beyond — will leave behind an economically ruined and freedomless country with his approaching death. Mr. Castro also killed and exiled thousands. But even when it became obvious that his communist economic system had impoverished his country, he refused to abandon that system: He spent the last years of his rule reversing a partial liberalization. To the end he also imprisoned or persecuted anyone who suggested Cubans could benefit from freedom of speech or the right to vote.
The contrast between Cuba and Chile more than 30 years after Mr. Pinochet’s coup is a reminder of a famous essay written by Jeane J. Kirkpatrick, the provocative and energetic scholar and U.S. ambassador to the United Nations who died Thursday. In “Dictatorships and Double Standards,” a work that caught the eye of President Ronald Reagan, Ms. Kirkpatrick argued that right-wing dictators such as Mr. Pinochet were ultimately less malign than communist rulers, in part because their regimes were more likely to pave the way for liberal democracies. She, too, was vilified by the left. Yet by now it should be obvious: She was right.

War Report

I have a round-up of good pieces by milbloggers to share this morning, touching on a variety of related topics.
Smash is there to say goodbye to Rummy;

Donald Rumsfeld is not universally loved in the Pentagon. I’m told that he can be a tough, stubborn, and demanding boss. Rumsfeld is infamous for firing off short memos — known colloquially as “snowflakes” — asking next-to-impossible-to-answer questions or demanding revolutionary changes. He came to the building in 2001, promising to transform the Department of Defense from a Cold War force to a more flexible, agile military, better prepared to face the challenges of the Twenty-first Century. Almost six years later, that transformation is well underway, but not yet complete. Along the way, Rumsfeld has stepped on many toes, and slaughtered many sacred cows. Inevitably, he made some enemies, especially among the senior officers and long-serving bureaucrats who were heavily invested in the “old way” of doing things.
But the troops, and a solid majority of the officers, love him. This is abundantly clear from the warm reception Rumsfeld receives as he walks up to the podium.

Josh Manchester from Adventures of Chester advises that for media, the times may be a-changing;

The Standard Narrative goes something like this: There is a massive deployment of US forces to the far side of the world. This action is more or less just and warranted. The troops charge into battle, sometimes many battles. All the while, there’s an understanding everywhere of an end-state – a point at which the war’s goals will have been accomplished and then, most importantly, everyone can come home.

Bill Roggio reports on the Information War, Eastern Front;

The information front in the Long War is perhaps the war’s most vital. And it is one front where the West is perceived as losing. While Coalition forces and Middle Eastern allies face shadowy transnational terrorist organizations such as al-Qaeda and its affiliates on the battlefields of Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan and elsewhere, the battle for hearts and minds is being fought on the Internet, print, cable and satellite television, and other forms of media. In Iraq, the al-Zawraa satellite television network is broadcasting insurgent propaganda 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

Small victories and new allies in Iraq;

It all began almost a month ago. A local sheik came to the Army unit in charge of the sector he lived in, announced his desire to fight the insurgents, and asked for help in doing so.

You’re invited to share other milblogger links I’ve missed in the comments.

Anybody Seen Allan Blakeney Lately?

$20bn gas project seized by Russia;

Shell is being forced by the Russian government to hand over its controlling stake in the world’s biggest liquefied gas project, provoking fresh fears about the Kremlin’s willingness to use the country’s growing strength in natural resources as a political weapon.
After months of relentless pressure from Moscow, the Anglo-Dutch company has to cut its stake in the $20bn Sakhalin-2 scheme in the far east of Russia in favour of the state-owned energy group Gazprom.
The Russian authorities are also threatening BP over alleged environmental violations on a Siberian field in what is seen as a wider attempt to seize back assets handed over to foreign companies when energy prices were low.

*

Pussy Diplomacy

Armed Liberal;

Over at HuffPo, Alec Baldwin, (of the “Film Actors Guild”) speaks out on what’s wrong [in the war to defeat Arab terrorism], and what we need to do about it. One of these is real, and one is a line from a puppet movie*. Can you tell which is which?

Andy McCarthy on more dangerous fools;

ISG Chairman James Baker, a foolish man, looked Congress in the eye on Thursday and explained his master plan. Did it seem foolish to propose negotiations with Iran, our relentless enemy? Sure. But, the “realist” doyen puttered, if we invite them to negotiate about Iraq’s future, and they demur, why, we’ll expose their intransigence for all the world to see.
Right. They slaughter and abet the slaughter of our marines, our airmen, our sailors, William Buckley, Robert Stethem, William Higgins, and countless others. They tell us their defining goal is a world without America, a world in which our allies are wiped from the face of the earth. But, at long last, we’ll know who they really are … if they don’t show up for a meeting.

Politics and Grain: 2006 Canadian Wheat Board Election

Larry Weber, from Weber Commodities;

The CWB Election is in the books for 2006. Four candidates for the single desk emerged victorious with one candidate for pro choice winning the other seat. It is apparent that fear and rhetoric are alive and well in western Canada but one must respect the voters who did manage to take the time and mail their ballot in.
If this was only a vote on the single desk and that is what it will be portrayed as, the break out will look like this: District 1 at 56.4% in for a choice candidate with 43.6% for the single desk. District 3 was 66.2% in favour of single desk versus 33.8% for pro choice. In District 5, 59.2% voted for single desk while 40.8% voted for choice while in district 7, 55% voted for the single desk and 45% voted for pro choice. In the Manitoba District 9, 65.9% voted for the single desk, while 34.1% voted for choice.
The former Canadian Agriculture minister, the Hon. Otto Lang was on my radio program on the weekend. It was apparent that nothing has changed in farm policy debates. In 1974, when he wanted to change the CROW rate, the resistance to change was so strong that he backed away. He also said on the weekend that his biggest regret was not following through on the Crow change. The number that he used on the weekend in 1974 was a $7 billion dollar payout. It had Cabinet approval.
The fear mongering continued for 20 years – rhetoric flew, and farmers ended up with $1.3 Billion dollars. Because farmers were lied to by farm groups, corporations who were not ready for change, it cost farmers monumentally. The dollar amount is bad enough; however, it was 25 lost years that hurt the western Canadian economy the most.
The Western Producer of the day, the NFU, the Pools, WAYNE EASTER was the President of the NFU from 1982-1993 all said that it could not change, but it did. Wayne Easter fought vigorously to oppose the payout of the CROW and WGTA. Otto said on the weekend that the after a change he made to quota allocations in the 70’s the NFU issued buttons that said Otto Lang is 4 letter words (I’ve also seen one that said HANG LANG) and that the NFU was going on and on about he was going to kill the family farm. Nothing has changed.
Enter the Pools. Otto said the CROW had become sacred. So much so that people forgot where it came from and what it represented. Media can do that. Organizations with ulterior motives can do that. And today when Wayne Easter stands with the Leader of the Opposition and the President of the CWB, everyone forgets what he did to the western economy. For the majority of farmers, it is like nothing happened and all is forgotten.
A line that I like and use is this: Those who do not study history are bound to repeat it.
The next time you see a politician, elected official or organization standing up for farmers, please ask yourself three questions:
1) What proof do they have to take that position?
2) What is in it for them?
3) Does this sound like the CROW/WGTA debate?
For half of the CWB districts, you had a vote on nothing but rhetoric and fear. And the rhetoric came from both sides. Demand better. Demand proof. Demand accountability. You are the CEO of your farm. You would not make a decision to buy anything without facts. You are accountable to your family who are your shareholders.
Remember the only one that is looking after you is you – no one else gives a damn. And if you ever want a refresher – take a look at the CROW/WGTA debate.
Ken Beswick, the now deceased former Commissioner of the CWB, may have been right. This industry does deserve itself.

Larry hosts a weekend agricultural radio program that’s both informational and highly entertaining. He can be reached by email here.

Navigation