John Robson of the Ottawa Citizen (a true conservative, that rare breed in Canadian journalism) answers the question:
Toxic commentary about toxic commentary
The irony in commentary about toxic American political rhetoric after Arizona congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords was shot is how toxic the commentary is. If the American right really had a particular penchant for murderous language and ideas it would be important to say it. But it’s just not true.
In one sense it doesn’t matter because the suspect, Jared Lee Loughner, appears to be insane. But if we are going there, let’s go the full distance: He appears to be an atheist Nietzschean enthusiast for the Communist Manifesto whose obsession with language resembles the PC fixation on “privileged discourse.” So let’s try to stick to the facts.
On Monday’s Citizen front page Andrew Cohen wrote “the Tea Party, as agents of a contagion of right-wing extremism in the United States, have helped create a climate of paranoia that has alarmed observers. … The political discourse has been seriously deteriorating since the presidential campaign of 2008. … Anxiety and fear are not new in the United States. Richard Hofstadter identified these undercurrents in a provocative essay called ‘The Paranoid Style in American Politics.’ [article with that title here]” Yes. And as a good progressive, Hofstadter pinned it on the right. I’m not sure American political paranoia is a problem compared to, say, the Middle East with its Mossad sharks and vultures. But I do know alarming rhetoric in the U.S. comes mostly from the left…
Read on. And listen to the audio at Mr Robson’s website of him talking this morning along similar lines with Steve Madely on CFRA Ottawa.
Update: Related:
Stop Target in Canada!
Upperdate: And how come people aren’t railing against the gun culture of the Swiss and Finns (next page at the link)?
…
In 2001, there were about 600,000 automatic rifles and 500,000 pistols kept in Swiss homes [population some 7.5 million]. There are few restrictions on the buying of weapons, and the government even sells off its surplus to citizens when new models are purchased. Many Swiss belong to shooting clubs, and marksmanship competitions are popular activities. A number of cantons have laws against carrying guns without a permit, but it’s not unusual to see off-duty reservists toting their assault rifles in public…




