Well, I guess we’re all taking turns at evaluating the circumstances of the sad death of Tom Fox in Iraq (see here and here).
So here’s my take on it. My beef is with the Christian Peacemaker Teams. Not in that they sent people into a dangerous area resulting in a death. But in that for their insistence on using the label of “Christian”, they seem to be behaving in a distinctly un-Christian manner.
They seem to have confused “turn the other cheeck” with “turning a blind eye”. They can call themselves teams, or even peacemaking teams. But Christian? That’s a tough sell for me.
Open Thread on Christian Peacemaker Teams
Richard took offense at my “stern warning against dissenting opinion” – I just thought it was common decency I was asking for, but apparently that’s left-libbish. Whoda thunk it?
So, here’s a forum for venting on the wisdom (or lack thereof) of Christian Peacemaker Teams policies, beliefs, actions, whatever your heart desires.
I’ll start you off with an excerpt of Richard’s post (which turns out to be an excerpt of an earlier post):
“Are the … terrorists going to be true to their demands and give us some new beheading videos?(edited per requests in comments)
If this happens, what does it do to the morale of the MoonBat population? Surely having some of their own slaughtered like animals will give them a different perspective no? Will they ignore it and carry on with their anti-war efforts anyway? It would seem to me personally that having the terrorist sand-monkeys follow through on their promise would go a long way in uniting the resolve of North Americans to seeing this adventure through. But I’m not a moonbat who’s willing to ignore facts so I can’t say for sure.”
Have at ‘er
UPDATE: Link to CPT site provided.
UPDATE #2: Arabian Dissent has his say.
American Christian Peacemaker found dead in Iraq
The body of Tom Fox was found in Baghdad today. There is no mention of time of death, but perhaps we now know why he was missing from the video. Forensics will be done in the US as to time & cause of death.
I certainly admire him for having the courage to stand up for his convictions, and extend my condolences to his family & friends.
And here’s hoping that the remaining hostages will be found alive soon.
crossposted at Waking Up On Planet X
UPDATE: As a guest blogger but frequent commenter, I admit to questioning the wisdom of posting this on SDA. If people are going to go on the attack on a post intended to bring to light the distressing news of a dead hostage, and what that may or may not mean for the fate of other hostages, and without regard to just WHO might google & find this site (like family) that would be hurt beyond belief by said attacks, I will either turn the comments off for this post so that the information is available, or delete it.
Conservative bloggers like to believe that they would never stoop to the levels that can be seen on progressive-blogs-that-shall-not-be-named. Here is an opportunity to prove it.
Mt. Vernon
Well, all I can say is that Charlotte, NC is one hell of a long way from Delisle. Made it as far as Mt.Vernon, Ill. Just a few hours left in this marathon… until it’s time to drive home. (In case you’re wondering why i didn ‘t fly – multiple dogs and airplane travel don’t mix well..)
Looks like the kids are holding down the fort nicely. Which is good, as I haven’t the energy to do much more than read this evening.
UPDATE – except for this;
A motorist was trapped in his car driving at almost 130mph for 60 miles after the accelerator jammed.
Kevin Nicolle, 25, was unable to stop the automatic BMW going at top speed after the malfunction on the A1.
Kevin Nicolle: ‘I couldn’t get the pedal off the floor’ His terrifying journey, which was followed by four police cars and a helicopter, ended when he smashed the car into a roundabout, flipping it on its roof.
What?
WHAT?
This twit (and it’s not the first time stories like this have come across the wire) needs his license suspended – not for the mechanical failure, but for not knowing how to find neutral orhow to drive without power steering. Holy crap, it’s disturbing to think there are people out there with such a total lack of emergency driving skills.
And yes, I’ve been in that situation – more often than I can remember. I used to own a Ford Bronco that suffered a frozen accelerator at random intervals every time the weather got cold. My ’65 Mustang pulled the trick on me a couple of times. The problem with a this particular type of mechanical failure isn’t “how to stop”, it’s how to manage the problem until you can pull into somewhere you can get it fixed. Of course, that’s just me.
I think of the situations I’ve found myself in – navigating Tower Junction Pass in Yellowstone Park in a heavily loaded Chev propane van without power brakes, the night I kicked the dimmer switch on my 65 ‘Stang doing 65 mpg on a gravel road only to have the headlights cut out completely, lots of blown tires. Why don’t they teach people the easy stuff like driving to the side of the road with the engine cut?
Freedom of Screech
Parliamentary Press Gang
As a guest blogger I shouldn�t go over ground already covered by Kate, but like most bloggers, I tend to be a loud mouth schnook� so here goes. A while back, HERE and HERE for that matter, it was pointed out that the Parliamentary Press in Canada were more or less whining cry babies who needed their wings trimmed a notch or two. What seems to have been missed are the subtle details of how the Parliamentary Press Corp. gather news; their sophisticated nuances, their intellectual prowess; and their shrewd capabilities of sharing with us, the simpleminded masses, what actually goes on in the corridors of power.
To better understand just how the system works� or rather used to work, we�ve taken the liberty at Celestial Junk to educate our readers on the finer details of the art of being a Parliamentary Press Journalist in the �traditional� sense. Sadly, a �tradition� that the PMO just may have destroyed forever. CLICK
In all seriousness though, here’s the rub:
The PMO wants journalists to submit questions in writing. The PMO and ministers then answer questions in an orderly fashion, BUT, the PMO gets to choose which questions are answered and which are ignored.
In the old format, the press either mobbed the PM or the minister; or, chose who got to ask the questions. For example, somebody, somewhere, decided that “Sir, do you love the country?” was a fair question.
Here’s how Paul Martin used to deal with unwanted questions in the old “scrum” format.
“That’s a very good questions, but what Canadians should be asking themselves is..”
He’d then go on to reframe the question, and answer his own question. The dopes in the media let him get away with it, and even printed his answers as if they had asked the question in the first place.
And finally, the last time I checked the Parliamentary press were very good at “creating” their own issues from thin air. Who needs to ask questions of the PMO? Give the gumshoes an obscure phrase or two and and they’ll turn it into a national crisis by morning.
At least the Harper way of doing business may add some order, decorum, and respect, to the house.
THE SHEAF BJ JESUS CARTOONIST SPEAKS
The Saskatoon Star Phoenix printed on Saturday the formal response of the Capitalist Piglet cartoonist, Jeff MacDonald, to the outrage his brilliant little piece of art caused.
He said that people should get off their “Inquisition-esque high horses… After all, people, I’m sure Jesus had a sense of humour… Capitalist Piglet… is not just shock comic. It is an important message.” He claimed that the cartoon was supposed to “expose” the double standard of Christians who were not offended by the printing of the Mohammad cartoons. CLICK
Right Jeff! We’ll be looking for your name on the New York Times editorial board some day. You’re just the kind of unapologetic glory-monger they like. At least he doesn’t have to worry that riots, head-hacking, flag-burnings, and all around general Jihad will be carried out because of him.
For Kate’s coverage of the issue: CLICK
Help counter The Mother That Roars
I guess she’s not getting enough attention in the US anymore, so she’s doing a roadshow. Or is she? Shame? Her? I find that hard to believe, but apparently she won’t be showing up, although her friends say they will.
Or will they?
“The snow started early Friday morning. Road conditions on post went from Amber, to Red, and finally to Black. Luckily I had arrived in Kaiserslautern the night before.
When conditions are Black, all non-essential personnel are sent home and the buses from Kleber to the hospital and the PXs stop running.”
I have no idea of the layout, so don’t know if it will affect the demonstrations. So what can we do? We can put a comment in encouraging them, that’s what we can do. Don’t know what to say? A simple “ignore the moonbats” would probably suffice, but feel free to pontificate.
UPDATE: It’s the middle of the night there, so although I’ve sent an email about the “Spam Blocker” (?), you can still get to the links by clicking on the highlighted “bypass this message”
Life in Afghanistan
If you’re like me, you’ve been wondering what our soldiers have to say about any number of things, but particularly about the mission itself – it’s purpose(s), it’s challenges, it’s rewards & it’s heartbreaks.
I stumbled across Dave’s blog a few weeks ago while surfing (I’d hat tip someone, but I forget how I clicked through to him), and bookmarked it for that very reason. The comments are moderated (good call!) so won’t show up until they’ve been checked for stupidity, but I highly recommend you stop by regularly for updates.
His current post is brilliant (he’s apparently working on a rebuttal to the buttheads that think we should bail, I’m looking forward to that) and explains the intricacies of the Afghan culture. It’s a response to an email asking whether sending him pencils for schoolchildren was a good idea. Here’s a sample:
“…But let me tell you about other factors that you�re probably not aware of.
Afghanistan is peopled by many different cultures. In the north live Tajiks, Uzbeks, and Turkmen. In the middle of the country, there are the Hazara, possibly the descendants of Ghengiz Khan�s Mongol Horde, Nuristanis, and Baloch. And in the south, there are the Pashtuns. Ethnic divisions are not clear-cut – nothing is in Afghanistan – and sizable populations of Tajiks live in the south and Pashtuns in the centre and so on. But each province has its ethnic makeup, and in Kandahar, like in Waziristan across the Pakistani border, the Pashtuns predominate.
Pashtuns form the largest tribal society in the Islamic world. They view themselves as the natural leaders of Afghanistan, and despise peoples like the Hazara as a sort of underclass. Their relations with one another are dominated by a tribal code called pashtunwali, which values above all honour, hospitality, loyalty, bravery, revenge, and fierce individualism. This code has some pretty inexplicable facets – it is perfectly acceptable under pashtunwali, for example, to change sides in the middle of a battle for a bribe. You don�t have to understand it, but if you are doing business here you have to deal with it.
Pashtuns are hardly monolithic either. One is not simply a Pashtun, one is a Durrani or a Ghilzai; and one is not simply a Ghilzai or a Durrani, one is a Popolzai or a Barakzai or an Alikozai or an Ishaqzai Durrani Pashtun, or a member of one of dozens of other tribes. It doesn�t end there; families come next. And it is a vast understatement to call the interrelationships complex. Don�t try building a road through a Barakzai area using Alikozai labour, unless the Barakzai of that area have just concluded an agreement with the Alikozai families. And be prepared for it all to go pear-shaped in a heartbeat, for reasons you will never fully understand…”
Go read the whole thing. It’s fascinating.
Paul Martin — best forgotten?
Best forgotten. That seems to be the policy at the Liberal Party website. Check out his official biography. It never mentions anything after the leadership race of November 2003. In fact, it doesn’t even mention that he won the race in November 2003.
Remember how they said Paul Martin’s tenure as prime minister would be relegated to a footnote? Looks like if the Liberal Party has its way, he’d be lucky to have footnote.
All the details are at Angry in the Great White North.
Why we are in Afghanistan
The Galloping Beaver has a great post that explains, in detail, the timelines and FACTS around how we ended up in Afghanistan, and more to the point, why we have to STAY.
“…If Canada were to suddenly withdraw because Canadians at home are getting squeamish, those who would have us do that should be aware that Canada would be forever viewed as an unreliable ally; not by the US, but by NATO. Canada relies on collective defence treaties to keep defence affordable. Withdrawl would result in no treaties, no collective defence and a huge price to pay in going it alone…”
It’s also cross-posted at The Torch.
UPDATE: Ooops, I forgot to h/t Cerebrus. Sorry about that.
Mini Roundup
I have WAY too much going on in my life this week, including planning for a second night of torture. So, here’s a mini-roundup:
For amusement purposes, I have to ask, wtf are the other provinces doing? Is this pandemic targetted at Quebec-only? Only bilinguals need worry? That’s a pretty discriminating bug! The Bloc will not be pleased.
YAY for everyone who chipped in and BOO to those who think we should bail.
GG Jean: Well, preferring a donation to a shelter instead of a gift, she seems to be a bit less of a spendthrift than our last one. However, her budget to date hasn’t been published, so I’ll reserve judgement for now.
And as Dad used to say, Good night, & don’t let the bedbugs bite.
cross-posted at Waking Up on Planet X
Road Buzz And Random Stuff
Sitting in a hotel room in Sioux Falls, SD. It’s really very warm here – one doesn’t have to go very far south at this time of year to get away from the snow. After weighing the alternatives, i opted to avoid the traffic snarls of Minneapolis and Chicago and took a more western route. Very pleasant drive, light traffic and was able to pick up Rush. I even coaxed the truck up to around 15 mpg, so I’m in a good mood. (It’s a 2100 mile one way drive – do the math)
The hot news story here is the new law criminalizing abortion in the state. Apparently “women are going die” due to the anticipated proliferation of “back street abortions” – (having never been told, apparently, that there are highways leading out of the state.)
Oh well. Opening that debate is not the intention of this post, so let’s not go there.
The ongoing saga of the ports deal is eating up a lot of air time nationally. (Go Halliburton!) The more one finds out about this controversy, the more appropriate Limbaugh’s phrase “drive-by media” becomes when understanding what’s really going on. That, and election year politics.
On to a few links –
Michael Totten sent the following by email;
This time I went to one of the villages formerly occupied by Ansar Al Islam (Al Qaeda in Northern Iraq). Abu Musab al Zarqawi was there, too, and the residents of that village had some interesting things to say that many Westerners have probably never heard.
Read it here
Oh, that liberal media… these little photo stunts are getting to be quite the habit…
Montreal Gazette – “There have been 160 or so floor-crossings in Canadian parliamentary history, several of which have led to cabinet. This is the first to lead to an ethics witch-hunt”.
Now, I’m going to relax with a Killians.
What’s Your Limit?
The headline reads, “Canadians Head out to Hunt Down Taliban!” It all begs the question, just how much will Canadians tolerate as far as casualties? How much will you tolerate? And, if you have family in the forces, or are in the forces yourself, how many KIA and WIA are you willing to put up with before the cost of keeping Afghanistan free of the Islamist threat becomes too high?
My personal feeling is that no place in the world today is “too far” away. 911 was hatched in Afghanistan, and any region of the world ruled by fanatics can become the incubator for tragedy right here in Canada. I view the issue in terms of winning and losing. You go in to win; period. I view each injury and death as a sacrifice for the freedom of Afghan children and my children. But then, that’s just me.
Another thought you may want to consider is this. Canada only has 33 million or so people. Every soldier we lose to injury or death, is equivalent to 11 or so in the United States as a percentage of population. When you look at it like that, our cost in Afghanistan has already been high.
For those of you unfamiliar with Canadian Armed Forces readiness, you may want to try this LINK. Cjunk did a series a while back on the equipment readiness of our forces. (warning, it’s a long read) Keep in mind that even the best equiped, best trained, best armed force in the world has lost over one thousand men and women in Iraq.
So, what’s your limit?
UPDATE:
In related news: click
Some are suggesting that by even being “over there” we create more terrorists. For an interesting read on the topic, you may want to try THIS.
Doing It on the Carpet
It’s that time of year again. The Golden Globes, The Oscars, The Grammys; you name it. Cjunk takes you to the biggest show of them all…
Good evening everyone, I�m Ben Mulroney, with co-hosts Joan Rivers and Mary Hart, and THIS is the Red Carpet pre-show for the 10th annual Bin-Cademy Film Awards. Welcome to beautiful sunny Tehran, and welcome to THE LADENS!
The Other Culture Of Entitlement, Con’t
Harper takes the Other Culture Of Entitlement down a flight – Politics Watch;
The Parliamentary Press Gallery is accusing the Prime Minister’s Office of impeding the freedom of the press to access decision makers after a decision to move the location for scrums with cabinet ministers.
What I said.
Quid And Quo
A reader with legal credentials offers the following thoughts on the Shapiro investigation into the appointment of David Emerson to cabinet;
Bernard Shapiro seems to have a limited understanding of how our parliamentary system works. As I understand it, he wants to investigate the appointment of David Emerson to Cabinet apparently on the theory that Emerson may have been induced to support the government by the offer of a Cabinet post.
Under our system, Cabinet is jointly responsible for its decisions. There is no such thing as the House having confidence in some but not all of the members of Cabinet. Her Majesty�s Ministers have the confidence of the House as a group or not at all. Being a member of Cabinet means supporting the government in the House � a Minister who cannot support government policy must resign.
What this means is, if Stephen Harper believes that his Cabinet should include representation from Canada�s larger urban centers and offers a post to David Emerson, the very thing that Emerson is offered implies an obligation to support the government in the House. A cabinet post offered in order to have a particular MP in Cabinet isn�t a quid pro quo, something given in exchange for the MP’s support of the government.
Emerson is asked to become a member of Cabinet because of the segment of Canada he represents, a qualification that no one elected as a Conservative could claim. In this circumstance quid (becoming a member of Cabinet) and quo (undertaking the obligations of a Minister) are one and the same.
Contrast Belinda Stronach. In her particular circumstances, quid and quo are easily distinguishable. Paul Martin needed another vote to withstand a confidence motion and got it by offering a Cabinet post to an MP with no distinguishing qualifications either for Cabinet or for the particular ministry to which she was appointed.
Mr. Shapiro�s decision to investigate the Emerson appointment but not the Stronach appointment shows he just doesn�t get things he needs to get to do his job properly.
Worse, he contributes to a political culture where people can�t tell the difference between a Prime Minister who offers a Cabinet post to someone he wants in Cabinet from a Prime Minister who traffics in Cabinet positions to retain power.
On The Road Again
I’m heading out later today on a 2 week trip (North Carolina, Kentucky), and while I expect to be checking in from time to time, my guest bloggers will be picking up the slack. In the meanwhile, be sure to expand your horizons and check out the many fine blogs on the sidebar!
Open thread, and readers tips in the comments.
Capitalist Piglet – Who’s Suckling Whom?
Since breaking the Capitalist Pig cartoon story on March 3rd, the original thread has now run into the hundreds of comments. (And now it’s been linked at Fark) It’s time to update the post, if only to give the discussion a fresh start.
Pressure is still on theSheaf – local media isn’t letting the story go. The Saskatchewan Human Rights commission has received a number of complaints and will decide what to do by months end. FWIW, I think that’s going too far – but then, in my perfect world, these extra-legal, unaccountable thought policing bodies wouldn’t exist n the first place. Though, I’m just twisted enough to enjoy the show of a far-left commission facing hatemongering from “one of their own”. But that’s a topic for another day.
One comment (there are many good ones) did catch my eye, and I’ll reproduce it here – commentor “Karl” replies to “Chad”‘
You wrote: “The cartoon is showing the Christianity and Capitalism/consumerism go hand in hand.”
Actually, it seemed to be showing Christianity and Capitalism/Consumerism going dick in mouth. If he had wanted to convey “hand in hand”, he could have drawn them holding hands. The point (innane though it is) would have been made, and no one would have been offended by the vulgarity of it. Jesus did not need to be made out to be a homosexual with zoophilic tendencies. And Christians need not be told that we are somehow the immature ones for being offended at an image of our Lord performing fellatio on a pig.
You went on:“How is that not true? Has anyone noticed that Xmas is more about a fat guy wearing red than christ’s birth? What about easter? A rabbit that lays eggs.”
As a pastor I can tell you that there is no group who is more critical of this trend than Christians. Have you not noticed all of the ‘keep the Christ in Christmas’ stuff? Have you not noticed that it is non religious people who continually want ‘holiday trees’ and the non specific ‘happy holidays’ greetings rather than ‘merry Christmas’? Have you not seen that non religious people are the ones who insist upon the consumerist non-Christian holiday of sentimentality, greed and gluttony that Christmas has become?? I say non religious, because in my experience, non Christian religious people (eg Muslims, Jews, Hindus) have no problem with Christmas. The ones who have the problem are those of ‘Christian Stock’ who put on airs of sophisticated athiesm, or groovy non sprecific spirituality which means anything, and nothing. Thye claim to be above Christianity, but really they are obcessed with it, blaming it for all of society’s ills, for every tragedy and travesty, and no doubt for their acne as well. To blame Christianity for the bastardization of Christmas is laughable!! If you feel so strongly about it, why don’t you ‘stick it to the man’ by letting your employer know that you are available to work on December 24th and 25th. And don’t buy anybody any presents. Don’t accept any either. Don’t visit family. Refuse that Christmas bonus. And might I suggest a protest fast on the 25th. For myself, I’ll do what I always do on Christmas. Preach the Word, administer Holy Communion, and later that day, break my Advent fast as I feast with my family in celebration of the Nativity of my Lord.
You continued: “I think Christianity has turned became a thing of social status. I find this mind blowing because Jesus preached about doing the exact opposite of this.”
I would find this mind blowing too, if it were true. Perhaps it was once, but the ’70’s are a long time ago. I wear my clerical collar in public quite a lot. I can relate well to the goths, because I get as many hostile stares. (and they seem to like to dress in black as much as I do). Think about it man!!! Stockwell Day was vilified for his Christian beliefs (remember the ‘How Scary’ McLeans cover?). Christians are regularily ridiculed for their beliefs. If we were looking for worldly status, we would be trying out for Canadian Idol, not living as Christians.
I was offended by the cartoon, and I don’t buy the argument that I am missing some deeper meaning. To me it is a sophmoric neo marxist interpretation of religion and its relationship to capitalism which was already past its expiry date some 20 years ago, and is only currently alive in the never never land of tenured political science chairs occupied by professors who are still a little miffed that revolution they boldly predicted some 40 years ago never came to pass. And how their young sheep bleat!!
Nicely done, I thought.
Now, time to take this issue down another tangent – so far the controversy has been limited to the offense given to Christians. That raises an interesting, and as yet, unasked question – When are the cartoonists going to be called on the carpet to explain the hatred directed at so-called “capitalists”?
The premise that “capitalism=bad” and that any group, any individual, any religion should have to disassociate themselves from business to attain moral purity is an intellectual embarrassment to begin with. But the cartoon goes one step further – in choosing a pig to represent the businessman, they have chosen the time honored progaganda tool of dehumanization.
That these small-minded refugees of Marxism are receiving a heavily subsidized education at an institution funded by tax revenues generated in large part by the very “capitalists” they would portray as pigs, just adds injury to insult.
Instead of hauling them before the Human Rights Commission, or calling for a wholesale purge at the Sheaf. I’d suggest a not-so-gentle push towards a little moral purity of their own – by removing the stench of “capitalism/consumerism” from their university education. Allow the enlightened to demonstrate the courage of their left-wing convictions. Present them with an invoice for the total cost of their education to date, adjust tuition to cover 100% of the costs, and cut off of any tax-funded student loans.
Something tells me the artist Y!th and his defenders at the U of S would find that a little too hard to swallow.
Kateastrophe
We broke the frog.
Reader Tips
As you may have surmised, it’s been another busy day, beginning with an early morning drive 30 miles on sheer ice. All the semis were pulled over – or in the ditch. On one curve near Vanscoy, Sk several had attempted to navigate a corner only to slide sideways across the oncoming lane and against the ditch on the opposite side of the highway. There must have been nearly a dozen stalled there.
Anyways, the day’s not over yet – I’m waiting for clear to bake on a couple of motorcycle helmets, so a few quick tips and you can add your own in the comments.
Oh, Scotty what have you done?
Harper isn’t playing Shapiro’s game. Good for him. Stephen Taylor has a couple of good posts up on the issue.
Soft Europe, soft Canada.
I’m sure there are others waiting in my mail bin – haven’t had time to check.
Barbura Streyesand
TRUTH ALERT: IN RESPONSE TO DRUDGE REPORT STORY ABOUT MISSPELLINGS IN MEMO.
