I wrote a note last week to a talk radio host after he finished an interview with the pro-naptime-in-the-workplace activist whose been making the rounds;
I think someone should pull all these studies together that extrapolate “lost productivity” figures and total them up.
I suspect we’ll discover that we no longer have an economy at all.
NYT Public Editor Daniel Orkent;
One of the appealing things about the complaints I receive about innumeracy at The Times is their ecumenical origin; when it comes to how it handles numbers, The Times is an equal opportunity offender. Like a bad cough that spreads its germs indiscriminately, numbers misapplied and ill-explained irritate the sensibilities of the right and the left, the drug company official and the animal rights activist, the art collector and the Jets fan.
Number fumbling arises, I believe, not from mendacity but from laziness, carelessness or lack of comprehension. I’ll put myself in the latter category (as some readers no doubt will as well, after they’ve read through my representation of the numbers that follow). Most of the journalists I know who enter the profession comfortable with numbers write about sports, where debate about the meaning of statistics is a daily competition, or economics, a field in which interpretation of numbers will no more likely produce inarguable results than will finger painting.
[…]
Numbers issued by those measuring criminal enterprise (“In Mexico, drug trafficking is a $250-billion-a-year industry” [story]) or the economic impact of a new stadium (“Bloomberg said that he expected the arena to generate about $400 million a year through various economic activities” [story]) don’t deserve to be published without challenge; it doesn’t serve agencies who want to fight drug trafficking to underestimate the problem, nor can any politician support a development project without hyping its potential benefit.
Still, The Times persists. In November, when New York City Comptroller William Thompson released a study purporting to show that New Yorkers purchase more than $23 billion in counterfeit goods each year, The Times repeated the analysis as if it were credible [story]. Quick arithmetic would have demonstrated that $23 billion would work out to roughly $8,000 per city household, a number ludicrous on its face. (In the Web version of this column, I’ve linked to an excellent dissection of Thompson’s report, by freelance journalist Felix Salmon.)
[…]
… [I]n the movie business, where records are about as meaningful as promises. “Shrek 2” is not, as an article in The Times Magazine had it in November, “the third-highest-grossing movie of all time” [story]; if you consider inflation, it’s not even in the Top 10 (and “Titanic” is far from No. 1). This record-mania has spread everywhere. “Record-high gas prices” summoned up last year weren’t even close; at its summer peak, gas cost 80 cents a gallon less than it did in 1981. Says economics reporter David Leonhardt, “Treating 2004 dollars the same as 1981 dollars isn’t much different from treating dollars the same as rupees. The fact that 10 is a bigger number than 9 doesn’t make 10 rupees worth more than $9; nor does it make $10 from 2004 worth more than $9 from 1981.” Inflation isn’t the only culprit stalking the record books: “Record deficits” may not be records when they’re expressed as a percentage of gross domestic product, a far more reasonable measure than any raw number.
I’m less generous than Orkent. The failure to factor in the most basic mathematical context – like adjusting for inflation – reveals that modern journalism doesn’t make these “oversights” because of laziness, or even innumeracy.
The do it because a headline that reads “Gasoline Prices Still Well Below All Time Highs” just doesn’t have quite the right ring to it.