Most of us have at some point or another encountered individuals who blithely dismiss the need for concern – or even discussion – about acts of serious malfeasance or general moral breakdown on the grounds that similar miscreant behaviours have occurred throughout history. This argumentative equivalent of a Gallic shrug, typically delivered in a didactic, Father Christmas tone, is essentially an ad hominem accusation that anyone who takes an interest in, or expresses concern about, recent events and trends has lost his sense of perspective due to a putative failure to realize that there is, in fact, nothing new under the sun.
In a Telegraph column titled “Why we need a ‘moral panic’ over last week’s riots”, Ed West takes exception to this form of indifference that masquerades as wisdom. Responding to one particular proponent of the tiresome “it’s happened throughout history, so chill out” meme, he coins a keeper of a phrase:
The Economist’s Bagehot suggests that we shouldn’t get our knickers in a twist about the riots, quoting previous examples of moral panic about social disorder, crime and youth culture to show that last week’s events are nothing new. He cites articles about “young delinquents’ in 1913, 1956 headlines about ‘rock’n’roll babies’ and even reports from 1815, and compares them with recent newspaper articles. His conclusion: we should avoid “moral panic” and a rush to “historically-illiterate judgment”.
I’ve heard this fallacy so many times that I think it really needs a name – perhaps the “moral panic fallacy“. It holds that because people in the past have expressed concern and alarm about crime and social decline, therefore such concern today must be mistaken. (emph. mine)
The data West provides suggest that modern-day concerns about crime and social decline are neither mistaken nor the result of “historically-illiterate judgement”:
In 1955…there were 500,000 crimes recorded in England and Wales; in 1992 there were 5.1 million, after which the crime statistics system was changed. Even in the 1930s indictable offences were a tenth what they are today – despite large numbers of people living in grinding poverty (actual poverty, not “BlackBerrys and £100 trainers poverty”).
Seems there is something new under the sun.
Between 1901 and 1941 there were never more than 400 recorded robberies in the whole of England each year. But in 2001/2 there were 6,500 in the borough of Lambeth alone…
Purveyors of the moral panic fallacy should try to gain a little ‘perspective’ in lieu of advising others to do so.