They Just Can’t Help Themselves

Tom Brodbeck in the Winnipeg Sun;

One television report this week had Mulroney calling former Tory cabinet minister Joe Clark “stupid” in the book.
Actually, what Mulroney really said in the book was that Clark was a weak leader and didn’t have the capacity to manage his caucus when he was party leader.
“I’m not so sure that he does today, although if he hasn’t learned anything over the last seven or eight years, he’d be a very stupid man, and he’s not stupid,” said Mulroney.
The TV report turned “not stupid” into “stupid.”
Maybe Mulroney’s not so crazy after all.

Out With A Whimper

Monte Solberg;

I’m told that the PMO has had around thirty staff changes in the last year. I note that long time loyalist Ruth Thorkelson quietly left the PMO as Deputy Chief of Staff for the office that makes appointments. I note too that this happened after the Michaele Jean uproar. Clearly these two things are unconnected and no stories should be written connecting the two.

I bet you didn’t hear that.
Though, let’s be fair to the national media – insignificant departures from the Prime MInister’s office are just so hard to fit it in, what with the headline grabbing coverage of Conservatives letting go staffers, Conservatives in Quebec criticizing the leader, and Conservatives dropping out… er, not dropping out of candidacy races.

Walking Off The Pounds

Via the Corner;

Steve Vaught, a roughly 400-pound man, is walking from Oceanside, CA to New York City, because, as he says, he wants to “lose weight and regain my life.” According to his website, he has made it over a thousand miles so far and is now in Texas.

An imaginative approach. He’s dropped quite a few pounds already, though he’s getting tired of the media hounding.
Which reminds me – ever since hearing about this little tromp, It occurred to me that those high-priced weight loss spas that ask clients to pack bathing suits might consider providing parkas instead.
ski.jpg

The Film That Launched A Thousand Suicide Bombers

Now the camera focuses on a man and a boy crouched behind a concrete barrel or culvert, their faces contorted in fear. Enderlin: “Here Jamal al-Dura and his son are targets of gunfire from Israeli positions.” The camera pans to a nearby Israeli outpost. The father waves with his right hand in the direction of the Israeli position. The father is hunched behind the barrel, the boy nestled against his back. Enderlin:

dura.jpg Muhammad is twelve years old. His father tries to protect him. He waves. But another round of fire bursts out. Muhammad is dead, and his father grievously wounded.

During the 55-second sequence, two shots have hit a concrete-block wall that stands like a backdrop for the scene, landing far afield of the father and son. Other bullet holes, similarly off-target, can be seen in the wall as well. The father shields the boy; the father’s arm is clearly visible, perpendicular to the ground. Guttural cries are heard, adding to the feeling of panic. The last round of gunfire kicks up a cloud of dust, obscuring the man and boy. When the dust clears, the boy is stretched out at his father’s feet; the father bobs his head as if groggy.
And that was it. As Enderlin would later explain, the reason France-2’s scoop was offered free to the world was that the producers did not want to earn a profit from so tragic an incident. Only the terrible moments of the child’s death throes, he added, had been edited out, being “too unbearable.” The film sequence itself, attributed at first to a “France-2 cameraman,” was subsequently identified as the work of the station’s Palestinian stringer, Talal Abu Rahmeh. By then, the full authority and reputation of France-2 itself had been indelibly stamped on the footage.
[…]
In one version of his story, Talal Abu Rahmeh went to Netzarim junction at seven in the morning on a hunch that the children would be out demonstrating “because it was a school day,” and he knew they demonstrated on school days. In another version, he ran over to the junction at 3 PM, after someone called his office to inform him that there were fierce battles going on. The outtakes show he was there from early morning. Apparently, a dozen of his colleagues had the same intuition; they too can be seen in the raw footage.
The Reuters, AP, and France-2 outtakes that I viewed show two totally different and easily identifiable types of activity at Netzarim junction: real, intifada-style attacks, and crudely falsified battle scenes. Both the real and the fake scenes are played out against a background of normal civilian activity at a busy crossroads. In the “reality” zone, excited children and angry young men hurl rocks and Molotov cocktails at the Israeli outpost while shababs (“youths”) standing on the roof of the Twins throw burning tires down onto the caged lookout; this goes on seemingly for hours, without provoking the slightest military reaction from Israeli soldiers.
At the same time, in the “theatrical” zone, Palestinian stringers sporting prestigious logos on their vests and cameras are seen filming battle scenes staged behind the abandoned factory, well out of range of Israeli gunfire. The “wounded” sail through the air like modern dancers and then suddenly collapse. Cameramen jockey with hysterical youths who pounce on the “casualties,” pushing and shoving, howling Allahu akhbar!, clumsily grabbing the “injured,” pushing away the rare ambulance attendant in a pale green polyester jacket in order to shove, twist, haul, and dump the “victims” into UN and Red Crescent ambulances that pull up on a second’s notice and career back down the road again, sirens screaming. In one shot we recognize Talal Abu Rahmeh in his France-2 vest, filming a staged casualty scene.*
Split seconds of these ludicrous vignettes would later appear in newscasts and special reports; the husk, the raw footage that would reveal the fakery, had been removed, leaving the kernel rich in anti-Israel nutrients.
Such staged scenes showed up, for example, in a dramatic CBS 60 Minutes special report on Netzarim crossing – a place “now known,” intoned Bob Simon, echoing Palestinian sources, “as Martyr’s Junction.”
The al-Dura death scene was filmed right in the middle of these falsified incidents. It can be localized and situated. In one section of Reuters footage we see the man and the boy crouched behind the upended culvert as a jeep drives slowly up the road, stops in firing range of the Israeli position that is clearly visible in the near distance, makes a U-turn, drives in the opposite direction, stops short of the barrel/culvert, and helps perform the clearly faked evacuation of a man wounded in the right leg, as also shown in the France-2 news report. In fact, two ambulances stand for a long moment no more than fifteen feet from the al-Duras. There is no evidence of armed combat in their vicinity. No sound of gunfire. Men run down the road, passing in front of the al-Duras. No one is hit.

Read it all.
David Gelernter has the full sequence of photo stills, along with more on the consequences of this bit of film making.

Deuce Four Heads Home

Michael Yon’s latest dispatch from Iraq carries an update on LTC Erik Kurilla’s recovery and the progress his team made in Mosul.

As the Deuce Four heads home this week, they leave behind a Mosul that, while not yet in the clear, is much closer to security and prosperity than anyone would have considered possible eight months ago. In between the daily secret reports Kurilla has brought to his hospital room so he can track his battalion, the Commander watches television news, increasingly frustrated by what he sees as a clear, and inaccurate, negative bias. “When you get the news back here in the states, it’s all doom and body counts. I only wish the American public could see the incredible progress that is being made every day in Iraq, particularly in places like Mosul.”

The account of the battle that led to Kurilla’s injuries is here.

Your search – “an independent review of the Calgary Police Service” – did not match any documents

In April of this year, the Calgary police chief went to extraordinary ends to seize a computer owned by a civilian employee. This was not for a criminal investigation, but a civil suit. Calgary Herald, April 9th;

Calgary Police Service Chief Jack Beaton has obtained a secret court order to seize from a civilian employee of the department a computer believed to be used in creating a website critical of his leadership.
The Anton Piller Order, a rarely used legal remedy aimed at preserving evidence in specific civil court cases, was executed by several police officers Saturday at the southeast Calgary home of Jan Vahey, who is contracted to do transcription work for the police service.
The order — along with the reasons it was sought and approved by the judge — have been sealed by the court, keeping its contents secret.� Vahey said she’s forbidden by the court order from speaking to anyone about it.

This little ad appeared in the Calgary Sun September 10, 2005, Classifieds, Section 1399 Public Notice and Tenders;

Deloitte & Touche, LLP (“Deloitte”) has been engaged by the Calgary Police Commission to conduct an independent review of the Calgary Police Service public and internal complaint process. The review will assess:
* accessibility
* effectiveness
* efficiency
As part of this review Deloitte is seeking written submissions from interested parties in the complaints process. These submissions should outline:
* accessibility to the complaint process
* barriers to the complaint process
Additionally, Deloitte is interested in all parties’ views as to the effectiveness, efficiency or failings of the complaint process.
These written submissions must be received by Deloitte no later than midnight October 15, 2005.
Please send your comments to the attention of:
Brian Tario, Firm Director
3000 Scotia Centre
700 2 Street S.W.
Calgary, Alberta
T2P 0S7
If further detail is required please contact Brian Tario at 403-267-1768 or by e-mail at btario@deloitte.ca

View original
Apparently a stingy little contract they have with Deloitte, considering how small and well-buried this notice is!
Nor has it been posted�on the Commission, The CPS, City of Calgary or Calgary Police Association websites.�

Good News From Iraq Continues

Arthur Chrenkoff is signing off. A step up the professional ladder requires that he discontinue blogging.
Few other bloggers have achieved what Arthur has, in almost single-handedly bringing balance and context to the greater progress being made in both Iraq and Afghanistan. If you have been framing your opinion on post-war Iraq through the lens of the mainstream media, you owe it to yourself to read Arthur’s final installment of good news. You’ll be astonished at how much there is. If you search the archives, how much there has been in all these months of car-bomb-a-day reporting from the “green zone”.
The good news is that the series will continue – the team at Winds of Change has taken up the torch, and have established a new site devoted to the series, titled Good News From The Front.
Bookmark it!

Tales From The Land Of Milk And Granite Curbs

The City of Ottawa guaranteed a loan for the organizers of this year’s Gay Pride Parade;

Parade organizers borrowed $50,000 from the TD bank to hold the parade, and somebody at the city thought it was a good idea to guarantee the lone. When the gays stiffed the bank and walked away from the load, the city was left to pay the bill.
This is just wrong at a number of levels.
One of the problems is that the city had to dedicate a large number of police officers to the event – and by the way the officers were on orders to wish everyone there a “Happy Pride Day”. With those costs involved, and with our short staffing issues with Ottawa police, don’t you think we would be better served if the police officers were doing more essential things like stopping kids from breaking windows at schools or setting houses and dumpsters on fire in Barrhaven?
As city residents, we need our tax dollars to go to pay for the lack of essential services. A gay pride parade is not a core service.
If there is going to be a parade, that’s fine. But if the gay community has so much pride, maybe next year they can pay for the parade themselves.

If they don’t have the cash, there’s always community service. At the risk of perpetuating a stereotype – the city sponsored “painting better graffiti” courses could probably use a few instructors with an eye for colour and design.

Paging Gurmant Grewal

The Canadian media and their cohorts on the Liberal-left side of the blogosphere are set to go nuclear in their condemnation of Peter C. Newman. Watch for words like “sleazy”, “dishonest” and “unethical”.
Information in his new book on Brian Mulroney, titled “The Secret Mulroney Tapes” was obtained by secretly taping conversations and phone calls between himself and the former prime minister.
So, fasten your seatbelts and reach for your earplugs. As we have already seen, the white hot lens of political punditry and media scrutiny is about to beam down on Mr. Newman.
Wake me when it starts.

Reader Tips

Busy day here, so I’ll just pass along a few items that have dropped in my inbox over the past few hours.
Reader Peter Benyk emails on a topic I haven’t followed, because I don’t care about satellite radio. Others do, so;

The two Canadian companies have finally been granted approval for broadcasting satellite radio from the Federal cabinet. Although they were approved earlier by the CRTC for licenses heavy lobbying from Quebec insisted there be and even number of French and English stations and now there will be four of each. The licensees relented to this bit of blackmail and as a result the federal cabinet approved both licenses. How ludicrous that this government insist on this provision as if the population of this country was split with approximately half communicating in French and the other half communicating in English. We know at best the figures would be 4 to 1 English over French. These radio stations are to carry a prescribed amount of Canadian talent so where is the equity in developing the English talent if their outlets are minimized so they are equal to the number of French outlets. This is just another example in my book where Quebec is dictating the Federal Liberal policies of Canada and if you wondered if there was truth to a common complaint that French is being shoved down the throat (and ears) of Canadians here you have it in living color. English speaking Canadians are being forced to split the number of English stations 50/50 as if this reflected the French -English population and talent pool of this country. Since 90% of the people who communicate in French are located in the Quebec area it is reasonable to assume that they will be able to get along with fewer stations but why limit and handcuff the English speaking population, by only giving them an equal number of stations, who are servicing a much broader cross section of people in Canada and are highly involved in providing English services in every province and who are in fact servicing a much larger pool of Canadian talent albeit English speaking.

Sounds about right. A few years ago I heard that it had been calculated that the CBC French language television in Saskatchewan had a viewership of around seven households.
Lots at China E-Lobby today.

Communist leader Hu Jintao came to his hotel in Toronto “via the underground parking garage” (Epoch Times) rather than face the Falun Gong and Tibetan protestors who jostled for position with the usual group of bribed welcomers.

In the 1970’s the US Congress approved a massive barrier system for New Orleans. An environmental lawsuit took care of that!
A pastor in Alberta is facing a human rights tribunal over a letter to the editor in a Red Deer newspaper criticizing homosexuality. If he loses, he could be forced to pay $7,000 in fines – including $2,000 to the homosexual-rights group EGALE Canada.
$2,000 just for being offended? Time to register REDNECK Canada as a non-profit, methinks.
(Add your own in the comments, or send a trackback to this post.)

Journalism Today: Never Let Timeline Get In The Way

Update: He’s having server problems, but the post linked to below can be accessed here for now
In a lengthy entry, Jeff Goldstein begins by quoting Jack Kelly in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in a report that takes dead aim at Katrina reporting;

It is settled wisdom among journalists that the federal response to the devastation wrought by Hurricane Katrina was unconscionably slow.
“Mr. Bush’s performance last week will rank as one of the worst ever during a dire national emergency,” wrote New York Times columnist Bob Herbert in a somewhat more strident expression of the conventional wisdom.
But the conventional wisdom is the opposite of the truth.
Jason van Steenwyk is a Florida Army National Guardsman who has been mobilized six times for hurricane relief. He notes that:
“The federal government pretty much met its standard time lines, but the volume of support provided during the 72-96 hour was unprecedented. The federal response here was faster than Hugo, faster than Andrew, faster than Iniki, faster than Francine and Jeanne.”
For instance, it took five days for National Guard troops to arrive in strength on the scene in Homestead, Fla. after Hurricane Andrew hit in 2002. But after Katrina, there was a significant National Guard presence in the afflicted region in three.
Journalists who are long on opinions and short on knowledge have no idea what is involved in moving hundreds of tons of relief supplies into an area the size of England in which power lines are down, telecommunications are out, no gasoline is available, bridges are damaged, roads and airports are covered with debris, and apparently have little interest in finding out.
So they libel as a “national disgrace” the most monumental and successful disaster relief operation in world history.

Jeff then goes on to rip into Newsweek, page by page;

We know that Bush watches ESPN.� We know that the Iraq War is a failure.� We know that the President surrounds himself with yes men.� And all these things-when coupled with his “failure of imagination” (a more “imaginative” President presumably would have shredded the Constitution and dropped active duty troops into New Orleans over the objections of a sitting governor, and would’ve done so on Tuesday as the levees were breaking-in effect, anticipating what the local government was unable both to anticipate and prepare for) – highlight Bush’s failure.
In short, the dumbest, Chimpiest, most fascist President ever failed to be the most prescient, creative, Constitutionally “proactive” President ever.
This, my friends, is “journalism.”

Especially for those of you new to SDA and the blogosphere, I suggest you read Jeff’s entry. In his disassembly of the Newsweek article, he exposes that much of the coverage we’ve been treated to on Katrina and the responses of the various levels of government is, at best, pathetically superficial and selectively factual. At worst (and most of it falls into the worst category) it’s intentionally politicized and misleading.
Journalists, take note. This is why increasing numbers of Americans – and Canadians – are turning off their network news and cancelling subscriptions. The “art of omission” is a dangerous ploy in an age where the media consumer has near instant, unfiltered free access to legal and constitutional experts, transcripts, archival material, and witnesses on the scene.
When viewers and readers discover you are ignoring the details – in this case, details like the limitations placed on presidential powers by the US Constitution – in a transparent ploy to score political points, you damage the relationship with the information consumer on a multitude of levels.
That you inflict long term damage on your own professional credibility goes without saying. What seems less understood by your profession is that your actions convey a profound contempt for your readers and listeners. Disingenuously superficial and/or inappropriately politicized versions of current events are an insult to our intelligence – and we know it.
As frustrating as this facade of journalism is to those of us who have the time to seek out a variety of sources to sift fact from half-fact, there are sobering implications that go beyond immediate reporting. Subverting the legitimate public policy debate that should arise out of this disaster (both in the US and here – where Vancouver awaits the “big one”) places lives at stake. Our lives.
If you, as a member of the general public, don’t feel a little uneasy at the eagerness of a crocodile media whose tears mix with saliva as they report rising ratings “rising death tolls” , if you don’t realize that our lives are no more valuable to these people than those in a Baghdad cafe or New Orleans street, you’re deluding yourself.
Disaster and terrorism fatalities serve a political purpose for a significant number of people who are posing as journalists while they pursue a higher ideological purpose. In their eyes, we’re just so many potential body parts for the next Pulitzer Prize winning illustration of their world view. These people are not on our side. They’re on theirs.
Related: Katrina timeline, plus this Hugh Hewitt inteview with Mark Steyn.
Update: Ben Stein says “The real story is that the mainstream media rioted.”

We Stand On Guard For Thee

Paul Tuns;

In March 2004, in the wake of the Adscam scandal, Auditor General Sheila Fraser released another damning report, this one on Ottawa’s inaction on addressing national security concerns. She highlighted the vulnerability of Canada’s ports and airports to terrorist attacks, especially with regard to those who work there. She found that 5.5 percent of a sample of airport employees had possible criminal connections, a flag for national security concerns. If extrapolated to the entire airport workforce, there would be 4,500 employees with possible criminal connections the implications being that employees are not being properly screened, and those with criminal connections may also be tied to terrorist groups.
Senator Kenny’s Security and Defence committee has released several reports over the last three years raising concerns about the country’s lack of preparedness for terrorist attacks. In December 2004, Kenny released the 2005 edition of the Canadian Security Guide Book, which highlighted the same concerns Fraser drew attention to: improperly guarded and underguarded borders, and vulnerable ports and airports. In one example, he noted that Canada’s ports of entry were jeopardized by the disappearance of 1,127 uniforms or uniform items belonging to Canadian airport screeners over a nine-month period, including 91 security badges.
Kenny’s committee also alleges that the government is “cutting corners on intelligence.” This seems to confirm Fraser’s findings that nearly $9 billion in anti-terrorism money is not ending up where it is supposed to go, and that there are intelligence gaps resulting from fiscal mismanagement and oversight confusion. Kenny says the problem is not merely money but training; he said it can take years to properly train intelligence officers, but that there is no commitment to train a sufficient number of analysts.
Fraser’s report also found other problems with the government’s response to 9-11. Fraser said the official watch lists of criminals and terrorists were outdated, and that such information was not being shared among departments so that, for instance, the list of 25,000 lost and stolen passports each year is given to front-line border officers. She concluded, “These matters are serious and need to be addressed.”

Juxtaposed against that summary of continuing Canadian sluggishness in addressing national security and internal terrorist groups, a story from the Montreal Gazette;

When an alert was sent to Canadian customs agents in Quebec warning of an “armed and dangerous” suspect, some 50 employees walked off the job for four hours at about 15 of 44 border crossings just before 9 a.m. yesterday.
[…]
…the protesting agents were exercising their right under the Canada Labour Code to withdraw services if they feel their life or health is threatened.
“We’re not armed, we’re not going to be a target,” said Jean-Pierre Fortin, a union spokesperson. The union wants the federal government to supply border agents with sidearms. Ottawa says the agents’ bulletproof vests, telescopic batons and pepper spray are sufficient.

Nor are they equipped with chase vehicles. As a result, about 1500 vehicles “blew across the border” last year with impunity, as the only recourse for Customs officials is to place a call to the nearest RCMP detachment – which in many parts of the country, are being closed.

Anniversary

After living overseas for about a year and a half, I was now finally home in New York. This time around I had landed a sweet apartment in Lower Manhattan. Situated about six blocks from the World Trade Center and just two from the South Street Seaport. I could stand on my balcony and see through the canyon of skyscrapers that lined John Street to catch a glimpse of the World Trade Center.
All in all, it was a great place to live — very quiet and peaceful, especially for Manhattan.
Except for the night before the attack.
That whole day I was restless. Work was a stessful and I couldn’t concentrate all day. I had decided to take my camera along and take pictures of the WTC/Battery Park City area at lunchtime, but I ended up stuck in a meeting all day.
At the end of the day, I was still quite anxious and tense. So much so, that I decided to walk around a bit before going home. I would have taken pictures but the rain that hit the area pretty much killed that idea. My digital cameras was anything but waterproof.
Even after getting home I was still restless, so I watched a little TV. Then things got wierder.
The intro to the show Third Watch contained a monologue about some guy talking about how fast things can go wrong in life and started mumbling about Chaos Theory. After that show was over, I turned to the History Channel which was playing a [surprise!] WW2 documentary. Suddenly, a few Normandy veterans started saying basically the same thing. They commented about how one minute their friend would be next to them and then the next instant they were dead.
Needless to say, this sort of stuff didn’t sit well with me. So I turned off the tube and went to check my email. Imagine my shock when I saw the Yahoo Question of the Day was about Chaos Theory. At this point, I called my parents to make sure everything was OK. I was certain something bad was about to happen, but I didn’t know what.

Confused, I decided to go out onto my balcony to get some fresh air. To my shock and amazement, I saw a kind of odd glow in the sky and a strange kind calm in the streets. At this point, I ran back in to get a my camera and got a few shots of this phenommenon.

Later, I would try to get some sleep, but with all the odd vibes around me, how could I? I finally fell asleep around 1:30 AM only to awaken again around 3AM from a nightmare. At 5 AM, I fell back to sleep, only to be awoken at a quarter to nine, when a loud boom interrupted my sleep.

Frank LaVigne’s 9-11 photo diary
Joe Katzman at Winds of Change has collected dozens of links related to 9-11 and the aftermath.

One Million!

SDA recorded the one millionth visitor a few minutes ago, according to Sitemeter.
Thanks, everybody!
(If you aren’t familiar with Sitemeter, scroll down to the bottom of the sidebar and click on the number – you’ll be taken to a site that provides general traffic statistics here.)

Katrina’s Impact On The Drug Trade?

Over at the Shotgun a comment by “Greg From Dallas” merits attention, I think.

Something that has not been addressed is how much of the shooting in New Orleans was simply your usual garden variety psychopath and how much of it was drug shipment warehouses being protected.
As one of the largest seaports in the world, only a small percentage of cargo shipments are thoroughly checked out. Lots of illegal narcotics flow in through the ports. Organized crime exerts a lot of infuence in the Port of Louisiana as well as at other ports around the world. (There are those who say that organized crime has no influence in Canadian ports, but I’m not buying it.)
So when Katrina hit, the natural order of things was disrupted. Drug distribution couldn’t take place and flow through normal channels. As a consequence, I imagine some people in charge gave explicit orders to protect shipments in their covert warehouses. (You have to wonder why street thugs would be trying to shoot down a helicopter.)
One of the things we can tell from this is that a) a lot of junkies are not getting their fix, so we should have a rise in burglaries and street crime; b) various kinds of dope are going to become expensive because when the supply is diminished, users are going to have to pay a premium to get their narcotics.
The upshot is that professional criminals took a bath. The street price of narcotics is going to be inflated for a while. A lot of junkies are not going to be able to get their dope. And probably there’ll be an escalation in various kinds of street crime for habituated drug users to get the price of their drugs.

Navigation