The Sound Of Settled Science

Joe Bast, Heartland Institute;

I’m not interested in what a small and non-representative group of liberal academics BELIEVE. I know you all trusted the United Nations to deliver truthful reports about the science of climate change, and you were fooled. With your careers (and probably political ideologies) now at risk, you will be among the last, not the first, to abandon a disproven scientific theory.
I want to see PROOF that climate models are reliable guides to future climate trends, since surveys of climate scientists suggest large majorities of them believe they are NOT. I want PROOF that the warming of the late 20th century didn’t stop around 2000, even though NASA’s satellites say it did. And I want PROOF that there is anything we can do, short of simply ending modern civilization and forcing billions of people to starve to death, that would have any discernible effect on the world’s climate.
Give me that evidence, and I’ll take you seriously. Otherwise, stick to science, and leave the politics to us.

Related Climategate updates at WUWT.

25 Replies to “The Sound Of Settled Science”

  1. Once again “big” media is not covering this. Including supposedly conservative Sun News Network. Aside from passing mention by the opinion folks, the hard news division will likely not report anything that would upset their J school masters. Sun News is only marginally less liberal than the rest. Sun News is slowly swinging left. Lets see if they fire Sid Ryan for assaulting Delaney. Not likely.

  2. Good for Joe Bast. He is a hero.
    UN Environment Chief Achim Steiner pressuring Durban participants to come up with a deal sooner rather than 2020. I believe he is concerned that the money scam he and his pals, Al Gore, Dr. Fruitfly et al have perpetrated may be coming to an end.

  3. Unless the DemocRat Party is even dumber than I think they are, 2010 was the last American election where Global Warming/AGW/Carbon Taxes are campaign issues. 2012 will be all economy, all the time.
    Dear Lefties, I’m sorry but its over. From here on out its going to be Politics As Usual, with no more save-the-polar-bears. Luckily the bears are not actually IN danger, but to the extent y’all believe they are, you are SOL. Bottom line, your party is no longer going to reflect your Lefty values and Lefty beliefs.
    As a Conservative, and I think I can speak for Conservatives everywhere when I say this, welcome to the club.

  4. rabbit, I think Bast wants ANY evidence, because there certainly doesn’t seem to be any. There is however a lot of scientific vandalism and data fudging. As in, we have two functional weather stations in the North? WTH?

  5. If just a few politicians here in Canada would grow a set like Nigel Farrage or Daniel Hannan/ Vaclav Klaus teal, call this massive SCAM what it is,a SCAM. Stand up for the honest law abiding taxpayers who are sick of busting our backs to send money to be squandered and stolen. You politicians were sent to those plum jobs by the people who you are screwing, one has to be a moron or a leftie, same thing, to believe this garbage, and if you are using globull warming for a convenient taxation vehicle, we have sniffed it out long ago, Man up Canadian politicians and start sending the money thieves back to the sewer outlets on the CBC CTV buildings they crawled out of, WE are not stupid out here.

  6. Science is just the verneer. The governments of the developed countries and especially Europe are desperate to increase GDP so that they may continue their charade. And their answer is to make the increase in GDP out of thin air. They know they will never be able to produce enough goods to cover the existing let alone future debt.

  7. Oh hey, the founder of a conservative think-tank funded by oil and tobacco companies is against climate change? Who Knew!
    Not saying I disagree with him, just saying this isn’t really news…

  8. the current methods used to “measure” temperatures is a joke, as they may only be indicating energy (in the form of heat) moving from one place to the next. I’v always been critical of the deighn of the methods used, and this flaw is starting to be pointed out by more leaned peoples than me

  9. that’s “design”
    Kate we needs 15 minute time span to be able to correct our stupidity in here:-))))

  10. The scam called Climate Change won’t come to an end until the greenie/leftist retards have ruined the economy with their totalitarian and uneconomic green shift. Only when the cold hard facts of economic bankruptcy hit the brainwashed masses in the face will things change. Until then the lying lamestream media and governments will continue to scare the gullible public into economic suicide.
    Don’t underestimate the evil of the global warming movement. These people will do and say anything to impose their insane ideology on the public. The battle to stop this outrage is far from over.

  11. For those who don’t read the National Post, a brave soul named Bill Bell, paid for a full ONE AND A HALF pages in the financial section to debunk the notion that the “science is settled”. Doubt it’s available on the Post’s site, but you can read it at “nucleus.com”.

  12. Powerfactor at November 24, 2011 10:35 AM
    Actually, climate change is a constant. The warm-mongers just adopted it to create a mass hysteria, since most of the population does not, will not take note of the difference between AGW and CC.
    The assumption is that CC is AGW. A 100% wrong assumption.
    There is no AGW, there is climate change as constant as night and day, as year after year and other such.

  13. The real Scientists have to stand up and demand that the Science Journalists (like Hollywood screen writers) get out of Science. The Scientific America Magazine is near the worst.
    The whole Green House Gas theory sits on a facade of unknown, unproven, and unmeasured (the measurements can’t be confirmed by traceable data). The UN/EU science game started with the ozone hole another outrages scientific claim without sufficient Scientific Proof.
    When you make claims of a scientific theory that has extraordinary impact on Society and human well being; That Science demands an extraordinary level of proof. Time to put up everything of AGW or nothing.
    The pll behind AGW are not Scientists, they have meaningless PhD’s.. (It’s the Puppy Mill Equivalent)
    JMHO

  14. Here is one of the emails that makes sense:
    Lanzante/NOAA:
    While perhaps one could designate some subset of models as being poorer in a
    lot of areas, there probably never will be a single universally superior model
    or set of models. We should keep in mind that the climate system is complex, so
    that it is difficult, if not impossible to define a metric that captures the
    breath of physical processes relevant to even a narrow area of focus.
    From: http://davidappell.blogspot.com/2011/11/sorting-through-stolen-uae-emails.html

  15. Yo, powerf*****r – One of the people running about the globe in hysterics that ‘man-made global warming’ is melting the glacier on Mount Kilimajaro, privately admits in his emails that IT IS TOO COLD UP THERE FOR THE GLACIER TO MELT, and that in his own estimation it is sublimation, accelerated by the FACT that the forests below the mountain have been severely cut back over the past century.
    Lying Bastard in pulbic. Knows the truth in private.
    There’s one of Your kind of scientists, powerf*****r.

  16. KevinB @ 11:19 – I couldn’t find the article through nucleus, but he also published in the Calgary Herald yesterday; the text is available through their ad service. He has generously sent me a .pdf copy (through billbell@nucleus.com). I’ll ask him how we can contribute toward his expenses.

  17. But every decade needs a new panic that the gullible can latch onto. 70s was new ice age. 80s was the hole in the ozone. 90s was the dying oceans. 2000s was global warming. We are overdue here folks. Perhaps the 2010s will be the real one and make the other ones look trivial and insignificant. The monetary one. The one that will take the wind out of every cause except the one that pertains to survival. The one that shows what a toothless bitch nanny can be. The one that will give us a whole new sense of reality and allow you to ride a bicycle without a helmet. The one that resets what is important in life.
    Not hoping, but the potential is there and larger than comfortable.

  18. I think this guy is epressing what most of us jaded realists have waited for from climate alarmists – proof there is a problem and if it is real, proof it can actually be corrected by man.
    The screaming hyteria and political noise surrounding AGW/climate change legislating, reminds me of the same hysterics and accusatory politics with dissenters that ensued 18 years ago when the government offered registering duck guns as a cure to domestic violence and crime.
    We’ve been screwed over so many times by political agendas driven by hysteria and fear mongering that being cynical is a matter of survivsl in such politically charged times. I usually question the logic of those who aren’t cynical of the latest meme pimped by the political elite.

  19. Imagine that the left engaging in potty-mouth slander. Nothing new about that. Amoral, situational ethics, foul mouths and empty heads – that’s yer hard core lefty right there.

  20. In order to prove unnatural climate change one first has to prove natural climate stasis. If there is no natural climate stasis then no one can definitively say that unnatural climate change is taking place.

Navigation