An old ADSCAM character is back in the news. Globe & Mail;
Industry Canada has frozen federal financing for research projects by an Ontario biotechnology firm pending the outcome of an investigation into the company’s agreement to pay $350,000 in lobbying fees to former Liberal cabinet minister David Dingwall, government sources say.
The move is part of a much broader probe of about 22 high-tech companies that may have hired unregistered lobbyists, or allegedly paid improper contingency fees to lobbyists to help secure federal financing under Ottawa’s controversial Technology Partnerships Canada program.
Bioniche, based in Belleville, Ont., recently admitted to Industry Canada that it agreed in May of 2000 to pay Mr. Dingwall a �success fee� of $350,000, the government sources said.
Adscam? you ask?
David Dingwall was the Public Works Minister who brought in Chuck Guite.
CTV News, Sept 2004;
Controversial bureaucrat Chuck Guite was hand-picked by the Liberal government to overhaul federal advertising policy after the 1995 Quebec referendum, evidence at a public inquiry shows.
A memo tabled Wednesday made it clear Guite was recommended for the job by the office of Dave Dingwall, then federal public works minister. Warren Kinsella, who served as Dingwall’s chief of staff, wrote on Nov. 23, 1995 — less than a month after the referendum — that “recent experience” had shown the need to centralize federal ad strategy.
The same centralized approach should apply to public opinion polling and other communications programs, he said.
Public Works was the logical department to review past practices and put new procedures in place, Kinsella wrote.
“In my view Mr. J. C. Guite … should be assigned to carry out this review on a full- time basis,” he told Ran Quail, the deputy minister at Public Works.
“It is requested that he (Guite) be assigned to a position that will allow him to carry out these tasks.”
Andrew Coyne had this to say about Dingwall’s “testimony” at the Public Accounts Committee in April of 2004;
A minister notorious for his enthusiastic turning of departmental budgets to political ends claims to have had no involvement — none whatever — in what his bureaucrats were up to, on the single most important file in federal politics, during the gravest crisis in our history. Nor, he suggests, did anyone else in Cabinet.
His testimony is contradicted at another point by Allan Cutler, the Public Works whistle-blower who kept detailed notes of what went on at the department in that time.
As PoliticsWatch reports, Cutler testified about a Nov. 17 [1994] meeting between Guite, himself and other members of the contracting group at Public Works.�
“At this meeting, Mr. Guite told us that normal rules and regulations should not apply to advertising,” said Cutler. “He said he would talk to the minister to have them changed.
“A week later, I was informed that myself and two other employees who worked for me would move to Mr. Guite’s section and report to him immediately. At this point in time, Mr. Guite’s responsibilities were expanded to include not only the selection of advertising agencies, but also the negotiation and award of contracts to selected agencies.
A number of bloggers are already following the latest Librano scandal involving Technology Partnerships Canada . “Angry” has been digging into the lobbyist registration database and has a lot more.
Strongworld explains;
This scandal at TPC is starting to look like another Adscam, only bigger. During its existence, TPC put $2.9 billion tax dollars into research & development “loans” to companies. Only about 5% of those “loans” were ever repaid.
Two things about this whole mess need to be thoroughly investigated.
How many Liberal heavyweights like Dingwall and Lalonde improperly received “success fees” for helping companies secure funding from TPC?
How much money was contributed to the Liberal Party of Canada from companies that received TPC funding and also from members of their Boards of Directors?
This comment at Blue Blogging Soapbox summarizes the current state of the investigation;
When you look at what we have so far – 51 companies audited out of 158 and so far they’ve found 15 have paid illegal fees – 29.4%. They still have 15 audits to finish yet out of that 51.
When the contingency fees had been paid, they were paid to unregistered lobbyists or to lobbyists who filed saying that they were not receiving a contingency fee. So far only 2 out of a possible 15 lobbyists have been identified and as far as we know, no action has been taken against the lobbyists.
Even the audits completed so far have been basic in nature. The reports state that they only looked at the six months before the TPC application and the six months following the successful applicaton, as this was the most likely time a fee would be paid. As well, they did not look for any non-monetary compensation.
While we certainly don’t have a ‘smoking gun’ on this one yet – it’s certainly getting close.
I’m run off my feet here for the next couple of days, so I can’t follow this the way I should. I’m going to invite the readers and other bloggers to update or flesh out the details I may have missed.
This thread is restricted to comments directly related to TPC only. If you’ve written something on this emerging scandal, send a trackback, or post your link in the comments.
(update- I’ve changed the timestamp on this post to keep it near the top of the page for a couple of days.)