The Hiroshima Fallacy

A nuclear physicist shares his views on Iran’s pursuit of nuclear weapons;

The most likely form of nuclear attack in the modern world is one carried out by terrorists. In carrying out such an attack, the attackers might well use a device quite different from the sophisticated weapon that military experts suggest it will take Iran “five to eight years” to develop. Current thought on this subject is often informed by what one might call the “Hiroshima fallacy,” the belief that terrorists would not consider the use of a nuclear weapon significantly less sophisticated than the first weapon used against Japan, or one with a yield significantly less than the yield of that weapon. This is simply not true. Terrorists could inflict tremendous damage in terms of both human life and economic disruption with much simpler devices. Another potentially dangerous fallacy is the notion that terrorists could not attack without transporting a complete weapon to the target. This, too, is nonsense.

The rest at Medienkritik
As was pointed out somewhere else, the fact that “intelligence sources” have provided such a wide range of estimates as to how far along Iran is in its nuclear capabilities is a warning in and of itself – it indicates that nobody really knows for sure.

Reader Tips

More Contests – win a DVD of United 93 from Greg Staples.
A report on anti-Semitism in the UK;

We conclude that calls to boycott contact with academics working in Israel are an assault on academic freedom and intellectual exchange. We recommend that pro-democracy lecturers in the new University and College Lecturers Union are given every support to combat such selective boycotts that are anti-Jewish in practice. We would urge the new union’s executive and leadership to oppose the boycott.

Making Sars look like gingivitis.
The National Citizens Coalition has something for NDP MP Jean Crowder.
Advertising’s best kept secret – it takes a graphic artist about 2 hours to come up with one of these – if they’re good at what they do. The rest of the time is spent writing after-the-fact bafflegab that speaks to the “brand”, to distract the client from the $3 million/hr design rate.
Thanks for all the items you’ve sent – if I didn’t use yours, feel free to share it in the comments.

We Interrupt This Chicken Wire WTC Experiment*

To bring you breaking news, via ABC News;

Al-Jazeera aired on Thursday what it called previously unshown footage in which al-Qaida chief Osama bin Laden is seen meeting with some of the Sept. 11 hijackers. The station did not say how it obtained the video, which was produced by As-Sahab, al-Qaida’s media branch.
The video showed bin Laden sitting with his former lieutenant Mohammed Atef and Ramzi Binalshibh, another suspected planner of the Sept. 11, 2001, suicide hijackings.
Atef, also known as Abu Hafs al-Masri, was killed by a U.S. airstrike in Afghanistan in 2001. Binalshibh was captured four years ago in Pakistan and is currently in U.S. custody, and this week U.S. President George W. Bush announced plans to put him on military trial.
In the video, Bin Laden was wearing a dark robe and white head gear walking outdoors in a mountainous area. He smiled as he received several of what the tape said was several of the Sept. 11 hijackers.

*

“Not As Accurate As Fahrenheit 911”

WaPo helpfully bullet-points the criticisms of the ABC documdrama ‘The Path to 9/11’ on behalf of Clinton & Co. This quote is especially good;

Former national security adviser Samuel R. “Sandy” Berger said the film “flagrantly misrepresents my personal actions.”

In July of 2004, Berger resigned as an advisor to the Kerry campaign after he was caught “removing copies of highly classified documents from the National Archives”;

Berger’s attorneys have acknowledged that he removed numerous classified memos, and apparently discarded some, as he reviewed materials on behalf of the Clinton administration for the independent commission investigating the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. They said the removal of documents was inadvertent but that Berger was aware he was violating the law when he removed his handwritten notes without submitting them for review by National Archives staff.

Berger “inadvertently” put them in his pants.
More – “Bubba goes ballistic”.
Update – ABC caves to pressure from the left.

Kate-O-Shop Results Are In!

A close contest that required a tie breaker – the entries were judged on overall impression, the creativity, technical skill, the effort involved, etc. Big thanks to judges Kathy Shaidle, Stephen Taylor and Ted Betts!
The winning entry “Sir Kate Churchill” was submitted by “Buster”. A $25 donation to Farmers For Justice will go out in today’s mail.

With Dorkafork coming in as runner-up with “Breakfast at Kate’s”

Honourable mentions to:

Apollo Kate by Robot Guy

Queen of the Blogosphere – by “Meadowlark”

“Kryptonite Kate” – by Dorkafork
You can view all the entries here. Thanks to everyone who entered.

Major Oil Find In Gulf

Just this weekend, I was listening to a radio interview with an expert of some alternative energy persuasion who announced that with today’s satellite mapping and other research technologies, that it was unlikely that there would be any new major oil finds outside of the Antarctic;

A trio of oil companies led by Chevron Corp. has tapped a petroleum pool deep beneath the Gulf of Mexico that has the potential to boost the nation’s reserves by more than 50 percent. A test well indicates it could be the biggest domestic oil discovery since Alaska’s Prudhoe Bay more than a generation ago.

I guess that’s why I can’t remember his name.
(Today’s little known fact for the Sect Of Smug Canadians – The United States is the world’s third highest producer of oil. Canada is eighth – behind Norway. Update – those are 2004 numbers. Read the comments for the full confusion. )

The EU’s REACH

US Ambassador to the European Union C. Boyden Gray sounds an international trade alarm in the WSJ ;

The fundamental flaw of Reach — which stands for the Registration, Evaluation and Authorization of Chemicals — is that it is not carefully tailored to address possible harms, and its potentially enormous costs are not offset by enough clearly identifiable health benefits. Reach would require producers and importers of chemicals and products containing chemicals that are manufactured in or imported into the EU in quantities over one metric ton per year — approximately 30,000 substances — to register them with a new EU agency in Finland, and to provide extensive information on their properties, uses and handling.
While this might seem unobjectionable, some of Reach’s key provisions will apply to chemicals to which there is no human exposure — and thus no possibility of harm. At the same time, the proposal exempts certain highly toxic chemicals where there is serious human exposure and much known existing harm. The latter group includes chemicals such as gasoline and diesel fuels — which, without an exemption, would likely be blacklisted by Reach…
These factors explain why virtually every non-EU country with a chemicals industry has joined the U.S. in voicing serious concerns about Reach. This “coalition of the excluded” includes South Africa, which is worried that Reach will cripple the mining industry in some of the poorest parts of the developing world. At the other end of the spectrum are sophisticated high-tech producers in South Korea, India, Japan and Israel.

(via NRO’s Iain Murray)
More analysis from the Competitive Enterprise Institute;

Currently on the horizon is the proposed EU Chemicals Policy, which represents what will be perhaps the most expansive regulation of the chemical industry ever. Known as REACH—which stands for registration, authorization, and evaluation of chemicals—this directive is likely to cost society billions of dollars, reduce innovation, and limit U.S. access to EU markets. Its protectionist effects are expected to trigger World Trade Organization (WTO) disputes. Meanwhile, the benefits of the proposal are likely to be small given that it attempts to reduce the effects of trace levels of chemicals, which have produced little documented adverse effects on public health.
The EU chemicals policy would employ the so-called precautionary principle by requiring companies to prove that their products are safe before their introduction into commerce. Currently, government officials bear the burden of proof and must prove a product unsafe before removing it from the market. REACH would reverse this burden, demanding that firms conduct extensive tests to demonstrate product safety. Since manufacturers can’t prove anything is 100 percent safe, this policy will likely produce arbitrary bans of many relatively safe substances and discourage innovation.

I can find virtually no mention of this in media, and nothing in the Canadian news services.

Reader Tips

The Blogging Tories have added a new feature – Forums
The Carnival of Liberty (link fixed!)
Turning coal into oil – a 60 year old technology whose time has come.
Yet another source for the blogosphere. Google is adding “the ability to search through more than 200 years of historical newspaper archives”.
The NDP draft policy resolutions make the National Post this morning;

Canada’s troops in Afghanistan have been “acting like terrorists, destroying communities, killing and maiming innocent people”, according to a resolution that will be voted on by New Democrats at the party’s convention in Quebec City this weekend.

Captain Capitalism and the Canadian Invasion.
Add your own in the comments.

Dispatches

From the 5th Annual Defense Forum in Washington, DC;

Today’s keynote speaker was the Vice Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Admiral Edmund Giambastiani, who began by saying, “We are engaged in an “all-hands fight,” and that it requires “friends, allies, and a focus on those who would destroy our way of life.”
Admiral Giambastiani made three main points. First, he shed some light on what he referred to as the “non-kinetic” aspect of the war, and the Navy and Marine Corps contributions to that fight.
“Our success in Iraq and Afghanistan is foremost in our minds, but the Long War is also being fought in the realm of ideas. It is a struggle between extremists and the vast majority of Muslims.” Moreover, he stated that “The struggle within the Muslim community is off-limits to us. It is a struggle among them.” However, he stated, “We do have a tremendous impact in setting the conditions under which this struggle takes place. To the extent that extremists can claim a clash of civilizations, then they receive support within Islam.”
He then drew attention to the details of Indian Ocean Tsunami Relief in 2004 and Pakistani earthquake relief more recently.
Thanks to US military efforts, “the favorite toy in Pakistan today is a Chinook helicopter,” he said. “When US engineering forces left, we left all the heavy equipment behind for the Pakistanis…” along with all of the hospital equipment too.

Related – Check out Damian Brooks at The Torch for a discussion of yesterday’s friendly fire incident, while Cjunk is your best bet for following the day to day reports on both the Canadian Forces progress in Afghanistan and those intent on undermining the mission.

Thanks Jack; I’m sure they toasted you with tea and murmurs of approval in the Taliban caves along the Afghan-Pakistan border. In the mean time, truly honorable men are fighting and dying in the name of freedom and democracy. While Jack plays the socialist hero at home; our true heroes are doing genuine socialist work in Afghanistan by ridding some of the poorest people on earth of the very tyrants who would hold them down forever.

Navigation