Michael Fulmento recently returned from his third tour as an Iraq embed. In this interview with John Hawkins. the first question concerns how few reporters are doing the same;
Yes, it’s preposterous to think that you can cover a country with 26 million people, the size of California, from a hotel room or from the international zone in a single city. Nobody would try to be a Hollywood reporter from Des Moines, Iowa. What if you turned on the news about some catastrophe, like Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans that has been going on a day or so, but the reporter was talking to you from Nome, Alaska? You wouldn’t give it much credence and you shouldn’t give it much credence. The Baghdad Brigade, as I call it, operating out of these hotels — not only would you think that they don’t deserve credence, but time and time again when you look at the stories they write about non-Baghdad areas, you find that they’re wrong.
Hawkins – You don’t have to pull a name out of the hat, but give me an example of that.
This is actually quite important. The Los Angeles Times, right after my next to last embed in April, reported that apparently there was another Fallujah style, Operation Phantom Fury (type attack) about to be carried out any day against Ramadi — and it talked about huge numbers of forces being brought up and this and that — and, of course, we now know it never took place. But, the fact is at the time, there were five reporters listed as chief, secondary, and then contributors. Four were Baghdad-based and one was based in Washington, D.C. So, is it a coincidence that they were completely wrong about this? No, not really. If they had someone in Ramadi, they wouldn’t have written the story. You can’t do these things out of Baghdad and you sure as heck can’t do them out of the District of Columbia (laughs).
Contradicting the prevailing theme, he describes the security situation in Ramadi as greatly improved since he was there six months ago, and is cautiously optimistic about prospects in Iraq.
His comments about the “Baghdad Brigade” are echoed at The Torch, where one of the priorities is auditing the military reporting coming out of Afghanistan;
The real question this focus raises, though, is this: is the attention we’re devoting to Canadian reporting unjustified? Well, not according to at least one member of the press, who expressed the following sentiments to us in private correspondence:
The problem IMHO is that the decisions about such coverage are increasingly being made by editors in Toronto or Ottawa, for reasons wildly unconnected to what’s been going on on the ground there for some time. [Media organization X], for example, insists on using Kandahar as a door prize assignment to hand out to…reporters regardless of their relevant experience (this in one of the most dangerous parts of the world). Many of them have never covered the military, let alone a complex counter-insurgency environment like that of southern Afghanistan, and as a result they mostly stay behind the wire doing “death watch.”
Many of the experienced reporters…who might’ve had the perspective to do stories along the lines that [The Torch] so eloquently outlines, have been sidelined in favour of editors playing [organizational] politics. Personally, I’m so disgusted by the handling of the whole thing I’m not going back to KAF and I’m not the only one who feels this way. The CF’s media strategy and the way they’ve handled the embedding process was and is far from perfect. But the lion’s share of the blame for this distortion of the mission in Afghanistan can’t be laid at their door.
That brings me to something I’ve been noticing lately. The more generalized media auditing that is a primary focus of SDA has prompted a phenomenon of anonymous and defensive comments appearing here from members of the media who attribute misquotes and misrepresentation to their editors, headline writers, even to translaters.
That may all be true. But what is also true is that it doesn’t matter who is responsible. Ignorance, bias, sloppiness, a reluctance to correct false reporting in as aggressive a fashion as it’s first reported – is media malpractice.
Every person who knowingly participates in the release of a flawed product, whether they be the reporter who allows their information to be added to or altered, the editor who ignores a misleading headline, drive-by sneer or burying of the lede – down to the proofreader who realizes that context has being twisted or omitted – all are equally responsible.
Because I make part of my living as an automotive airbrush artist, I spend a good deal of time in automotive body repair shops. It takes a team to restore a damaged vehicle to its original soundness and safety. From the frame straightener to the windshield installer to the paint prep and application, modern automotive body repair is a concert of exacting trades.
Much of it is performed, day in and day out, by people who hold no university degrees. Some aren’t even high school graduates. But, they know their jobs. As craftsmen, they know they will be held responsible for screwing up – but most of all, they understand that everyone who worked on that car shares the consequences when a vehicle is released that fails to meet safety or refinishing standards. Work must be redone. A pattern of faulty workmanship can result in a loss of insurance accreditation.
So, why is it that an industry that produces mere words and facts, that is stacked with university graduates, political celebrities and academics, which serves as a fundamental underpinning of our western democracy, does not hold their members to the standard of performance expected of a nameless welder in an auto repair shop?
How is it that reporters and editors can fail so profoundly, so routinely, with such utter internal unaccountability – and not lose their accreditation to issue a newspaper or news broadcast?
This brings me to the third item in this post, and back to Iraq reporting. The questioning of the source for the Associated Press “six Sunni worshippers burned alive” story (mentioned in previous posts here and here) is now the subject of a column by Boston Herald city editor Jules Crittenden. And he cuts right to the chase;
The Associated Press is embroiled in a scandal. Conservative bloggers, the new media watchdogs, lifted a rock at the AP.
Curt at Floppingaces, www.floppingaces2.blogspot.com, led the charge. He thought there was something strange about an AP report, and took a second look at it, then a third look. He and others blew the lid off it. The AP is making up war crimes. But the resulting stink in the blogosphere has barely wrinkled a nose in the mainstream press. The ethics-obsessed Poynter Institute seems to be oblivious to it.
It has to do with the AP’s Iraqi stringers and an oft-quoted Iraqi police captain named Jamil Hussein. Problem is, the Iraqi police say Capt. Hussein does not exist. The Iraqi police and U.S. military say an incident described in an AP report – Iraqi soldiers standing by as people were burned alive in a mosque – didn’t happen. Another AP-reported incident, U.S. soldiers shooting 11 civilians, also never happened, the military says.
When the AP was forced to acknowledge this situation, it did so in a story about a new Interior Ministry policy regarding false reports. The AP buried the fact that its own false report prompted this new policy.
The AP stands by its reporting.. The AP has cast “Capt. Jamil Hussein” simply as someone not authorized to speak, and AP Executive Editor Kathleen Carroll has sniffed morally: “Good reporting relies on more than government-approved sources.”
The AP has another Iraqi stringer problem. Photographer Bilal Hussein is in U.S. custody, and the AP has been clamoring indignantly for his release. AP reports have buried the U.S. explanation that Hussein is being held without charge because – quite aside from producing photos that showed him to be overly intimate with terrorists in Fallujah – he was in an al-Qaeda bomb factory, with an al-Qaeda bombmaker, with traces of explosives on his person when he was arrested.
The AP, of course, has been delivering unbalanced reports about U.S. national politics for some time, as when President Bush, whom AP reporters despise, is barely allowed to state his case on an issue before his critics are given twice as much space to pummel him. The AP, once a just-the-facts news delivery service, has lost its rudder. It has become a partisan, anti-American news agency that seeks to undercut a wartime president and American soldiers in the field. It is providing fraudulent, shoddy goods. It doesn’t even recognize it has a problem.
And apparently, neither do the media sources that you and I rely on for our news. From the CBC National to the news-talk radio stations – much of their information on foreign current events originates with the Associated Press. They simply cannot have missed this story – I see their ip addresses in my logfiles.
The original story was widely reported in Canada – why have we not heard that a controversy exists?
The Iraqi stringer issue is just the latest in a serious of questioned reports. Others are currently questioning whether the AP may be working with Al Jazeera.
That elements of the US media are slowly beginning to acknowledge the problem openly is a beginning. The question is – with a Canadian media so invested in anti-Americanism as both an ideology and marketing device, how long will we wait before the minority who are diligent, who do their research properly, who recognize the bias, the misreporting, the under-reporting, are willing to move the extra step and take their complaints beyond anonymous comments and private emails to bloggers?
(Related – The future of journalism doesn’t look any brighter.)
By request – Democracy Project has a listing of the AP Board of Directors.
UPDATE – Bill Roggio is back embedded in Iraq. (The same Bill Roggio who reported on the Canadian media “death watch” while embedded with our Canadian Forces a few months ago) His post covers the soldiers’ take on “balcony reporting”. They feel the press has “abandoned them” and small wonder, when the only good soldier these days is a flag draped “victim”;
What a terrible situation to be in, having to defend yourself because of your profession. I’ve always said that the hardest thing about embedding (besides leaving my family) is wearing the badge that says ‘PRESS.’ That hasn’t changed. I hide the badge whenever I can get away with it.
This isn’t the first time I encountered this sentiment from the troops. I experienced this attitude from the Marines while I was in western Iraq last year, and the soldiers in the Canadian Army in Afghanistan also expressed frustration with the media’s presentation of the war.
Another independent, so hit his paypal button if you can.
Dec.4 Update – New York Times Baghdad correspondent Ed Wong questioned the legitimacy of the AP report when it originally broke;
Hi Tom,
You ask me about what our own reporting shows about this incident. When we first heard of the event on Nov. 24, through the A.P. story and a man named Imad al-Hashemi talking about it on television, we had our Iraqi reporters make calls to people in the Hurriya neighborhood. Because of the curfew that day, everything had to be done by phone. We reached several people who told us about the mosque attacks, but said they had heard nothing of Sunni worshippers being burned alive. Any big news event travels quickly by word of mouth through Baghdad, aided by the enormous proliferation of cell phones here. Such an incident would have been so abominable that a great many of the residents in Hurriya, as well as in other Sunni Arab districts, would have been in an uproar over it. Hard-line Sunni Arab organizations such as the Muslim Scholars Association or the Iraqi Islamic Party would almost certainly have appeared on television that day or the next to denounce this specific incident. Iraqi clerics and politicians are not shy about doing this. Yet, as far as I know, there was no widespread talk of the incident. So I mentioned it only in passing in my report.
Best,
Ed Wong
Dec. 20 Updates: Michelle Malkin is still digging.