John Burns With Hugh Hewitt

“… he’s reported from Afghanistan under the Taliban, and after their overthrow, and he’s reported from Iraq under Saddam, and after his overthrow.”

HH: Mr. Burns, in reviewing the Charlie Rose interview, as well as the one you did with Bill Maher in March of 2006, I was struck by two statements. To Bill Maher, I’m paraphrasing, yes, the Americans made a whole bunch of mistakes in the occupation, but if we fail, it won’t be because of those mistakes, and to Charlie Rose, the statement that when Iraqis sit down and talk with you in calm situations, the vast majority of people still believe they are better off with Saddam, under Saddam. Nothing was possible, it was frozen. Those two statements are extraordinary. You don’t hear them very much. Can you expand on them?

A good interview, but it’s astonishing to me that a reporter with the reputation and experience of the New York Times’ John Burns, covering a city in which foreign correspondants are virtually non-existent, has only a passing awareness of the work of independent imbeds like Bill Roggio. Or Michael Yon.

The ambulance headed down the road, stopping in a densely populated warren of narrow streets and alleys. The ambulance stopped, and some men flushed out toward the flashing lights, apparently also completely unaware that American troops had converged on the scene. LTC Welsh’s simple plan had worked, and either the driver truly didn’t seem to realize we had followed him, or, perhaps he was just an honest ambulance driver picking up people who happened to be injured in some non-combat fashion while most people were sleeping.
This was fantastically dangerous: about eight men piled out of that alley, two of whom were obviously wounded, and booked toward the ambulance. By now, the enemy knows we have their POOs. Name it, it could all be there waiting in ambush: suicide vests, grenades in pockets, knives up sleeves, RPGs, IEDs planted along the roads to blow us into little pieces.
photo-8.jpg

Two lengthy pieces from quite different reporting perspectives in Iraq, both worth your time.

Last Refuge of The Bigot

Western Europe’s America Problem;

Ambivalence, antipathy, and resentment toward and about the United States have made up an important component of European culture since the American Revolution, thus way before America became the world’s “Mr. Big” — the proverbial 800-pound gorilla — and a credible rival to Europe’s main powers, particularly Britain and France. In recent years, following the end of the cold war, and particularly after 9/11, ambivalence in some quarters has given way to unambiguous hostility. Animosity toward the United States has migrated from the periphery and become a respectable part of the European mainstream.
Negative sentiments and views have been driven not only — or even primarily — by what the United States does, but rather by an animus against what Europeans have believed that America is. While the politics, style, and discourse of the Bush terms — and of President Bush as a person — have undoubtedly exacerbated anti-American sentiment among Europeans and fostered a heretofore unmatched degree of unity between elite and mass opinion in Europe, they are not anti-Americanism’s cause. Indeed, a change to a center-left administration in Washington, led by a Democratic president, would not bring about its abatement, let alone its disappearance.
Anti-Americanism constitutes a particular prejudice that renders it not only acceptable but indeed commendable in the context of an otherwise welcome discourse that favors the weak. Just as in the case of any prejudice, anti-Americanism also says much more about those who hold it than about the object of its ire and contempt. But where it differs markedly from “classical” prejudices — such as anti-Semitism, homophobia, misogyny, and racism — is in the dimension of power. Jews, gays and lesbians, women, and ethnic minorities rarely if ever have any actual power in or over the majority populations or the dominant gender of most countries. However, the real, existing United States does have considerable power, which has increasingly assumed a global dimension since the end of the 19th century, and which has, according to many scholarly analyses, become unparalleled in human history.
While other public prejudices, particularly against the weak, have — in a fine testimony to progress and tolerance over the past 40 years — become largely illegitimate in the public discourse of most advanced industrial democracies (the massive change in the accepted language over the past three decades in those societies about women, gays, the physically challenged, minorities of all kinds, and animals, to name but a few, has been nothing short of fundamental), nothing of the sort pertains to the perceived and the actually strong. Thus anti-Americanism not only remains acceptable in many circles but has even become commendable, a badge of honor, and perhaps one of the most distinct icons of what it means to be a progressive these days.

Required reading.
Although the article is written from a European perspective, one can’t help but hear its echo in the pervasive “damned if they do, damned if they don’t” anti-Americanism that has mestasticized into the highest levels of the Canadian political discourse.

Reader Tips

“So what is the big problem with the photo? No, it’s not Photoshopped. No, that really is Khatami. But it’s not what you think“.
Calmly

… the Sheik watched as the Marines detained the two young men in the house, volunteering that if they were “bad guys” he was happy to see them go. “You and I are going to find a way to work together to make this area better,” he told Lt Friel, “like Ramadi.” The Sheik added that it was “Iranians and foreigners” who were destabilizing his tribal area. “Iranians are forcing out the doctors and teachers. Soon this town will look like Afghanistan.”

Bill Roggio – progress in the hunt for al-Masri.
“Stephane Dion’s Green Scarf politics may turn out to be the most boneheaded strategy since Paul Martin decided to go on his Adscam apology tour.”
Read this. Then ask yourself how it would have been written, had this RCMP officer been a man.
Add yours in the comments.

WaPo: “Sexing Up” The Evidence

Redstate explains;

The article, by Walter Pincus and R. Jeffrey Smith, purported to summarize the conclusions of a report by the Pentagon’s inspector general, beginning with the news that..

Intelligence provided by former undersecretary of defense Douglas J. Feith to buttress the White House case for invading Iraq included ‘reporting of dubious quality or reliability’ that supported the political views of senior administration officials rather than the conclusions of the intelligence community . . .

[…] take a look at the whopper of a correction the Post has posted, essentially recanting the entire thing.

A Feb. 9 front-page article about the Pentagon inspector general’s report regarding the office of former undersecretary of defense Douglas J. Feith incorrectly attributed quotations to that report. References to Feith’s office producing “reporting of dubious quality or reliability” and that the office “was predisposed to finding a significant relationship between Iraq and al Qaeda” were from a report issued by Sen. Carl Levin (D-Mich.) in Oct. 2004. Similarly, the quotes stating that Feith’s office drew on “both reliable and unreliable reporting” to produce a link between al-Qaeda and Iraq “that was much stronger than that assessed by the IC [Intelligence Community] and more in accord with the policy views of senior officials in the Administration” were also from Levin’s report. The article also stated that the intelligence provided by Feith’s office supported the political views of senior administration officials, a conclusion that the inspector general’s report did not draw.

Oops.
Ed Morrissey looks at what the report does say; “They Were For Dissent And Alternative Analysis Before They Were Against It”
Feb 12 Update– Less an error than an agenda. The inside story on what happened doesn’t look good on Walter Pincus, or the Post.

Y2Kyoto: Maurice And The Media

Finally. Maurice Strong is plopped front and center in the Kyoto debate, and in a Canadian newspaper. That said, there’s the sense of an editorial black pen at work;

The Liberals’ commitment to Kyoto is economic suicide, and I believe that the whole exercise was cynical and a favour to Liberal insider Maurice Strong.
Now the Liberals are leading a charge to force the Tories to live up to commitments that the Liberals never did in four years. That’s because they realized the commitments were not realistic.
But Kyoto wasn’t renegotiated because Mr. Strong is a buddy of former Prime Ministers Jean Chretien and Paul Martin. When he was involved in United Nations operations, he organized the UN’s Earth Summit to deal with pollution. He asked for, and got, Canada’s unconditional support for Kyoto.

Bless Diane Francis and whatever God granted her the ovaries lacking in the rest of Canadian media. Even our local radio talk hosts cut callers off when they try to bring his name into the debate, citing “conspiracy theories”.
They must not read the Wall Street Journal.

Bruce Montague

Via email;

“On October 5, 2005, the Canadian Government led at the time by the Liberals, took their first steps in court to seize the home of Bruce and
Donna Montague. This was done in response to their constitutional challenge of Canada’s failed “gun control laws”. Is this any less terrorism and tyranny? You might expect this to happen in some backwater third world country but this is taking place right now in Ontario, Canada!
For more details, click on www.brucemontague.ca
To help in the fight to eliminate Bill C68, there is an online petition here.

Chinese Threaten Not To… Er….

Take our money in exchange for goods, I guess. And finally, someone with the guts to point it out to them;

HALIFAX – Prime Minister Stephen Harper warned China today not to
threaten Canada on economic issues in the hope of getting his government to back off on human rights criticisms, including the case of Huseyin Celil.
Speaking with reporters in Halifax, Mr. Harper suggested China has more to lose if the economic relationship between the two countries becomes fractured.
“I would point out to any Chinese official that just as a matter of fact, China had a huge trade surplus with this country so it would be in the interest of the Chinese government to make sure any dealings on trade are fair and above board,” he said.

Brace yourselves for mewling from the “progressives” on benches opposite that the government is displaying an alarming lack of moral cowardice.

Prison Abuse In Afghanistan: Con’t

More reader abuse at home;

Now Attaran and his pet journo at the Globe and Mail say [Commander Denise LaViolette] tried to intimidate the Ottawa legal beagle.
You want intimidation? How about a media-hungry activist leaving a message after hours for the senior policeman in an active investigation? Since Koring declined to reveal it in his article, I wonder what Attaran said in his message? Specifically, I wonder what would make an experienced Public Affairs Officer return such a message with a witness present?
Ask yourself: if this were any other police force undergoing any other internal investigation, how appropriate would it be for a lawyer who initiated the original complaint to call the chief of the force up late at night?
In fact, speaking of intimidation, I’d like to know what else you would call a journalist putting up an article on the front page of one of the most influential and respected newspapers in all of Canada – the cream of the crap, as it were – that spanks the military for one officer daring to question the motives of its accuser. Koring and Attaran might as well have said “We’re the inquisitors here, not you.” This story is intended to put the CF back firmly in its supposed place.

More at Flit;

Damned if you do…
“It is inexcusable that they [the military] have not investigated. This is not right.”
–Afghan detainees’ rights advocate and law professor Amir Attaran, Feb. 7, on allegations that an Afghan detained at an apparent bomb-making facility received superficial injuries while resisting attempts to take him into custody.
“In light of what happened a decade ago in Somalia, I very much doubt that [the military] should investigate internally.”
–Attaran again, Feb. 8, upon hearing that the military had immediately launched separate criminal and administrative inquiries into his allegations.

Amir Attaran has a long history.
Update –

“Good questions, Mr. Brooks. In reply, I’d point out GUANTANAMO, and furthermore ABU GHRAIB SOMALIA AIRBORNE DOGS GENITALS CIGARETTE BURNS HUMILIATION. I hope that answers your questions.”

Program Update – Damian Brooks will be on with Breakenridge tonight at 8:40 EST.

The Jihad Goes Low Tech

Jules Crittenden;

Now, the audience is Europe’s Muslims, hence the plan to abduct and
behead British Muslims. Europe has been teetering on the brink of open ethnic warfare for some time, with brief outbursts in France. The al-Qaeda leadership isolated in their Waziri caves and dodging Hellfire missiles in Anbar apparently have just figured out that they can influence this situation. They’ve also figured out this blowing up planes thing isn’t working out for them.

Affirmative Autocracy

When women can’t win nomination the old fashioned way, enter the Liberal sugar-daddy;

Liberal Leader Stephane Dion is prepared to take “extraordinary measures” to boost the ranks of women candidates in the next election, including barring men from seeking nominations in some ridings.
During last year’s leadership race, Dion promised that under his watch at least a third of the party’s candidates in the next election would be women.
But campaign organizers have concluded that the ambitious goal will be impossible to reach without some intervention to secure nominations for female candidates.

This guy is just a gift that keeps on giving…

“I really don’t know whether we’ll be printing the Times in five years…”

Haaretz;

Why would the man behind the New York Times be stressed? Well, profits from the paper have been declining for four years, and the Times company’s market cap has been shrinking, too. Its share lags far behind the benchmark, and just last week, the group Sulzberger leads admitted suffering a $570 million loss because of write offs and losses at the Boston Globe.
As if that weren’t enough, his personal bank, Morgan Stanley, recently set out on a campaign that could cost the man control over the paper.
All this may explain why Sulzberger does not talk with the press.

The article focuses on a probable transition from print to internet publishing at the NYT, as though the meltdown of the newspaper publishing industry (which saw 13.5B in market value evaporate in the last two years) is simply the result of consumer preference for faster information delivery – the problem not the product, but the platform.
What isn’t mentioned is that while the New York Times, and other distinguished organs of the mainstream press have been bleeding circulation, another was inexplicably moving in a different direction;

The New York Post today surpassed the Daily News and The Washington Post to become the 5th largest newspaper in America after bucking the national trend and chalking up a whopping 5.1 percent jump in circulation.

Sulzberger makes an open admission;

There are millions of bloggers out there, and if the Times forgets who and what they are, it will lose the war, and rightly so, according to Sulzberger. “We are curators, curators of news. People don’t click onto the New York Times to read blogs. They want reliable news that they can trust,” he says.
“We aren’t ignoring what’s happening. We understand that the newspaper is not the focal point of city life as it was 10 years ago.
“Once upon a time, people had to read the paper to find out what was going on in theater. Today there are hundreds of forums and sites with that information,” he says. “But the paper can integrate material from bloggers and external writers. We need to be part of that community and to have dialogue with the online world.”

And with that, reveals (like so many who argue the false premise that “blogs will never replace the mainstream media”) that he still doesn’t fully comprehend what is happening to his industry.
Those “bloggers and external writers” aren’t an “online world”. Blogs, forums and other resources of the internet are a platform, a pathway for information transmission – but they are tools of the individual, not the collective.
The “external writers” Sulzberger sees are not competitors. They’re his industry’s former subscribers – media consumers no longer interested in recieving politically-filtered news from the bottom end of a one-way pipe, who no longer tolerate interference by self-appointed gatekeepers who view information as their exlusive property to frame, sanitize, analyze, and interpret as they see fit,
It’s not a war, Mr. Sulzberger. It’s a revolt.

Mark Holland’s Cirque De Syncrude

Via David Akin, paraphrased;

He was for “consequences” for the oil industry before he was against nationalization, before he was for “limits” on oil sands expansion before he was against limiting expansion, before he was for a “cap” on oil sands emissions before he was against a cap on expansion, before he was against growth of the auto industry plant in his home riding that has no hope in Hell of expanding, and he is for Albertans who are also for him.

Faster, please.
Another, somewhat longer transcript. Holland’s serpentine backpedalling act was nearly as good on Mike Duffy Live.
Update – Conservative MP Diane Ablonczy (Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Finance, CPC) : “Mr. Speaker, a Liberal has slipped up and given Canadians a glimpse of the Liberal’s secret agenda.”
Previous posts.

Y2Kyoto: If You Don’t Like Our Methodology

Wait five minutes;

In evaluating industrial impact, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change used GDP estimates based on exchange rates rather than purchasing power: As a result, they assume by the year 2100 that not only South Africans but also North Koreans will have a higher per capita income than Americans. That’s why the climate-change computer models look scary. That’s how “solid” the science is: It’s predicated on the North Korean economy overtaking the United States.

Friday update – Cosh explains.

Navigation