What Would We Do Without Peer Review?

WUWT;

Appearing yesterday in Science magazine online is the news that “A U.S. federal judge has ordered the OMICS International publishing group to pay $50.1 million in damages for deceiving thousands of authors who published in its journals and attended its conferences…

h/t Paul

19 Replies to “What Would We Do Without Peer Review?”

  1. The problem is how academe functions nowadays.

    Part of an academic’s job is to bring in external funding. That’s one source of revenue from which university departments use for their operations, even though they are supported by the government. But, in order to qualify for that money, one needs to convey to the funding agency that one is productive and will put that cash to good use.

    The chances of being funded increases with the number of publications one adds to one’s CV. Consequently, some academics will find ways of doing that. They can, for example, slice and dice their data sets so that they can produce several mediocre papers when, if they had used all of their results, they could have written one or two really good ones. (There’s another reason for that. More publications means that the number of citations one receives increases and, thereby, raises one’s visibility with one’s peers.)

    One reason why happens can be summed up in one word: tenure, namely the promise of having a job for life, along with a seat at the golden hog trough. Abolish that, and many of the shenanigans one reads about will end very quickly.

  2. If this is the status in the Medical Profession, imagine the quackery in the Climate FAKE Sciences. I keep saying AGW or whatever they call it today is the Greatest Fraud ever put upon the people and they should all be jailed for the Billions and Billions defrauded from the Taxpayers by the Greasy Politicians and their Globalist Handlers. The Lancet here claims as much as 50% of all Medical Papers are Bogus and a Fraud. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(15)60696-1/fulltext?rss%253%20Dyes

    1. Agreed! There has been ZERO scientific PROOF of global warming caused by the burning of fossil fuels. NONE. The computer models, and statistical manipulation are NOT science … let alone scientific proof of anything. It’s all a LIE.

    2. “If this is the status in the Medical Profession”

      Pfft! The Medical Profession has always had for too much prestige and status compared to it’s real world efficacy and results.
      That’s why they have abrogated unto themselves the sole power to be the gatekeepers of drugs regardless of whether or not
      they have properly diagnosed the patient’s illness. It’s the real working drugs that should get the credit, not the Medical Profession in general.
      Half of the Doctors out there graduated at the bottom of their classes, you know.

  3. If the scientific scientists were the Catholic Church, they would burn these heretics at the stake … any activity that misinterprets results is a delusion of belief in science … Old Testament justice knew what it was up against and knew what it was doing. False prophets were stoned.

    1. Sheeesh that didn’t take long. 4 comments in and god shows up in a peer review thread…..

        1. Sheeesh, I’m hardly a stand in for NME666. He’s in a league of his own. I have a better sense of humour……ha – to prove it I’d recommend a little tune – just to keep things light.

          “Bible on the Dash” by Corb Lund

  4. What good does Peer Review do when the whole pool are made up of Village Idiots… Science doesn’t depend on an uneducated consensus that claim that “The Science is Settled” Refuse to debate or engage unbelievers… A MSM that only allows one side to dominate the issue…

    AGW is NOT Science in any perverted form, it is a Communist action command.. The Zionist method (early 1917) defined by Lenin & Marx to dominate a ONE world Government… YES! Communism is a Zionist construct of the early 1900’s

    JMHO

    JMHO

    1. You were doing real good until the Zionist silliness. Put a leash on that shit and you’ll influence people. Really.

      1. Zionism during the early 1900’s is not the same definition of todays Zionism in Israel… The Zionism of the Communist Jews like Lenin & Marx.. George Soros has nothing to do with the traditional religion of Judaism in Israel….Zionism has been redefined today… It was the Communist Zionism that formed the negative view of Jews by the general public in England, Canada & USA during WWI and following WWII…..

        JMHO

  5. Why should the scientific charlatans and CAGW rent seekers and political opportunists have all the fun? NASA started it all.
    NOAA and NASA have been fabricating the climate record for decades, the only hot air coming from their “models.”
    If the data doesn’t support the hypothesis – dump the hypothesis – no check that, alter the data to support the hypothesis.
    Thermometer readings are subject to interpretation, right? Models show warming is higher than required, no wait, “expected.”

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pgk3xFHvWLE

    1. When taking college physics courses … there was a massive no-no that the instructor could usually detect. It was called “dry-labbing”. When the experiment didn’t come out the way it should have … as was predicted … you’d simply go home and fudge the numbers. You would simply rewrite (change) the actual experimental results. If the experiment didn’t turn out as it should … the professor would want you to learn WHY. What did you do wrong that tainted the results. If you just faked it all … you’d never learn. The CAGW “scientists” haven’t learned. It’s ALL fake! The Godfather of CAGW … Michael Mann is using the courts to block access to his “research”. He is so afraid of “showing his work” … because he’ll be discovered to be a FRAUDSTER … a SHYSTER … a LIAR … and an incompetent “scientist”. All the CAGW gravy trainers have learned is propaganda … and government funding. They’re all expert at … “dry-labbing” their “science”

        1. The only science they’re sharing is science fiction. Faith, delusion, self-interest, bigotry, ideology – but never science.

  6. Science is the new Religion. You want to sell some sort of new shit on TV, BOOM, you get your actor to wear a Lab coat.
    From his/her mouth to god’s ear. Seriously, this ain’t New. Bolshevism and Nazism both sold their ideologies as Scientific.

    Know what the Opium of the Masses is? Science. Yeah, Science has even created Opium on Steroids, *”Fentanyl”*!!!11!1Yay!

    1. So very, very, true. I am mocked for believing in a “sky daddy” … by the folks who WORSIP Elon Musk as the Messiah. Ridiculous.

  7. Why am I reminded of Trofim Lysenko when I think of much of what passes for science these days.

  8. I am baffled by this story.
    Why are these fine publishers being persecuted?
    They merely provided a timely service perfect for the state of Academia.
    Publish or perish is now a staple of the Dark Halls of Academia,churning out credentials for all.
    Shit, a modern doctorate is almost as valuable as a BreX share.
    The whiners who felt “ripped off” by these “predatory publishers” got exactly what they paid for.

Navigation