Why Britain Struggles To Assimilate Immigrants

When the concept of “multiculturalism” was introduced to Canadians, most assumed it meant more pavilions at Folkfest…

A third of London’s residents were born outside Britain, a higher percentage of newcomers than in any other city in the world except Miami, and the percentage continues to rise. Likewise, migration figures for the country as a whole—emigration and immigration—suggest that its population is undergoing swift replacement. Many of the newcomers are from Pakistan, India, and Africa; others are from Eastern Europe and China. If present trends continue, experts predict, in 20 years’ time, between a quarter and a third of the British population will have been born outside it, and at least a fifth of the native population will have emigrated. Britain has always had immigrants—from the French Huguenots after the revocation of the Edict of Nantes to Germans fleeing Prussian repression, from Jews escaping czarist oppression to Italian prisoners of war who stayed on after World War II—and absorbed them. But never so many, or so quickly.
To the anxiety about these unprecedented demographic changes—a substantial majority of the public, when asked, says that it wants a dramatic reduction in immigration—one can add a reticence in openly expressing it. Inducing this hesitancy are intellectuals of the self-hating variety, who welcome the destruction of the national identity and who argue—in part, correctly—that every person’s identity is multiple; that identity can and ought to change over time; and that too strong an emphasis on national identity has in the past led to barbarism. By reiteration, they have insinuated a sense of guilt into everyone’s mind, so that even to doubt the wisdom or viability of a society consisting of myriad ethnic and religious groups with no mutual sympathy (and often with mutual antagonisms) is to suspect oneself of sliding toward extreme nationalism or fascism; so that even to doubt the wisdom or viability of a society in which everyone feels himself part of an oppressed minority puts one in the same category as Jean-Marie Le Pen, or worse.

h/t Penny

29 Replies to “Why Britain Struggles To Assimilate Immigrants”

  1. I don’t know why everyone is so excited about Iran obtaining a nucleur bomb. In about 30-40 years Europe will be mostly Muslim and as such wii be the government of European countries….alas, then they will have the bomb….now that is scary…

  2. The same people who think assimilation of native Indians in Canada would be a disgrace welcome the assimilation of British culture to foreigners.

  3. don’t know why everyone is so excited about Iran obtaining a nucleur bomb. In about 30-40 years Europe will be mostly Muslim and as such wii be the government of European countries….alas, then they will have the bomb….now that is scary…

  4. ohh I thought Toronto was the most ethnically diverse city in the world.

  5. When I have guests or tenants in my home, I expect those guests (immigrants) to understand one thing and one thing only. MY HOUSE, MY RULES!!!!! No exeptions.

  6. I’m not doubting that stat about Miami, but I’d like to see the documentation. And any of you Brit or Canadian refugees are most welcome here in the Magic City. As I tell my worried family in PA-
    If Miami is good enough for discerning citizens of color, it’s good enough for us white guys, too.

  7. My neighbours and wife are of dutch descent, while my other neighbour is of polish extraction.
    I don’t taser them when they ask for help with their computer.
    When I ‘invade my neighbours’ it is usually to borrow a lawnmower or weedeater and I am fully ‘armed’ with beer.
    I think this is the “democratic Canadian” way.
    Cheers
    Hans-Christian Georg Rupprecht
    Commander in Chief
    1st Saint Nicolaas Army
    Army Group “True North”

  8. Another in a succession of thoughtful essays by Theodore Dalrymple. Immigration clearly needs to be carefully managed, and the cultural relativism that sees no difference between the West and various totalitarian regimes needs to be seen for what it is: juvenile posturing.
    Mike Larsen: Your vision is indeed rather disturbing, but I am cautiously hopeful that European resistance to a cultural takeover will stiffen. In my own country, the New York Times (of all newspapers) recently ran an article about a Belgian Muslim woman who, while operating a website supporting Al Qaeda, cynically accepts welfare payments and exploits Belgium’s legal scruples. I found it surprising that the Times would print this article at all. In general, I think I’ve detected a slight lessening of the MSM’s tolerance for Muslim aggressiveness and a greater willingness to call a spade a spade.

  9. Hans: I liked your post. Should your Polish neighbor ask how HE might best arm himself when invading YOUR property, I suggest that you recommend a platter of meat-based perogie (chopped meat and onions, to be precise). If invaded by a force so armed, I think I would offer little resistance.

  10. If one ever needed better proof that immigration was a tool of the globalist socialists to destroy nationalism this difficult to beat.

  11. Britain is in a unique position. It doesn’t just have to kow tow to its own liberals, it also has to bow and scrape before the German and French Eurocrats in Brussels. So reform all they want at home, but even after they get everyone behind substantive immigration reform, they’ll still need to face off with Europe and its 20 different immigration systems, all feeding economic mercenaries into Britain.
    I can see why so many Britons just say ‘sod it’ and emigrate.

  12. I find it unbelievable that any First World democratic country would even consider curtailing its laws, murder for example to accommodate other cultural ideologies and practices! Who is training who here?
    Politicians and court magistrates should be held accountable for treason to even make such a suggestion. Their crime should be subject to life in prison if not death for such an irresponsible attempt to commit their own people to such genocide.
    The sickening hatred of the left of their own culture and peoples is indeed an embarrassing afterbirth of our societies success. Our pampered wealthy societies have allowed a comfortable petri dish for these people to flourish unmolested and unchecked in our midst, spreading their mental disorders and infecting our indigenous populations. The madness needs to end now, or we will forever be lost as a great and free people by the tide of totalitarian slavers welcomed in by the cancerous liberal left excesses of our success.

  13. There will come a point, you understand, where there will be a huge ‘bang’ and not a whimper..when the native populations of these countries have had enough, and start to get behind and follow far right nationalist parties..it is happening in France, in Holland, In Denmark,Switzerland, Sweden, Norway, and of course our old friend Germany.
    It will get very bloody and messy indeed..but these nation’s people will not go down without a fight, win or lose.

  14. “Britain has always had immigrants—from the French Huguenots after the revocation of the Edict of Nantes to Germans fleeing Prussian repression, from Jews escaping czarist oppression to Italian prisoners of war who stayed on after World War II—and absorbed them.”
    There is a vast cultural gulf between the immigrants to Britain from a bygone era and the present. Europeans have always got on without majore incident – and continue to do so despite the usual carping about Polish workers.
    Even the older generation of “Imperial” immigrants – Asians and Caribbean blacks – got on despite considerable prejudice against them because they understood, and subscribed to, the essential civic demands of being British.
    Indeed, there is often quite an ironical clash of generations in the British Pakistani community. It is the older generation of immigrants who are usually most accommodating of wider British society and are completely baffled by their British-born grandsons’ militant Islamism.

  15. Kursk, I think you are incorrect. The children and teens of today have already been completely brainwashed in surrender mentality, moral relativism, and have no sense of nationalism. The EU is coming fast and will crush all opposition. There is no one in Europe who can resist the EU, and they will ensure that there is no opposition to any social changes they dictate.
    The pathetic generation that is reading adulthood now is incapable of resisting the 3rd world hordes that are coming by their thousands every day. They do not understand the threat of the EU.
    The only ones putting up resistance now are the older generation who remember Stalin, and Hitler, and of course the usual white supremacist thugs. The “cream” of today’s youth, the mainstream educated individuals, including our future leaders, have no sense of nationality, no knowledge of history, and will never be a part of any resistance.
    I think the blood shed will be little indeed, and that the world is headed for a dystopian future that only some of the science fiction writers of the past 50 years have predicted.
    My hope is that North America will see the unfolding disaster in Europe in time to make the changes to permit some survival of a Western Civilization here.

  16. Lori:
    I am a afraid your right. You remember those Women who where shoot in Montreal? The men walked away, no one tried to even rush the Women hating monster. They just left the Women to be killed which they where. To this day 70% or more justify the boy’s ( I refuse to call them men) behavior. Try to rationalize this cowardice of the highest degree. At any other time in history these boy’s would have been ostracized if not hung for cowardice. You see for most of history people thought some things where worth dying for. Even when they had life spans as short as a monkey‘s with plague. Obviously except for the few who go into the armed forces, or those with convictions of right or wrong, religious or not. In this type of society all fall down to excuse the inexcusable . Those who deem ethics as a mental connivance or rationalization for promoting themselves falsely for gain. After all it situational to act according to others expectations to attain the objective of personnel craving.
    Now if its that bad here, just guess how Foreign anti-western cultural immigration coupled with ignorance, married to moral relativism have warped Britain‘s youth into nihilism. I hope watching the eventual shock show over there, will preserve some modicum of freedom on this Continent from shear revulsion.
    Not many will fight because most have no principles at all, except saving there own skins.
    They have lost the will to civilization.
    Just my opinion

  17. Canada’s immigrants are so well assimilated I see:
    “This is in our religion and nobody can force us to do anything against our religion,” he said. “If the laws of the country conflict with Islamic law, if one goes against the other, then I am going to follow Islamic law, simple as that.”
    http://www.thestar.com/News/GTA/article/429490
    The guy should be in Pakistan, and tomorrow morning wouldn’t be soon enough.

  18. There is a professor from Germany who comes each year to Canada and he focuses on the demographics of what is happening in Europe. As he points out the rapid aging of their population with the concomitant muslim immigration and their huge families will spell the end of Europe as we know it. The young Europeans are emigrating to North America, Australia and New Zealand as they can see the writing on the wall.
    As this trend continues he says there will be no Europeans to militarily challenge the muslim tide as the remnants will be too old. As he also pointed out these muslim immigrants are coming not to work but to take advantage of the socialism of Europe with its welfare. They are for the most part uneducated and have no interest in assimilating into western culture.
    Remember as Hirsi Ali states and writes muslims hate our culture. They with their leftist allies like Bin Layton will end our civilization if we do nothing. Each day I see more and more headscarfs on my travels around Toronto.

  19. Lori>
    I also agree with your assessment. We are like frogs sitting in warm water waiting patiently as it heats to a boil. Europe is the distinct barometer that we can judge our own public reactions, as we overlook the obvious debasement of our society and smile thinking that we are helping a world of “people just like us”.
    This is a farce of course, and anyone who has legitimately traveled and spent time in the countries we are so keen to displace our populations with, knows what I’m saying.
    We are viewed by the greater world of humanity as a weak and impotent race of undeserving pushovers. We are considered gullible, spiritually defunct and transparently shallow. This is not even the extremist point of view, simply the average Joe on the block sitting in his Internet café attempting to swindle a Canadian passport and citizenship for the well-known overseas total of $10,000.00USD.
    The only cavalry coming over the hill to save what we call our way of life, will be when aware Canadians watch the dismemberment of European countries – well enough ahead of course of the Islamic beachhead that is already landed on our shores. Hopefully once sensible Canadians see the ethnic British vacancy on that once proud island, and the open bloodshed flowing in the sewers of Paris and Amsterdam, we might stand up for our rights to exist as a Judeo-Christian European founded nation. That would make us an extremely unique society on this planet of totalitarian rule.

  20. Europeans, and God only knows the spine density left with them, have to survive two cancers, their fascists elite in Brussels sucking all of the oxygen out of their freedoms and Islam firmly planted and protected on their soil.
    I’m with Mark Steyn that by the time the passive and always historically disappointing Eurosheeple take stock of their ridiculous situation it will be far too late. These are people that we have had to wrench twice from their past fascist follies.
    I’m just finishing a book, “A Crime So Monstrous”, about the modern day slave trade in which the Arabs, once you are past Haiti, play a prominent role. Here’s the first chapter. Who really are sickening are the Dutch whose amorality and degenerate decadence puts them at the top of the heap in Europe as a sex slave trade haven. They deserve every burqa on so many levels that they get sown into.
    I’ll maybe change my low opinion of Europeans they day we see mass demonstrations on their streets.

  21. Knight 99: “I find it unbelievable that any First World democratic country would even consider curtailing its laws, murder for example to accommodate other cultural ideologies and practices!”
    Lori: “The only ones putting up resistance now are the older generation who remember Stalin, and Hitler, and of course the usual white supremacist thugs.”
    The reality is this:
    “The older generation” lived with faith in God. Most of the older generation grew up in families where family, faith, country were paramount. God and Church were not outdated concepts but daily realities, whose tenets people lived by: Love your neighbour as yourself (and between the lines: Know your enemy, know who s/he/it is, and do something about it).
    The West reminds me of the U.S. under President Jack Nicholson in the film “Mars Attacks”: “The aliens/Muslims MUST/HAVE TO like us because WE want peace”–based on nothing, based on no tenets or principles but “give peace a chance.”
    (Disclaimer: Plot revealed…) I LOVE the scene when the Martians arrive in Washington in their space ships: President Jack and Mrs. President, Annette Bening, show up on the tarmac, marching bands in attendance, an exultation of doves released, and POW: Doves are firebombed, marching band members are shot to death, little Pet President Pooch is kidnapped, and the Martians take over the White House.
    Singularly lacking in most blog comments on this topic is the role that Christianity has played over the centuries in civilizing and demorcratizing the West–and what has happened as the West has bought the apostasy that “God is dead.” Most of the West’s privileged elites believe this and live accordingly: decadantly.
    Which brings me to Knight 99’s point: What’s happened in England is that its “leaders,” many of them rich and privileged landed gentry and aristocracy–or rock stars–have foresaken all or most of their spiritual heritage and legacy. They live entitled, privileged lives completely bereft of any sense of either gratitude or “noblesse oblige.” In their thinking, sans God, they They “deserve” the decadant lifestyles they revel in, and “sod off” to everyone else.
    This me-first attitude denudes so-called Western leaders of any leadership capabilities, let alone a sense of altruism–which is something Christianity has always instilled in believers.
    Thus, in the West, we have all of the fruits of the Christian faith of our forebears–which include unprecedented freedoms, material well-being, and democracies the envy of the rest of the world–without any sense whatsover of gratitude, what can I do to share with others what I have?, or awe of the Numinous, the mystery of faith which fuelled, upheld, and strengthened society when faced with unspeakable evil and degridation.
    We are spiritual waifs and orphans, totally disarmed for the fight ahead. Until we reclaim our spiritual heritage, our spiritual memory, we walk as sleep walkers, as sheep to the slaughter.
    Bury your heads in the sand, if you like, put blinkers on, pretend that our Christian faith is dead and that it has never mattered–in fact, that it is the problem. Go ahead and do that, si vous voulez.
    But be aware that the belief in this way of thinking is what is doing us in: witness Great Britain and formerly Chrisitan Europe.

  22. The third cancer, penny, is our apostasy, our failure to see that the Christian faith is the root of our democracies and all of the freedoms we, in the West, hold dear.
    It’s just too bad that so many are too blind to see, and too deaf to hear: He who has eyes to see, let him see, and he who has ears to hear, let him hear.
    Amen.

  23. Muslims are going to be the majority in Europe and eventually North Americas as their birth rate is 4 times than the indigenious population that they have emigrated to.
    They’ll just out nimber us in 10 to 20 years. So get used to Female Circumcism, the Burka, and women getting 200 lashes for being raped.
    also Women won’t be able to go to school under Sharia…
    It’s coming so just accept it gang….

  24. Why should I accept it, RL? Why should any of us accept it?
    I don’t think we should accept it. Not accepting it, and saying that we don’t accept it, might mean that some people stop inviting us to their parties, it might mean that things get a little sticky at the water cooler, it might mean that people cross the street to avoid us, it might mean that our sisters, brothers, aunts, uncles, cousins, mothers, fathers stop talking to us–or start telling everyone else that “________’s gone crazy”–but that shouldn’t stop us from speaking up and out.
    The only way we accept it, is if we agree that our creature comforts and our popularity quotients are more important than the truth, are more important than our freedoms and those of our children and grandchildren.
    Perhaps the only legacy we can leave our children and grandchildren, now, is that we didn’t accept the Islamofascist tyranny. We fought it.

  25. The reason I say accept it is that no one, no Liberal, Conservative, or NDP’er (because of Political Correctise will stand up to it. That’s why I say accept it.

  26. More foreign born does not mean more ethnicly diverse. They are two different things, although I am sure they correlate somewhat. Miami has ethnic enclaves within ethnic enclaves. Spend some time there sometime.

Navigation