Defenseless

IN the Ottawa Sun Douglas Fisher minces few words.

New thinking on defence? Ask yourself: What other nation doesn’t provide a separate chapter in its budget for defence? In our 400-page document this bold, new era for our forces got five, buried in a 25-page chapter entitled Meeting our Global Responsibilities. Our military was lumped in with — and symbolically followed — tsunami relief and other foreign aid.
And then there is the language used. The budget speaks of “conflict situations” not wars. Our allies may be “fighting a war on terrorism” in Afghanistan but we are there to re-establish “peace and security.” If anything, this budget strengthens the notion that our military’s true role is to be an alternate delivery mechanism for foreign aid.
The notion the military is receiving an immediate and desperately-needed infusion of cash is a joke. Fully $10.2 billion of the $12.8 billion “promised” won’t arrive until 2008-10, which is budgetary never-never land. The minority Liberal government is preening over a promise to deliver cash relief to the forces after its own re-election, and this with the proviso that only if the country is still posting enormous surpluses at that time. This is an empty, despicable boast, given the military’s plight.
[…]
Perhaps most stunning of all in this budget is its lack of any new money over the next two years for new equipment.

Laurie Hawn fleshes this out.

We should also be aware of what is happening to our fighter force. For fifty years, we have had Canadian fighters patrolling our airspace, or sitting on alert to react to Soviet incursions or other air traffic situations. The focus changed on 9/11 from looking outward to also looking inward. Our ability to look anywhere has steadily eroded.
We will soon be down to 80 operational CF-18s, the number that we can afford to upgrade. We are also critically short of fighter pilots, many having left in disillusionment. Flying time has been cut back to the point where we no longer train at low level and intensity of training has been reduced to preserve safety. Preserving safety under these circumstances also makes us ineffective. No matter how fast we can spin the earth, the new simulators we’re buying will never fly and nothing in the new budget addresses the erosion of our aerospace sovereignty.
Most people probably don’t know that 433 Squadron in Bagotville will shut down this summer to make one larger 425 Squadron. It won’t be long before some bean counter or other non-warrior sees a source of further personnel cuts. Heck, if you’ve got 400 people, surely you can make it work with 375, or 350, or………… The same thing will happen in Cold Lake next summer, with the shutdown of 416 Squadron. That will leave Canada with two, count ’em, two operational fighter squadrons. Billy Bishop weeps!
These shutdowns will free up a handful of positions to help start a new air warfare college. What’s the point of having a college about air warfare if you have no Air FORCE to apply it? I’m sure that the office equipment, pens and paper in Winnipeg will strike fear in the hearts of our enemies and respect in the hearts of our allies.

Laurie – you need a blogroll. Your viewpoint deserves more readership, and that won’t happen if you move into the blogosphere proper. Outgoing linkage = incoming traffic.

Shifting Tides?

Poll results in Indonesia show that US sponsored tsunami relief may be having an effect on public opinion.

In the first substantial shift of public opinion in the Muslim world since the beginning of the United States’ global war on terrorism, more people in the world’s largest Muslim country now favor American efforts against terrorism than oppose them.
[…]

  • For the first time ever in a major Muslim nation, more people favor US-led efforts to fight terrorism than oppose them (40% to 36%). �Importantly, those who oppose US efforts against terrorism have declined by half, from 72% in 2003 to just 36% today.
  • For the first time ever in a Muslim nation since 9/ 11, support for Osama Bin Laden has dropped significantly (58% favorable to just 23%).
  • 65% of Indonesians now are more favorable to the United States because of the American response to the tsunami, with the highest percentage among people under 30.
  • Indeed, 71% of the people who express confidence in Bin Laden are now more favorable to the United States because of American aid to tsunami victims.
  • hat tip – Bill Strong

    Open Letter To That Stupid Bitch In The White House

    To those Americans who mistakenly perceive our nuanced, sophisticated and uniquely Canadian world view as “anti-Americanism”, former Canadian foreign minister Lloyd Axworthy (Liberal) would like to explain more thoroughly, in this open letter to the US Secretary of State, Dr.Condoleeza Rice.

    Dear Condi,
    I’m glad you’ve decided to get over your fit of pique and venture north to visit your closest neighbour. It’s a chance to learn a thing or two. Maybe more.
    I know it seems improbable to your divinely guided master in the White House that mere mortals might disagree with participating in a missile- defence system that has failed in its last three tests, even though the tests themselves were carefully rigged to show results.
    But, gosh, we folks above the 49th parallel are somewhat cautious types who can’t quite see laying down billions of dollars in a three-dud poker game.
    As our erstwhile Prairie-born and bred (and therefore prudent) finance minister pointed out in presenting his recent budget, we’ve had eight years of balanced or surplus financial accounts. If we’re going to spend money, Mr. Goodale added, it will be on day-care and health programs, and even on more foreign aid and improved defence.
    Sure, that doesn’t match the gargantuan, multi-billion-dollar deficits that your government blithely runs up fighting a “liberation war” in Iraq, laying out more than half of all weapons expenditures in the world, and giving massive tax breaks to the top one per cent of your population while cutting food programs for poor children.
    Just chalk that up to a different sense of priorities about what a national government’s role should be when there isn’t a prevailing mood of manifest destiny.
    Coming to Ottawa might also expose you to a parliamentary system that has a thing called question period every day, where those in the executive are held accountable by an opposition for their actions, and where demands for public debate on important topics such as missile defence can be made openly.
    You might also notice that it’s a system in which the governing party’s caucus members are not afraid to tell their leader that their constituents don’t want to follow the ideological, perhaps teleological, fantasies of Canada’s continental co-inhabitant. And that this leader actually listens to such representations.
    Your boss did not avail himself of a similar opportunity to visit our House of Commons during his visit, fearing, it seems, that there might be some signs of dissent. He preferred to issue his diktat on missile defence in front of a highly controlled, pre-selected audience.
    Such control-freak antics may work in the virtual one-party state that now prevails in Washington. But in Canada we have a residual belief that politicians should be subject to a few checks and balances, an idea that your country once espoused before the days of empire.
    If you want to have us consider your proposals and positions, present them in a proper way, through serious discussion across the table in our cabinet room, as your previous president did when he visited Ottawa. And don’t embarrass our prime minister by lobbing a verbal missile at him while he sits on a public stage, with no chance to respond.
    Now, I understand that there may have been some miscalculations in Washington based on faulty advice from your resident governor of the “northern territories,” Ambassador Cellucci. But you should know by now that he hasn’t really won the hearts and minds of most Canadians through his attempts to browbeat and command our allegiance to U.S. policies.
    Sadly, Mr. Cellucci has been far too closeted with exclusive groups of ‘experts’ from Calgary think-tanks and neo- con lobbyists at cross-border conferences to remotely grasp a cross-section of Canadian attitudes (nor American ones, for that matter).
    I invite you to expand the narrow perspective that seems to inform your opinions of Canada by ranging far wider in your reach of contacts and discussions. You would find that what is rising in Canada is not so much anti- Americanism, as claimed by your and our right-wing commentators, but fundamental disagreements with certain policies of your government. You would see that rather than just reacting to events by drawing on old conventional wisdoms, many Canadians are trying to think our way through to some ideas that can be helpful in building a more secure world.
    These Canadians believe that security can be achieved through well-modulated efforts to protect the rights of people, not just nation-states.
    To encourage and advance international co-operation on managing the risk of climate change, they believe that we need agreements like Kyoto.
    To protect people against international crimes like genocide and ethnic cleansing, they support new institutions like the International Criminal Court — which, by the way, you might strongly consider using to hold accountable those committing atrocities today in Darfur, Sudan.
    And these Canadians believe that the United Nations should indeed be reformed — beginning with an agreement to get rid of the veto held by the major powers over humanitarian interventions to stop violence and predatory practices.
    On this score, you might want to explore the concept of the ‘Responsibility to Protect’ while you’re in Ottawa. It’s a Canadian idea born out of the recent experience of Kosovo and informed by the many horrific examples of inhumanity over the last half-century. Many Canadians feel it has a lot more relevance to providing real human security in the world than missile defence ever will.
    This is not just some quirky notion concocted in our long winter nights, by the way. It seems to have appeal for many in your own country, if not the editorialists at the Wall Street Journal or Rush Limbaugh. As I discovered recently while giving a series of lectures in southern California, there is keen interest in how the U.S. can offer real leadership in managing global challenges of disease, natural calamities and conflict, other than by military means. There is also a very strong awareness on both sides of the border of how vital Canada is to the U.S. as a partner in North America. We supply copious amounts of oil and natural gas to your country, our respective trade is the world’s largest in volume, and we are increasingly bound together by common concerns over depletion of resources, especially very scarce fresh water.
    Why not discuss these issues with Canadians who understand them, and seek out ways to better cooperate in areas where we agree — and agree to respect each other’s views when we disagree.
    Above all, ignore the Cassandras who deride the state of our relations because of one missile-defence decision. Accept that, as a friend on your border, we will offer a different, independent point of view. And that there are times when truth must speak to power.
    In friendship,
    Lloyd Axworthy

    For those who may not recognize the name, Lloyd Axworthy is the man credited with bringing about the sweeping economic, democratic and human rights reforms in Cuba in 1997.
    hat tip – Greg
    ouch.

    No War, For … eh… Desmarais

    A follow-up to this post on the UN oil-for-food involvement by UN Deputy Secretary-General, Canadian Louise Frechette.
    Canada Free Press

    It appears the impartiality and credibility of the Volcker Committee’s Investigation into Oil-for-Food is growing grim, exacerbated by Fr�chette’s troubling actions during the Oil-for-Food Program, and her colliding work history with investigators and possible defendants.
    According to Fox News, “When [Louise] Fr�chette served as Canada’s ambassador to the United Nations from 1992 to 1995, her boss during most of that time was Canadian Deputy Minister Reid Morden, who is now executive director of the Volcker team.” Fr�chette’s current boss, Kofi Annan appointed Paul Volcker, to investigate the UN’s Oil-for-Food Program. The Volcker committee and Reid Morden have “no comment” at this time concerning Fr�chette.
    After leaving her first post at the United Nations, Louise Fr�chette returned to Canada serving from November 1994 to June 1995, under then Minister of Finance Paul Martin, as his Associate Deputy Minister. Paul Martin held Canada’s Minister of Finance position from November 1993 until June 2002, becoming Canada’s 21st Prime Minister on December 12, 2003. Together, in 1995, Martin and Fr�chette worked on several issues including the Halifax G-7 Summit, and participated in the “Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Trade.” Inquiries to Prime Minister Martin’s office were not answered as of press time.
    Louise Fr�chette joins the illustrious Canadian connection in the UN Oil-for-Food Program, where there is her former boss, Prime Minister Martin who replaced Prime Minister Jean Chretien. Jean Chretien’s daughter, France is married to Andre Desmarais, the son of Paul Desmarais. Desmarais is the chairman and Co-Chief Executive Officer of Canada’s Power Corporation, and the largest shareholder and director of France’s TotalFinalElf. TotalFinalElf was one of the largest benefactors of Oil-for-Food contracts. According to the Financial Post, “In 1974, Desmarais, Sr., made Martin president of Canada Steamship Lines and then in 1981, he made him spectacularly rich by selling the company to him and a partner for $180 million.” As CFP previously reported, Canada, the seventh largest contributor to the United Nations, will not investigate the Oil-for-Food Program.

    Today, Kevin Libin at the Shotgun picks up the Desmarais meme;

    On the China watch, we have the National People’s Congress passing “a new law that could provide the basis for an attack on the island [Taiwan].” Also note that Beijing Clamps Down as Parliament Delegates Gather. Then, China proposes massive military spending hike. Just days before we have the EU announcing their stance on ending the arms embargo with China.
    So, for absolutely no reason, let’s flash back to Nov. 26, 2003 when we see BNP Paribas–European–officially opening in China as the first foreign-owned enterprise bank. (BNP Paribas, you might recall, is the bank that handled Saddam’s oil-for-food money, now under investigation for possible improprieties in that scam.)
    So you’ve got potential domestic unrest, a possible nationalistic target for a fascist government to redirect that unrest, an arms build-up, a willing foreign arms supplier, and a bank the supplier and the buyer both trust. Let’s get down to business.

    Kevin’s post is rich with links – I”ll send you there to check them out. From an earlier post here on BNP Paribas;

    BNP Paribas bank is part of a holding company, Pargesa Holding, which is jointly owned and controlled by the Fr�re and Desmarais families. Paul Desmarais Sr. is the chairman of the group, while Albert Fr�re is the vice-chairman. Gerald Fr�re, Albert’s son, is one of three general managers who oversee day-to-day operations, and Paul Desmarais Jr. is also an officer.
    Pargesa, and thus Power Corporation and the Canadian Desmarais family, holds a controlling significant stake in TotalFina Elf, the Belgian-French petroleum multinational corporation formed from the merger of Total and Petrofina.

    Caught At The Border

    The RCMP seized a computer from the Canadian daughter of a suspected al-Qaeda financier when she entered Canada two weeks ago, according to a report.
    Police officers took a laptop and other property from Zaynab Khadr as she entered Canada from Pakistan, the Toronto Star said Thursday.

    Canadian border and security officials have also confirmed that they have possession of Fateh Kamel’s Playstation, Ahmed Ressam’s cell phone, and a Guy LaFleur rookie card once owned by Paul Rose.

    A “Blistering Memo”

    Editor And Publisher;

    Laurie Garrett, the prize-winning Newsday reporter, left the Melville, N.Y., paper Monday with a blistering memo to her colleagues that may provoke debate elsewhere in the newspaper industry.

    Well, there went the gold watch.

    “When I started out in journalism the newsrooms were still full of old guys with blue collar backgrounds who got genuinely indignant when the Governor lied or somebody turned off the heat on a poor person’s apartment in mid-January. They cussed and yelled their ways through the day, took an occasional sly snort from a bottle in the bottom drawer of their desk and bit into news stories like packs of wild dogs, never letting go until they’d found and told the truth. If they hadn’t been reporters most of those guys would have been cops or firefighters. It was just that way. …
    “Honesty and tenacity (and for that matter, the working class) seem to have taken backseats to the sort of ‘snappy news’, sensationalism, scandal-for-the-sake of scandal crap that sells. This is not a uniquely Tribune or even newspaper industry problem: this is true from the Atlanta mixing rooms of CNN to Sulzberger’s offices in Times Square. Profits: that’s what it’s all about now. But you just can’t realize annual profit returns of more than 30 percent by methodically laying out the truth in a dignified, accessible manner. And it’s damned tough to find that truth every day with a mere skeleton crew of reporters and editors.
    “This is terrible for democracy. I have been in 47 states of the USA since 9/11, and I can attest to the horrible impact the deterioration of journalism has had on the national psyche. I have found America a place of great and confused fearfulness.”

    You know, it’s tempting to just agree and applaud.
    It’s more tempting to ask why she waited until after she quit.

    Four RCMP Down

    Breaking CTV

    At least four RCMP officers are not responding to their radios after conducting a raid on an alleged marijuana grow operation in northwestern Alberta, says Alberta Solicitor General Harvey Cenaiko.
    “They don’t know whether that’s a malfunction of the equipment or what yet, but it’s a very serious situation,” said Cenaiko.
    He added that gunfire was continuing.

    And our marijuana decriminalizing legislators would have us believe that the safety of the public depends on arresting hotel owners for smoking violations, unhelmeted bicycle riders and dog owners.
    Keep them in your prayers.
    Update – 4:30pm reports are that all four are confirmed dead. Military is reported to have been called in.
    update 2
    CBC report
    Background:
    “The Ontario Association of Chiefs of Police estimates that the number of illegal grow-ops in this province has increased 250 per cent. Revenue could hit $12.7 billion.”
    Realty Times – How can you tell if there’s a grow-op house in your neighbourhood.
    More details are emerging – this was not a raid, per se, but the intentional killing of four junior officers who had been posted to guard the property until evidence gathering could be completed in the morning. The owner returned to the scene to, for all intents and purposes, execute them.
    More on James Roszko from Cosh.

    Brad Wall

    I attended the SaskParty Leaders Dinner last evening. Reportedly, the 700 plus attendance was a new record for the party. I didn’t take notes, so just a few general remarks from memory. The introduction by long time Liberal Bob McKercher, QC, who argued that it was time for Liberals to stop diluting the free-enterprise vote was well recieved.
    I went to the event with an open mind and no expectations. I was pleasantly surprised – impressed, even.
    Brad Wall is the real thing. A gifted speaker, he communicates with vision, optimisim, conviction, humour, self deprecation – and apparently, without notes. His pokes at the NDP and their proclivity for “investing” tax dollars in the wishful-thinking segment of the economy were well aimed and damaging – as was his criticism of the competence of the union-controlled NDP government in throwing grenades at the confidence of the business community.

    “The left hand doesn’t know what the extreme left hand is doing”.

    I divided my time listening to Wall, and watching the face of a well-known New Democrat, and former city councillor. Reading facial expressions and body language is an inexact science, but it was fascinating to watch the reaction. Restrained, below-the-tabletop applause when there was agreement, discomfort when he hit senstive nerves.
    In conversation after the dinner broke up, I was a pleasantly surprised to meet a few people who knew of SDA. One amusing anecdote – someone laughed that he had been led to my site by a friend who sent him an email from “Izbecka-khazik-somewhere-stan”. (I have no memory for names).
    There were a handful who were aware of how powerful a role the blogsophere played in the re-election of Bush, and recognized that this medium is a tool that conservative policy makers in Canada should try to utilize – or perhaps more accurately, include.
    We shall see. Hopefully, attendees with better memory for detail will drop in and add their observations of the dinner, the SaskParty, and Brad Wall, in the comments. Send me links to consider for the sidebar. If there’s room for the Blogging Tories, there’s room for the blogging SaskPartiers.

    More Pigs Take Wing

    If you didn’t catch Jon Stewart last night, this is well worth a read.

    Stewart: Do you think that the people of Lebanon would have had, sort of, the courage of their conviction, having not seen–not only the invasion but the election which followed? It’s almost as though that the Iraqi election has emboldened this crazy–something’s going on over there. I’m smelling something.

    I hope there’s a heavy duty axle on that bandwagon.

    Missile Fallout

    A Montana court has granted an injunction to R-CALF, keeping the US-Canadian border closed to Canadian cattle. It’s unlikely that any appeal will be heard prior to the scheduled March 7th opening.
    Is the decision the result of Paul Martin’s botched BMD fiasco? No – but the oncoming freight train of Bush administration indifference to Canadian grievances will be.
    Condoleezza Rice has deferred her visit and Paul Martin can’t get his calls returned. Martin’s flip flopping support for missile defense reminds me about something that David Frum wrote in his book “The Right Man”;

    Then Arafat made what may someday be reckoned as the most fateful miscalculation of his career. On January 5, 2002, Israeli naval forces intercepted a Gaza-bound merchant ship loaded with fifty tonnes of arms from Iran. Arafat hastily sent Bush a letter denying any involvement in the shipment. Probably Arafat did not even intend his denial to be interpreted literally; he may have written it as a social form, like the phrase I regret in a letter declining an invitation to a wedding or a dinner party. If so, Arafat sorely misunderstood his man. Bush does not lie to you. You had better not lie to him.

    I’m beginning to wonder if Paul Martin has just been confined to his compound on 24 Sussex.

    Navigation