Poll Wanking

The political pollsters never call me. The marketing/research types, on the other hand, seek my views quite regularly. This is a roughly paraphrased and greatly abbreviated version of a phone survey I took a couple days ago;
After a brief introduction and explanation as to the type of questions to expect, she began;

Q: “Of the two following health problems, which would you say is more prevalent – heart disease or lung disease?”
Me: “What do you mean, which one? They usually go together.”
Q: “No they don’t.”
Me: “Yes they do – heart failure generally leads to lung problems and lung disease can cause the heart to fail.”
Q: “I’m not sure that’s…”
Me: “It’s why they call it cardiopulmonary.”
Q: “Oh.”
Me: “It’s a stupid question.”
Q: “I’m not sure what to tell you, other than you have to pick one.”
Me: “Oh, whatever – put down heart disease”.

Prematurely relieved, she went on to Question 2.

Q: “Which would you say is more common, cancer or blood disease?”
Me: “Well, there they go again! What do they mean by “blood disease”?
Q: “I don’t understand”.
Me: “Is leukemia a cancer or a blood disease?”
Q: “I see your point.”
Me: “Who designed these questions? They’re illogical.”
Q: “I don’t know”.

And so it went. It didn’t take long to figure out that “injury related health costs” were on the poll designer’s mind – a survey to test or design communications strategy for the Worker’s Comp or some other “tell us how to live our lives” program. (Perhaps the mandatory bike helmet or spikey-shoes for seniors lobby?) Near the end we got into the numbers.

Q: “What would you estimate to be the cost to the Saskatchewan heatlh system of preventable injury – $500,000; $1 million; $500 million; $1 billion; $1.5 billion?

It’s not so hard to spot when questions are designed (the only age-relative question being “whats the greatest killer of Saskatchewan residents under the age of 40?”) to push results towards a general conclusion – in this case it appeared the one they were aiming to prove, “Saskatchewan residents vastly underestimate the incidence and cost of injury to the health care system”.
So, I picked $1 billion. “Oh.” Her voice registered surprise. She went on with a few other questions, and closed with this;

Q: “On a scale of one to five, five being ‘very in favour’, how supportive would you be to programs designed to lower preventable injury?”
A: “Is there a zero?”

Expect to hear in the upcoming weeks, a news release from some government agency advising us that Saskatchewan residents “greatly underestimate” the costs to the health care system of work-related and preventable injury – justifying yet another regulation, program or communications strategy designed to perpetuate their own existence.

Lighter Fare

My Kingdom for a camera!

Look, up in the sky. It’s a bird, it’s a plane! No! It’s Separatist Chicken, and it’s after Prime Minister Paul Martin.
When Martin arrived at a Christmas reception Thursday at a restaurant in Gatineau, Que., he was greeted by a fowl sight – someone dressed as a chicken. The chicken held up a sign in French that read “Martin – debate,” an obvious shot at Martin’s refusal to debate Bloc Quebecois Leader Gilles Duceppe on federalism.

Thanks to “Ottawa Core”, we have the evidence!
Kathy Shaidle has a few words for five new readers.
J. Kelly Nestruck’s Actual Conversation With An Intelligent Torontonian who Lives in Cabbagetown This Evening.. I think he’s being generous.
This is a guy I could grow to like.
And from the comments, “steve” has the quote of the day;

“Layton, Harper and Duceppe have become so close they’re thinking of making a cowboy movie together.”

With Christmas approaching, I’d like to lighten things up. If you have other items of “lighter fare”, short jokes, funny blog posts etc. to share in the comments, feel welcome.

Let Freedom Ring

Now that the Supreme Court of Canada has replaced the “community standard of tolerance with a harm-based test”, let’s hope the approved-list-of-shrubbery-and-house-colour “planned community” question is soon put to the courts.
I for one, can’t wait to see the restoration of our constitutional right to store a vehicle on blocks in the front driveway.

Backdoor Sharia

In in Australia.

“The head of the Victoria Government’s Equal Opportunity Commission, Diane Sisely, hired Muslim investigators to assist the Commission in targeting people criticising Islam.
First stop for the Muslim investigators? A Pentacostal Church where two pastors were reading passages from the Koran and quotes from terrorists who used the Koran to justify violence…

Cold Day In Hell

This photo, courtesy Canadian Press, ought to dispell those lingering fears about whether Stephen Harper is a closet Christian fundamentalist.
capt.n122175a.jpg
What with being the anti-Christ, and all.
Update
This black and white Reuter’s photo taken at almost the same time, seems to show larger pupils. It may be a matter of resolution or camera angle, but one still has to wonder about the editorial wisdom at Canadian Press in allowing a photo to be used with this degree of colour distortion.

Omar Alghabra

I’m getting a lot of email on the Omar Alghabra “victory for Islam” nomination story in Mississauga. Kathy Shaidle is trying to get to the bottom of this one, with the help of others like Lost Budgie and KennethK – so my advice is to head over there and follow her links and updates.
Further thoughts: There seems to be concern that this incident has “undermined” the integrity of the blogosphere. I find that concern perplexing – watching the story develop across a variety of sites, it seems to me the blogosphere is approaching this in the expected manner. Sure – some people took the report at face value – just as dozens of bloggers took the MSM hysteria about “hundreds of thousands” of lost Iraqi artifacts at face value, and others were led down a false path by the same individual later reponsible for fooling CBS with the fake “Rathergate” memos.
The story was denied within hours by the candidate, that denial has been duly noted, further investigation is taking place and new details are emerging. No concensus yet on what actually went on, but from my vantagepoint, things are humming along quite normally. If this turns out to be the work of an intentional plant, hoping to use the blogosphere to push a lie – things are likely to turn out badly for them, whoever they may be.

Just In Time For Christmas

The Supreme Court Of Canada has now erased the principle of community standards in law.

“Criminal indecency or obscenity must rest on actual harm or a significant risk of harm to individuals or society. The Crown failed to establish this essential element of the offense. (Its) case must therefore fail,” McLachlin wrote.
In indecency cases, Canadian courts have traditionally probed whether the acts in question “breached the rules of conduct necessary for the proper functioning of society.” The Supreme Court ruled that from now on, judges should pay more attention to whether society would be actively harmed.

By the way, Justice McLachlin recently had this to say.

�The rule of law requires judges to uphold unwritten constitutional norms, even in the face of clearly enacted laws or hostile public opinion,� said a prepared text of the lecture Chief Justice McLachlin gave to law students at Victoria University of Wellington late last week.
�There is certainly no guarantee or presumption that a given list of constitutional principles is complete, even assuming the good faith intention of the drafters to provide such a catalogue.�
Chief Justice McLachlin set out a blueprint for when judges must rely on unwritten principles, which she defined as �norms that are essential to a nation�s history, identity, values, and legal system.�

I’m sure you remember the media and political firestorm that caused.
Yeah, me either.
Reading the comments, I’m surprised that nobody has yet raised the point that this ruling has pretty much set the stage for legalization of bigamy.
Related thoughts from Stanley Kurtz.

Don’t Bring An Email To A Blog Fight

Ottawa Citizen (via Bourques Voy forum);

Elie Betito is known in political circles as the chief spokesman for generic drug company Apotex, and can often be seen on the Hill helping the company in its ongoing campaign for changes to patent drug rules. But Mr. Betito got a splash of ink this week for something entirely different over an e-mail he sent to Stacey Cherwonak, a sport shooter and forensic firearms expert with the RCMP in Ottawa.
As a volunteer on Liberal candidate Bonnie Brown’s campaign in Oakville, Mr. Betito fielded Mr. Cherwonak’s angry e- mail last week over the Liberal announcement about further restrictions on handguns. He closed his e-mail with, “you lying bastards.”
Mr. Betito e-mailed back: “take your NRA , GUN LOVING ASS BACK TO THE U.S. WHERE YOU BELONG, E. BETITO.”
Mr. Betito admits the e-mail was written in “a moment of insanity,” and says he was provoked into the foolish move by the tone of Mr. Cherwonak’s message and his concerns about the Dodge City environment in the Toronto ‘burbs. He has resigned from Ms. Brown’s campaign and apologized to Mr. Cherwonak.
But Mr. Betito says he now feels like he’s the one in the crosshairs. Once his e-mail was posted on a blog, it spread rapidly among the guns ‘n’ ammo set across North America. He says he has received hundreds of e-mails from the U.S. and Canada, many threatening in tone.
“I have been bombarded,” he said. “I got concerned about my welfare. I never knew the reach and breadth of these groups.” Mr. Betito says some e-mails are suggesting a boycott of Apotex’s drugs and others were sent to his bosses to demand he be fired.
One message confused his gender and began with the salutation, “You Liberal slut.” One website posted his home address. ‘This is the greatest level of intimidation I have ever seen,’ Mr. Betito said, and that’s something coming from someone who regularly picks fights with the most powerful industry in the world — the brand-name drug companies.
And Take Your Beer and Popcorn With You
Meanwhile, Mr. Cherwonak is giving some serious consideration to taking Mr. Betito’s advice. “I may be taking my gun- loving ass to the U.S. after all,” he said. He is reconsidering his future in Canada because of the Liberal approach to gun control. He calls Liberal leader Paul Martin’s proposal on new handgun restrictions “a grub for votes in Toronto,” that may force him to relocate if he wants to continue competitive sport shooting.
The message from Mr. Betito did not surprise him, he said, given the party’s past position on guns. It was one of only a few replies he received after blanketing Ontario Liberal MPs with his e-mailed message of protest.
One reply from a Liberal campaign worker came with a suggestion: “It said you better practise because Harper’s going to send you to Iraq,” he said.

The post that started it all is here. One point I’d like to add to the Citizen item – Betito’s address was available on the internet prior to this incident. However, I hope folks let up on Mr. Betito now. He’s done the honourable thing by resigning.
There was a time when a citizen like Stacey Cherwonak wouldn’t have had his complaint heard unless a friendly media outlet chose to voice it for him. When the message is pro-gun, the likelihood of finding such an outlet is slim.
Those days are over. Within hours of posting the exchange, the information had been read here by thousands of Canadians, and through the multilayered network of blogs, lists and forums, to thousands more before the first dead tree story went to print.
Welcome to the brave new world of filter-free politics.
(More here on the blogosphere angle.)

Jim Travers: Breaking News Of The Blatantly Obvious

Paul Martin will be out if he fails to win a majority.
Other headlines In today’s Star: “Dogs Bark”, “Water Runs Downhill”
Astute commentor “MGK”;

Travers has a pipe into the PMO. Without it, he would be just like all of the other ink-stained wretches who crawl on Parliament Hill.
But the significance of what he is saying is not obvious on its face. For that, we travel back in time to the year 2000. During that federal election, Chretien was bleeding support and some thought he might lose huge numbers to the Alliance. Overnight, a new lie appeared on all doorsteps across Canada, spoken by all Liberal candidates, namely that Chretien would step down immediately after the election and be replaced by the then more popular Paul Martin.
So, Travers’ story, planted by Paul Martin’s Liberals, tells you two things: First, that the Liberal campaign is aware that it is in desperate trouble. Second, that Paul Martin is repeating Chretien’s deceptive strategy – of promising a new leader tomorrow if you vote for the old leader today.
Of course, if you think that Martin will ever voluntarily step down, you don’t understand Liberal politics or the people who make their careers betting on one man.

Reader Tips

It’s been a busy week, and I’ve only been able to scratch the surface of the many, many you’ve sent in. .
2005 Awards for the year’s worst reporting!
Canada Free Press;

Now it makes sense why four years ago, Canadian Steamship Lines International, a CSL subsidiary, entered into a deal with Shanghai based Jiangnan Shipyards to build two bulk cargo vessels-at $45- million per ship.

The CBC has been forced to withdraw a Harper bashing cartoon.
“Senior government officials went into panic mode last fall after 46 top-secret cabinet documents went missing.”
This incident is a couple weeks old, but it’s worth a chuckle.

“Sometimes election campaigns can travel to so many cities and towns in a day it gets hard to remember what time it is or where you are. But Prime Minister Paul Martin appeared to forget what country he was in yesterday. During a series of interviews with Chinese media organizations, Mr. Martin attempted to explain to the interviewer how important the Chinese Canadian community is to the country. In fact, he announced that Canada has geographically moved its borders to be closer to them. “What we really are saying is we’re a major Asian country,” Mr. Martin told Omni TV, to roars of laughter from the Canadian media watching the interview.”

Add your own in the comments.

On the Seventh Day Of Libranomas

Greg Staples;

So what do I learn by watching Countdown tonight? That the Liberals are so broke that they are going to send their paid campaign staff back to their government jobs, from which they were on a leave of absense during the Christmas week off.

That may help explain the reported elusiveness of the Liberal party in providing evidence that their $1.4 million Sponsorship “loan repayment” cheque has cleared the bank.
A link to the video at ATC.

Fill In The Blank Conservatives: Winners are!

Things have been so busy here that I nearly forgot to announce the “winners” of the Fill In The Blank Conservative contest.
To review – it all started with a comment by JulieM:

Okay, this is my first post here but that reminds me of the 2000 elections (I’m an American). I’m one of those “broken glass” Republicans who would crawl through broken glass (the pundits said) to vote against the Clintons.
Maybe someone can come up with some witty Canadian equivalent, perhaps “broken snow plow Conservatives,” or “dead battery Conservatives,” or, “Where in the #*@( are my mitts Conservatives.”

So based on a mathematical equation specifically formulated to produce a purely subjective result:
3rd place;
“Brass Monkey Conservative” – “Brian”
2nd – (and readers choice) ;
“40 Below Conservative” – “Fred”
And the winner is!
“Damn the Tim’s! Where’s the polling booth? Conservative” – “Alan”
And no contest is complete without an Honourable Mention in the Most Understated Category;
“Actually-voting Conservative” – Stephen J.
Thanks everyone!
You can catch the rest of the entries here.

Paul Martin’s Spat With The US – Was It A Setup?

Stephen Taylor and I have been working to check out something a reader emailed me about a couple of days ago. Because of my technical limitations and a busy workday yesterday, I asked Stephen to dig into the video of the ads up on the Liberal.ca website to see if there was something to the suspicions cast and he’s pulled together a devastating case.
I’ll be using Stephen’s text extensively in this post as well as the timeline he pulled together. Let’s review;
December 5th: The Liberals release three ads on their website. (1, 2, 3)
December 7th – Paul Martin at Montreal climate change conference: “To the reticent nations, including the United States, I say this: There is such a thing as a global conscience, and now is the time to listen to it, now is the time to join with others in the global community”
December 8th – Canadian ambassador to the US, Frank McKenna (a Liberal) reportedly receives a “dressing down” from the Bush administration over Martin’s comments on December 7th.
December 13th (morning) – US Ambassador to Canada, David Wilkins: “It may be smart election-year politics to thump your chest and constantly criticize your friend and your No. 1 trading partner”
December 13th (afternoon) – Paul Martin: Let me simply say to anyone who wants to question what I have been saying, beginning with (Conservative Leader) Stephen Harper, that I am the prime minister of this country, that our position on climate change will be determined by the government of Canada, that the fact is that we do expect our partners to honour their agreements — and I will defend Canada. Period.
December 16th – Liberals release new ads on their website (4, 5)
Check out the transcript of the 4th Liberal ad, which seems to underscore Martin’s bold response to Wilkins:

Keith White: “I think Paul Martin’s doing a fantastic job representing our interests… in America”
Neil Dhalla: “Paul Martin definitely has the ability to stand up to Mr. Bush”
Art Cowie: “Paul Martin’s taking a very strong stand on the lumber situation”
Bardish Chagger: “He has protected Canadians’ interests, he has fought for our softwood lumber.”
Nathan Van Beselacre: “It’s important to have good relations with our neighbours, but when there’s a problem you have to deal with it diplomatically. I feel he’s done so.”

However, this fourth ad (released Dec 16th) was filmed on the same day as second ad released on Dec 5th – long before the reported “summoning” of Mckenna to Washington.
(I’ve screencaptured Stephen’s shots – be sure to go over to his site for the live links.)

libad1.jpg
Note the positioning of the parked cars and the same clothes.
libad2.jpg
Note the pattern of the puddles over Dhalla’s shoulder. Note the time on the clock in the background (ad 4 was filmed 7 minutes after ad 2)
libad3.jpg
Same clothes, same rainy day.
The clips the ads obviously were filmed on the same day and sometime before December 5th.

Did the Martin campaign deliberately set out to sour relations with the Bush administration for political advantage? Did Wilkins fall into a trap that had been already laid? It might explain why he seemed a bit mystified over the reaction to his speech. On Dec.13, Norm Spector noticed something that David Frum had mentioned in the National Post.

The National Post’s David Frum is onto Paul Martin.
The story of White House reaction to that speech turns out to have been wildly overhyped. The White House official who met with ambassador McKenna on Friday was not the Vice- President, not the National Security Adviser, not even the National Security Council’s Senior Director for Western Hemisphere Affairs: It was the head of the Council on Environmental Quality. Nor had McKenna been “summoned”: He had requested the meeting himself. As for the administration’s alleged fury, the true mood seems to have been closer to one of irritated resignation.

The ads are a little too prescient. Together with Frum’s revelation, what the LIberals have tried to pull off may represent an all-time low in the history of Canadian politics. I agree with Stephen ;

The Liberal braintrust obviously thought that clips of “ordinary Canadians” (er, Liberals) would be required defending what would be future rhetoric of Paul Martin taking on George W. Bush and the USA.
If the recent diplomatic row with Washington was merely part of a partisan ploy to gain anti-American votes (as many observers have suggested), does the timing of the filming of these ads further confirm that the Liberals were preparing to sour Canadian-US relations for electoral gain?

Navigation