Tolerance is not a good thing

Is Pope Benedict XVI going too far with the apologies? I think a moral argument could be made for that, at least as far as Thomas Aquinas is concerned:

St. Thomas teaches (Summa theol., II-II, Q. x, a. 11): “Ritus infidelium tolerari possunt vel propter aliquod bonum, quod ex eis provenit, vel propter aliquod maum, quod vitatur” (Heathen worships can be tolerated either because of some good that results from them or because of some evil that is avoided).

He was talking about whether a Catholic state should tolerate other religions within its borders (he says they should be tolerated, and other Catholic philosophers have expanded on this), but the principle applies more widely. Tolerance is a good thing because it generates a good result.

Are apologies, which implicitly signal tolerance of the violence shown by Muslim mobs, leading to a good result? So far, it has only led to further violence. Moreover, it signals to the mob that future violence on other issues will be rewarded. I think there is an argument to be made that the Church must take an intolerant stand. She must make it clear that no further apologies or explanations are forthcoming, that the violence shown over the spoken word is intolerable, and that the Church will demand tolerance of Muslims in the future. That too, will lead to violence, but then it’s likely unavoidable. But taking such a stand will mean that the Church will have drawn a line in the moral sand, and in doing so taken sides with such others as Salman Rushdie and Naguib Mahfouz who themselves were victims of those who tolerated extremism, and who themselves represent the marriage of Islam and reason which was the point of the Pope’s speech in the first place.

[See the expanded post at Angry in the Great White North. Hopefully this expanded precis addresses some of the criticism from Kate’s readers. I’ll try to get the balance right in the future.]

GreenStone Media — hardly a ripple in the blogosphere

That new all-woman media enterprise, GreenStone Media, backed by Gloria Steinem and Jane Fonda, has a splashy website to promote the all-talk radio network. The website also lists some of Gloria’s favourite blogs. But based on the traffic patterns on the first blog listed, it seems like getting the nod from GreenStone Media makes no difference to a blog’s traffic.

Which makes me wonder just how many people are going to the GreenStone Media website…and then how many people are listening to the radio shows.

Not too many, apparently. But judge for yourself.

Idiot of the Day

Yeah, it’s early but we have a winner!
The Globe & Mail reports that we spent $85-million to evacuate large numbers of non-taxpaying “dual citizen” teat-sucking ingrates out of Lebannon. The combox includes some non-idiots, like this guy:

This whole shamefull episode clearly shows that there is a double-standard when it comes to canadian citizenship : canadians with duties and other ‘canadians’ with privileges. I have been living in Montreal for many years, and for a while in a section of the town where a lot of people from Lebanon live. They come from upper middle-class Lebanon, speak french, are well-educated and know how ‘the system work’. Their mothers, fathers, cousins, etc, enjoy free medical care, send their kids to our schools, do NOT pay taxes, etc. All of this has been going on since 1990. They now think it’s a ‘droit acquis’ that we owe them. You question that and you’re on Bush’s payroll, you hate muslims and should be put on trial before the ‘Droits et Libertés’ tribunal. Our ‘leftists’ agree with them. What a ignominous farce.

However…
Darren Smith writes from “Dubai, Canada”:

I currently live in the middle east and I consider myself a proud, contributing Canadian, regardless of my tax paying status. It baffles me that Canadians view the funds used to evacuate Canadians as a waste of tax payer dollars. What makes Canada so great is our melting pot of cultures, our standing and influence in the international community and our global social conscience. You do not develop these traits by keeping immigrants out and keeping Canadians at home. I think before you develop an opinion on changing Canada’s immigration policy you should consider the demographic challenges we face and the value that immigrants bring to our economy and our way of life. Though I am not a Canadian tax payer today, I will be returning to Canada with my wealth and my knowledge while contributing to Canada’s presence as a global citizen. I am surprised that my values differ so much from fellow Canadians. $2.60 per Canadian tax payer is a bargain for the benefits we receive. I will gladly send my $2.60 home.

Wow, who knew Dubai had a shortage of People Who Can Squeeze the Largest Number of Cliches Into One Paragraph? That’s some skill set. Glad “Darren Smith” will be coming back here sometime to share this marvelous talent with us — there’s a desk at the CBC waiting for him.
He only left out “PS: We burned down the White House in the War of 1812. Har Har!” Or did he? What other Canuckistan cliches did Darren forget to squeeze into his little missive from The Land of the One Way Airline Ticket of Allah (pbuh)?
Pile on, kiddies.

On The Road Again

Like Willie Nelson without the ‘shrooms!.
My itinerary begins in Montana and eventually winds up in Philadelphia on Oct.8, and while I’ll take my laptop along – but, I’m also travelling with 7 dogs, so that won’t allow much free time for news surfing, much less blogging. I’ll be checking in from time to time, and may put up the occasional post, but for the most part, I’ll be offline.
But, fear not – our peerless guest bloggers have once again agreed to help keep the place going while I’m gone. Be patient if your comments are held up in the filter , be polite, and perhaps, even thank them if you get the chance!
These breaks are one of the reasons I’ve been able to avoid “blog burnout”. (Remember Nealenews?) So, have fun, behave yourselves, and help make the crew’s job a bit easier by ignoring the trolls and drive-by’s.
And if a day or two goes by without something new, eh… it’s not the end of the world. Check out the sites at the left and expand your blog horizons!

CBC Chairman Guy Fournier

Saying goodbye to a member of Canada’s cultural elite;

OTTAWA (Reuters) – The chairman of the publicly funded Canadian Broadcasting Corp. has resigned after remarks about bestiality and ruminations about defecation, Canadian Heritage Minister Bev Oda said on Tuesday.
Guy Fournier created an uproar in Canada’s Lebanese community and in the media when he claimed that Lebanon allowed men to have sexual relations with female animals, but reserved the death penalty for those who did so with male animals.

If you’re looking for the item on the CBC website – scroll down, way down, under “arts and entertainment”.

Forget The Soundbites

And the pundits, and the academic elites, and Peter Mansbridge’s nightly filter.
It’s 2006. You don’t need anyone to tell you what he said.
Here, without further commentary, is the text of President George W. Bush’s address today, to the General Assembly at the United Nations. You, good readers, can judge its worth for yourselves.
(*note – II received the original version of this post via email from a member of the media. I’ve found a later version that indicates it was incomplete. The remainder is in the extended entry)

Mr. Secretary General, Madam President, distinguished delegates, and ladies and gentlemen, I want to thank you for the privilege of speaking to this General Assembly.
Last week America and the world marked the fifth anniversary of the attacks that filled another September morning with death and suffering. On that terrible day, extremists killed nearly 3,000 innocent people, including citizens of dozens of nations represented right here in this chamber.
Since then, the enemies of humanity have continued their campaign of murder. Al-Qaida and those inspired by its extremist ideology have attacked more than two dozen nations. And recently a different group of extremists deliberately provoked a terrible conflict in Lebanon.
At the start of the 21st century, it is clear that the world is engaged in a great ideological struggle between extremists who use terror as a weapon to create fear and moderate people who work for peace.
Five years ago I stood at this podium and called on the community of nations to defend civilization and build a more hopeful future. This is still the great challenge of our time.
It is the calling of our generation.
This morning I want to speak about the more hopeful world that is within our reach, a world beyond terror, where ordinary men and women are free to determine their own destiny, where the voices of moderation are empowered, and where the extremists are marginalized by the peaceful majority.
This world can be ours, if we seek it and if we work together.
The principles of this world beyond terror can be found in the very first sentence of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. This document declares that the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom and justice and peace in the world.
One of the authors of this document was a Lebanese diplomat named Charles Malik, who would go on to become president of this assembly.
Mr. Malik insisted that these principles applied equally to all people, of all regions, of all religions, including the men and women of the Arab world that was his home.
In the nearly six decades since that document was approved, we have seen the forces of freedom and moderation transform entire continents. Sixty years after a terrible war, Europe is now whole, free and at peace, and Asia has seen freedom progress and hundreds of millions of people lifted out of desperate poverty.
The words of the Universal Declaration are as true today as they were when they were written.
As liberty flourishes, nations grow in tolerance and hope and peace. And we’re seeing that bright future begin to take root in the broader Middle East.
Some of the changes in the Middle East have been dramatic, and we see the results in this chamber.
Five years ago, Afghanistan was ruled by the brutal Taliban regime, and its seat in this body was contested.
Now this seat is held by the freely elected government of Afghanistan, which is represented today by President Karzai.
Five years ago, Iraq’s seat in this body was held by a dictator who killed his citizens, invaded his neighbors and showed his contempt for the world by defying more than a dozen U.N. Security Council resolutions.
Now Iraq’s seat is held by a democratic government that embodies the aspirations of the Iraq people. It is represented today by President Talabani.
With these changes, more than 50 million people have been give a voice in this chamber for the first time in decades.
Some of the changes in the Middle East are happening gradually, but they are real. Algeria has held its first competitive presidential election, and the military remained neutral.
The United Arab Emirates recently announced that half of its seats in the Federal National Council will be chosen by elections.
Kuwait held elections in which women were allowed to vote and run for office for the first time.
Citizens have voted in municipal elections in Saudi Arabia and parliamentary elections in Jordan and Bahrain and in multiparty presidential elections in Yemen and Egypt.
These are important steps, and the governments should continue to move forward with other reforms that show they trust their people.
Every nation that travels the road to freedom moves at a different pace and the democracies they build will reflect their own culture and traditions.
But the destination is the same: a free society where people live at peace with each other and at peace with the world.
Some have argued that the democratic changes we’re seeing in the Middle East are destabilizing the region.
This argument rests on a false assumption: that the Middle East was stable to begin with.
The reality is that the stability we thought we saw in the Middle East was a mirage.
For decades, millions of men and women in the region had been trapped in oppression and hopelessness. And these conditions left a generation disillusioned and made this region a breeding ground for extremism.
Imagine what it’s like to be a young person living in a country that is not moving toward reform. You’re 21 years old, and while your peers in other parts of the world are casting their ballots for the first time, you are powerless to change the course of your government.
While your peers in other parts of the world have received educations that prepare them for the opportunities of a global economy, you have been fed propaganda and conspiracy theories that blame others for your country’s shortcomings.
And everywhere you turn, you hear extremists who tell you that you can escape your misery and regain your dignity through violence and terror and martyrdom.
For many across the broader Middle East this is the dismal choice presented every day.
Every civilized nation, including those in the Muslim world, must support those in the region who are offering a more hopeful alternative.
We know that when people have a voice in their future, they are less likely to blow themselves up in suicide attacks. We know that when leaders are accountable to their people, they are more likely to seek national greatness in the achievements of their citizens, rather than in terror and conquest.
So we must stand with democratic leaders and moderate reformers across the broader Middle East. We must give them voice to the hopes of decent men and women who want for their children the same thing we want for ours.
We must seek stability through a free and just Middle East, where the extremists are marginalized by millions of citizens in control of their own destinies.
Today I’d like to speak directly to the people across the broader Middle East.
My country desires peace. Extremists in your midst spread propaganda claiming that the West is engaged in a war against Islam.
This propaganda is false and its purpose is to confuse you and justify acts of terror. We respect Islam, but we will protect our people from those who pervert Islam to sow death and destruction.
Our goal is to help you build a more tolerant and hopeful society that honors people of all faiths and promotes the peace.
To the people of Iraq, nearly 12 million of you braved the car bombers and assassins last December to vote in free elections.
The world saw you hold up purple-ink-stained fingers. And your courage filled us with admiration.
You stood firm in the face of horrendous acts of terror and sectarian violence. And we will not abandon you and your struggle to build a free nation.
America and our coalition partners will continue to stand with the democratic government you elected. We will continue to help you secure the international assistance and investment you need to create jobs and opportunity, working with the United Nations and through the international compact with Iraq endorsed here in New York yesterday.
We will continue to train those of you who step forward to fight the enemies of freedom. We will not yield the future of your country to terrorists and extremists.
In return, your leaders must rise to the challenges your country is facing and make difficult choices to bring security and prosperity.
Working together, we will help your democracy succeed so it can become a beacon of hope for millions in the Muslim world.
To the people of Afghanistan, together we overthrew the Taliban regime that brought misery into your lives and harbored terrorists who brought death to the citizens of many nations.
Since then, we have watched you choose your leaders in free elections and build a democratic government.
You can be proud of these achievements.
We respect your courage and determination to live in peace and freedom. We will continue to stand with you to defend your democratic gains.
Today, forces from more than 40 countries, including members of the NATO alliance, are bravely serving side by side with you against the extremists who want to bring down the free government you’ve established. We’ll help you defeat these enemies and build a free Afghanistan that will never again oppress you or be a safe haven for terrorists.
To the people of Lebanon, last year you inspired the world when you came out into the streets to demand your independence from Syrian dominance.
You drove Syrian forces from your country and you re-established democracy. Since then, you have been tested by the fighting that began with Hezbollah’s unprovoked attacks on Israel. Many of you have seen your homes and your communities caught in crossfire.
We see your suffering and the world is helping you to rebuild your country and helping you deal with the armed extremists who are undermining your democracy by acting as a state within a state.
The United Nations has passed a good resolution that has authorized an international force, led by France and Italy, to help you restore Lebanese sovereignty over Lebanese soil.
For many years, Lebanon was a model of democracy and pluralism and openness in the region. And it will be again.
To the people of Iran, the United States respects you.
We respect your country. We admire your rich history, your vibrant culture and your many contributions to civilization.
You deserve an opportunity to determine your own future, an economy that rewards your intelligence and your talents, and a society that allows you to fulfill your tremendous potential.
The greatest obstacle to this future is that your rulers have chosen to deny you liberty and to use your nation’s resources to fund terrorism and fuel extremism and pursue nuclear weapons.
The United Nations has passed a clear resolution requiring that the regime in Tehran meet its international obligations. Iran must abandon its nuclear weapons ambitions.
Despite what the regime tells you, we have no objection to Iran’s pursuit of a truly peaceful nuclear power program.
We’re working toward a diplomatic solution to this crisis. And as we do, we look to the day when you can live in freedom, and America and Iran can be good friends and close partners in the cause of peace.

Continue reading →

Milestone

Early this morning, SDA passed a milestone of sorts – comment #100,000!
Honour goes to Gunney99, in the “What do we need guns for anyway” thread. (Which seems pretty lively)
(Speaking of comments threads, there’s an interesting discussion to check out on the Benedict On Islam post from September 13th.)
Much of the success of SDA is due to the wealth of reader tips and discussion. Thanks to everyone for your contributions!

FBI Raids Largest Islamic Charity In The USA

Debbie Schlussel:

This morning, the FBI began raiding LIFE and hauling out documents. Well, it’s about time. LIFE–the largest Islamic charity still open for business in America–openly admitted on its 1995-’97 taxes to be a major funder of HAMAS. Headquartered in the Orthodox Jewish suburban Detroit subdivision in which I grew up, it gave millions to Human Appeal International, which the FBI identified as HAMAS’ Jordanian operation. It has done many vague “Katrina,” “Lebanon Relief,” and “Afghanistan Wheelchair” fundraisers and believed to have laundered the money to terrorists. Its founding resident agent is tied to Al-Qaeda, and one of its former employees Abdel-Jabbar Hamdan is also tied to terrorists. The government has been trying to deport him.

Google News indicates this story is still largely confined to local media.

“What do we need guns for anyway?”

In the comments, Bryceman asks for help;

I have a question for my fellow conservatives. 99% of the time, I can handle myself well in a political discussion/debate on any of the hot-button topics of the day. And I can usually send the more left-leaning of my political adversaries to the defensive. Not in a bad way. Most of the people I discuss politics with are very cool and reasonable people who will give and take political points on grey-area issues. These aren’t knock-down, drag-out arguments with extremists…just friendly debate.
But, there is one approach to one topic that I never have a very good come-back for. It’s about gun control.
Now, I don’t actually own any firearms. While I have not kept the tradition alive, I come from a long line of hunters. I used to be certified to handle and carry guns (except for restricted weapons). But, my old certification was declared null and void (thank-you Mr. Rock) because I hadn’t had it since before 1979.
So, I have to take it all over again. And I will – since I am set to inherit some guns that have been in my family – some of them going back as far as the 1870’s.
Anyway, when something like the Dawson College incident happens, I always react by saying, “Hunters and farmers from BC to Newfoundland will be made to pay for this.”
And my “less-right” political sparring partners respond by posing questions like, “Yeah. But, in today’s world, what do we need guns for anyway? And what’s the limit on what kind of guns a person should be allowed to own? Should they be allowed to own a tank? How about a SAM launcher?”
I’m never able to answer these kinds of questions to my own satisfaction. I never get that “slam-dunk” feeling when arguing back. Sure, I can go on about the creeping nature of the state unecessarily taking away the rights of law abiding citizens in a hollow response to a problem (like Dawson) that has nothing to do with them. But, I can’t go much further without my own argument sounding weak – even to me. Second Ammendment arguments don’t have any relevance in Canada. And, as I am a prime example, the argument that there is a need to hunt for you and your family’s food is all but gone in the modern world.
Has anyone got a suggestion on how to answer this one better?

Yes, I do. Concede the point.
“I agree. There is no need in today’s world for a citizen to own a gun.”
Having come to agreement that “need” is the threshold for a citizen’s right to own a firearm, the discussion is ready to move forward.
Announce to your friend that you are ready to accompany them to their home. You will begin with an inspection of the kitchen, and from there, will work your way through their house, tagging each possession you believe they do not need in “today’s world”.
Don’t forget the garage.
There’s no logical reason to limit the inspection to possessions that pose a threat as weapons. With the consequences that await society from global warming, and the alarming increase in energy consumption, those homes with a television in every room, two cars in the garage, and appliances of pure convenience – food processors, cappuccino makers – cappuccino makers! – must come under review.
Tagged items will then be removed to a truck and taken to a location for safe disposal.
Explain that only possessions for which you determine there is current need will be allowed to remain – the “greater good” is not open to negotiation. You might point out that this position is perfectly consistant with your friend’s determination that there is no “need” to own a firearm. The only thing that has changed is the person doing the determining.
(In addition to those tagged for immediate seizure, items with the potential to become unecessary in the “today’s world” of tomorrow will be recorded in a registry. In that way, future unecessaries may be confiscated more efficiently. Some accomodation may be made for heirlooms and items with sentimental importance – antique automobiles, plasma tv’s, recreational vehicles – so long as they are rendered permanently inoperable. Plus, they’ll need a permit.)
When you are interrupted – and you will be interrupted – ask your friend this;
If “need” is to be a criteria for the private ownership of property, then what’s so damned special about guns? And if the definition of a citizen’s “need” is at the perogative of the state, then what’s so damned special about yours?

The Canadian Press Geography Project (Updated)

Take the “Find Afghanistan On A Map Quiz for Canadian Reporters”

Play the game here!
Then, sent the link along to “Sylvain Larocque, correspondent parlementaire”, care of editors@cp.org.
(Story here)
h/t – Maz2 in the comments
UPDATE – Sylvain Larocque explains in the comments;

Hello everyone,
I don’t want to hide, but it was actually a translation mistake. The original story can be found
here.

Thanks for the clarification, Sylvain.

Reader Tips

Two of these things are kinda the same.
Keep track of your favourite blogs with Google Reader.
Elections in Yemen. No, really.
Operation Medusa wraps up – ” described as one of their biggest battles since the Second World War”.
Gunmen have shot dead

… an elderly Italian nun and her bodyguard in the Somali capital Mogadishu.
The attackers shot the nun three times in the back at a children’s hospital in the south of the city, before fleeing the scene.
It is unclear if the shooting is connected with strong criticism by a radical Somali cleric about the Pope’s recent comments on Islam.

Allah Akbar.

Kevin Yates

In the wake of yesterday’s provincial cabinet shuffle and the questions about Regina Dewdney’s Kevin Yates’ departure, a reader emails with the following speculation ;

Kevin Yates was thrown out of Lorne Calvert’s cabinet today for actively promoting Dwain Lingenfelter for new Leader. In a caucus meeting held Monday only 6 NDP MLAs showed up the balance stayed away to protest to Lorne’s Leadership. The NDP are in disarray and Lorne has lost the support of his caucus. By firing Yates Lorne has shown that he intends to stay no matter what.

“This is a form of dishonesty that has become common in journalism today.”

David Warren

This was not a crude anti-Islamic polemic; nor was it so at the end of the 14th century. It was a quest for peace and amity, then as now.
By turning the story back-to-front, so that what’s promised in the lead — a crude attack on Islam — is quietly withdrawn much later in the text, the BBC journalists were having a little mischief. The kind of mischief that is likely to end with Catholic priests and faithful butchered around the Muslim world. Either the writers were so jaw-droppingly ignorant, they did not realize this is what they were abetting (always a possibility with the postmodern journalist), or the malice was intended. There is no third possibility.
From the start, the BBC’s reports said the Pope would “face criticism from Muslim leaders” — in the present tense. This is a form of dishonesty that has become common in journalism today. The flagrantly biased reporter, feigning objectivity, spices his story by just guessing what a man’s enemies will say, even before they have spoken.
[…]
From now on, the reporting will be about the Muslim rage, and whether the Vatican has apologized yet. That is the “drama” the media will seek to capture — the drama of the cockfight — because they know no better kind. That the Pope said nothing intrinsically objectionable will be overlooked, in deference to the Muslim rage, just as the media hid the Danish cartoons from their viewers — preventing them from discovering how mild they were.

Looks like the project was a success. Though I doubt this will make it to the front pages of the New York Times.
popeqaeda.jpg
(Via Michelle Malkin)
The script in red calls for his beheading.

Navigation