Y2Kyoto: No Blood For Biodiesel!

What’s a green revolution wiithout a massacre?

Armed groups in Colombia are driving peasants off their land to make way for plantations of palm oil, a biofuel that is being promoted as an environmentally friendly source of energy.
Surging demand for “green” fuel has prompted rightwing paramilitaries to seize swaths of territory, according to activists and farmers. Thousands of families are believed to have fled a campaign of killing and intimidation, swelling Colombia’s population of 3 million displaced people and adding to one of the world’s worst refugee crises after Darfur and Congo.
[…]
“As a consequence of the development of palm by secretive business practices and the use of threats, people have been displaced and [the businesses] have claimed land for themselves,” he said. His claim was backed up by witnesses and groups such as Christian Aid and the National Indigenous Organisation of Colombia.
The revelations tarnish what has been considered an economic and environmental success story. The fruit of the palm oil tree produces a vegetable oil also used in cooking, employs 80,000 people, and is increasingly being turned into biofuel.
“Four years ago Colombia had 172,000 hectares of palm oil,” President Alvaro Uribe told the Guardian. “This year we expect to finish with nearly 400,000.”
“Four years ago Colombia didn’t produce a litre of biofuel. Today, because of our administration, Colombia produces 1.2m litres per day.” Investment in new installations would continue to boost production, he added.
However the lawlessness created by four decades of insurgency in the countryside has enabled rightwing paramilitaries, and also possibly leftwing rebels, to join the boom. Unlike coca, the armed groups’ main income source, palm oil is a legal crop and therefore safe from state-backed eradication efforts.

Before you chime in with kneejerk outrage, think of the big picture, not to mention the opportunities.
Dead Peasant Carbon Credits.
It could work.
(h/t reader Karl.)

“Reporting Today From Sleepy Hollow…”

It already has a name – DeCapiGate.

I’m not Associated Press reporter Sinan Salheddin, nor am I Kim Gamel, AP’s Baghdad news editor, but if I was investigating a story about a 20-corpse mass murder in—let’s say, Manhattan—then I’d try to find a local police officer at the scene to interview about the case.
I wouldn’t rely on a desk sergeant in Staten Island who merely heard reports of other officers being dispatched to check to see if there was such a crime, nor would I rely on a beat cop in Albany who is only reporting rumors of what he heard from friends of relatives in Queens.
But the Associated Press didn’t rely on the local police. Instead, they blatantly presented hearsay as the truth, and as a result, ran a story about a brutal massacre that currently appears to have never taken place.

Greyhawk, via Instapundit;

I’m shocked – shocked I tell you, to read this. I haven’t heard of such a thing since the last time the news reported a bogus headless bodies story.

Or the time before that.
On June 30th, the report was challenged.

June 30, 2007 Release A070630c
Extremists using false media reporting to incite sectarian violence
BAGHDAD, Iraq – Friday, news media reported a mass killing in a village near Salman Pak where 20 men were allegedly found beheaded. It now appears that the story was completely false and fabricated by unknown sources.
Upon learning of the press reports, coalition and Iraqi officials began investigating to determine if the reports were true. Ultimately it was concluded the reports were false.
Anti-Iraqi Forces are known for purposely providing false information to the media to incite violence and revenge killings, and they may well have been the source of this misinformation.
“Extremists promote falsehoods of mass killings, collateral damage and other violence specifically to turn Iraqis against other Iraqis,” said Rear Admiral Mark Fox, spokesperson for MNF-I. “Unfortunately, lies are much easier to state, the truth often takes time to prove,” said Fox.
Not all media reports can be immediately substantiated by Government of Iraq or Coalition Forces. They must go through a process to verify such claims, to include checking with various Iraqi Ministry’s, local police and security forces. Meanwhile, extremists have achieved their goal of spreading false information aimed at intimidating civilians and destabilizing Iraqi security.
Ultimately, media reporting based on verifiable sources will reduce the possibility of misinformation unnecessarily alarming citizens.

I know you didn’t learn this via the media that originally reported repeated the item.
AFP is one of few news services that has responded.

The US military accused the international media on Saturday of exacerbating Iraq’s violent tensions by reporting false claims of massacres which it said were deliberately fabricated by extremist groups.
This week several newspapers and agencies reported that Iraqi police had found 20 beheaded corpses in Salman Pak, just south of Baghdad.
AFP did not carry the report after its sources were unable to confirm the rumour.

While the Associated Press and their parrots in the mainstream media regurgitate second hand information from Iraqi “police” at locations more than an hour from the alleged crime scenes, freelance Iraq embed Michael Yon is delivering the goods on verifiable atrocities, supported entirely by his readers and out-performing them all. And he’s totally ignored.
This is why people cancel subscriptions.
Update – Both AP and Reuters have now retracted the story, citing the usual excuse: “war reporting is hard”. (Yes it is. See Michael Yon.)
Bob Owens;

Throughout the Iraq War, and with seemingly increasing frequency over the past year, these media outlets have become increasingly reliant upon anonymous sources and questionable sources hiding behind pseudonyms to deliver “news” with no apparent basis in fact.
In some of these instances, these wire services have been forced to retract days later, as they have with the false Um al-Abeed beheading story. Sadly, the international and national news outlets that often carry the initial claims as “page one” material fail to do so with the refutations, leaving most media consumers with the impression that the original account was accurate.
Remarkably, these news organizations continue to employ the same reporters and editors that have published multiple erroneous or highly suspect claims, or who have consistently cited discredited or disreputable sources.
Further, these wire services continue to employ newsgathering techniques that rely upon anonymous sources with little or no direct involvement with the story being reported, and often publish these claims as absolute fact, without any indication they are publishing what is often, at best, hearsay.
The MNF-I refutation of the Um al-Abeed decapitation story states that the claim was “completely false and fabricated by unknown sources.”
That isn’t exactly true. Both Reuters and the Associated Press presumably know precisely who their sources were for this story, as they know who their sources were for other discredited stories.
They just as they certainly know, or should know, which of their indigenous reporters—”stringers,” in industry parlance—have been providing these suspect or discredited stories, and which editors have allowed these stories to press based upon the flimsiest of evidence, which often does not meet the service’s own stated reportorial standards.
To date, these wire services have consistently failed to visibly enforce standards of reporting, and in some instances, have promoted employees involved in using questionable sources and printing false claims. Once promoted, these same employees only further degrade editorial standards, leading to the public’s increasing distrust of these news organizations.

And deservedly so.

Y2Kyoto: Saving The Planet One Empty Seat At A Time

Another inconvenient box office ;

Continued weak demand for the singing saviors of climate change
With the worldwide “Live Earth” concert on July 7, Hamburg wants to protect the climate and take its place next to other metropolitan venues such as London, Tokyo and Sydney. But only half of the tickets have been sold. Hamburg tourist officials are giving away the tickets in promotional packages.

Perhaps they can recycle the empty seats as carbon credits. As it stands, the City of Hamburg looks to be on the hook, with the concert unlikely to break even.
(Someone might put them in touch with the Saskatchewan government – world leaders in flogging Al Gore tickets).
More;

Kevin Wall, Al Gore’s new-found partner producer of Live Earth previously founded Network Live to make money, not save the poor. It did neither.
It failed as a business and as an effort to fight poverty. Next he saw Al Gore’s film and, lo and behold, Control Room was born. It’s partners? MSN, DirectTV, Qualcom, etc…. It don’t mean a thing, if it don’t bring the green – and I don’t mean as regards the environment. Same opportunist, different snake oil. zzzzzzzzzzz

The concerts are in trouble in Turkey and South Africa as well.

The Johannesburg leg of the Live Earth concerts has shifted venues due to lack of ticket sales at original venue.
The show will now take place at the 18,000 capacity Coca Cola Dome in the city as opposed to the original venue in Maropeng.
[…]
The Istanbul leg of the event was cancelled last week, due to lack of sponsorship interest.

Doctors

Without borders;

[B]oth doctors trained in their home countries, neither of them practised there. As soon as they qualified, they left for the west, whose government health services have a chronic shortage of medical personnel that can only be filled by fast-track immigration from almost anywhere on the planet. If that’s a strategic decision to exploit a vulnerable express check-in to the western world (as they did with Britain’s fast-track imam immigration program of the Nineties), it’s an extremely canny one.

Story: Five doctors held over attacks. Freedom fighters, driven by despair, poverty and hopelessness.
Update: And another, arrested in Brisbane. (h/t Maz2)
Should the term “terror cell” be updated to “terror practice”? One wonders what the hell is going on here.
Oh, looks like terror practice is appropriate. (On a different topic – someone help me out here. How does a 26-year-old become a practicing neurologist? What is this, the Readers Digest version of medical school or just Mohammed Jamil Howzer?)
With the numbers of foreign-trained doctors peopling our marvellous medical system, all ll I can say is that I hope CSIS is on scramble orders tonight.

Canada – “The national beer glass half full” perspective

As we enjoy this national day off, John Robson has penned a patriotic column that almost brings a tear to the eye:

I would like to be more positive. But I cannot do a Maple Leaf Forever kind of column, not least because that aspect of our heritage is not exactly popular with the smart set. Americans generally lay aside their grievances on the 4th of July because they regard their history as fundamentally glorious. But here the official view is quite different. Our statesmen were bigots, our industrialists rapacious, our scholars hegemonist, our soldiers war criminals, and our past a shabby nightmare from which we are only now awakening.

Okay, I said almost.

“As these graves were being unearthed, more bombs were found in London.”

Michael Yon;

Captain Clayton Combs has been fighting hard in Diyala for about ten months, much of it side-by-side with Iraqi soldiers from the 5th Division. Each time I’ve come into contact with the 5th, they seem far better than most. American officers and sergeants who work with the 5th have good things to report about them, saying that although the 5th still has far to go, and cannot sustain itself logistically, it can fight.
Captain Combs said this particular Iraqi unit, the 3-25, has never run away from combat, and never refused to close on the enemy. Combs said, “I’ve fought with 3-25 for 10 months in Diyala and they have always come when I am in trouble. They always go on patrols when I ask. They never back down.”
I asked Captain Combs to repeat what he said, making sure he knew I was planning to quote him directly. A veteran like Combs would be unlikely to append his name to such words if he weren’t dead serious. Captain Combs repeated his words and stuck by them. He then demonstrated that faith when we took off deeper into the danger zone with nine soldiers from 5th IA: just Captain Combs, Iraqi soldiers and me. As we passed through the village, Captain Combs pointed out the nice houses, saying the people had been simple farmers with comfortable homes and lives.
Until al Qaeda came.

When you’re finished, these thoughts from Michael Ledeen.

Navigation