My Conservative Dreamworld has a nice catch ;
Now, there is nothing wrong with journalists piggy-backing on other writers; for example, they may add their own spin to a story, or compress it for readers who don�t need the full details. Roberts does indeed acknowledge K�ntzel and the New Republic directly as the source of one item of information. But as the quotations below indicate, he has basically lifted not merely facts from K�ntzel�s piece but whole paragraphs. How this duplication escaped the Mop�s editors is a mystery to readers. It will surely prove an embarrassment to the paper.
The paper in question is the Globe & Mail, Matthias K�ntzel is the author of Ahmadinejad’s Demons (mentioned here last week) and the Globe writer is Paul William Roberts. Just one of several such paragraphs;
K�ntzel: The Basiji’s cult of self-destruction would be chilling in any country. In the context of the Iranian nuclear program, however, its obsession with martyrdom amounts to a lit fuse. Nowadays, Basiji are sent not into the desert, but rather into the laboratory. Basij students are encouraged to enroll in technical and scientific disciplines. According to a spokesperson for the Revolutionary Guard, the aim is to use the “technical factor” in order to augment “national security.”
Roberts: A past immersed in such a cult of self-destruction would be chillingly ominous in any country. In the context of the Iranian nuclear program, however, this obsession with martyrdom is deeply worrying. Basiji followers are no longer sent into the desert; now, they go into the laboratory. Basij students are encouraged to enroll in technical and scientific disciplines. According to a spokesman for the Revolutionary Guard, the aim is to use the “technical factor” in order to augment “national security.”
Uh oh.
April 27 Update: Thankyou to Angus Frame (editor of globeandmail.com) – for stopping by in the comments to notify readers that this was published today, both online and in print;
Clarification – A profile of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad that appeared in last Saturday’s Focus section referred to a story about the Iranian President in the current issue of The New Republic. After an investigation by The Globe and Mail, it appears that notes by the author were mistakenly inserted into the story without proper attribution. The Globe has apologized to The New Republic and regrets the error.




