One Of These Things Is A Lot Like The Other

My Conservative Dreamworld has a nice catch ;

Now, there is nothing wrong with journalists piggy-backing on other writers; for example, they may add their own spin to a story, or compress it for readers who don�t need the full details. Roberts does indeed acknowledge K�ntzel and the New Republic directly as the source of one item of information. But as the quotations below indicate, he has basically lifted not merely facts from K�ntzel�s piece but whole paragraphs. How this duplication escaped the Mop�s editors is a mystery to readers. It will surely prove an embarrassment to the paper.

The paper in question is the Globe & Mail, Matthias K�ntzel is the author of Ahmadinejad’s Demons (mentioned here last week) and the Globe writer is Paul William Roberts. Just one of several such paragraphs;

K�ntzel: The Basiji’s cult of self-destruction would be chilling in any country. In the context of the Iranian nuclear program, however, its obsession with martyrdom amounts to a lit fuse. Nowadays, Basiji are sent not into the desert, but rather into the laboratory. Basij students are encouraged to enroll in technical and scientific disciplines. According to a spokesperson for the Revolutionary Guard, the aim is to use the “technical factor” in order to augment “national security.”
Roberts: A past immersed in such a cult of self-destruction would be chillingly ominous in any country. In the context of the Iranian nuclear program, however, this obsession with martyrdom is deeply worrying. Basiji followers are no longer sent into the desert; now, they go into the laboratory. Basij students are encouraged to enroll in technical and scientific disciplines. According to a spokesman for the Revolutionary Guard, the aim is to use the “technical factor” in order to augment “national security.”

Uh oh.

April 27 Update: Thankyou to Angus Frame (editor of globeandmail.com) – for stopping by in the comments to notify readers that this was published today, both online and in print;

Clarification – A profile of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad that appeared in last Saturday’s Focus section referred to a story about the Iranian President in the current issue of The New Republic. After an investigation by The Globe and Mail, it appears that notes by the author were mistakenly inserted into the story without proper attribution. The Globe has apologized to The New Republic and regrets the error.

From A Canadian Forces Widow

Yesterday I received an email that I’ve received permission to share. I’ve edited the identifying details, as the writer would like to preserve her privacy;

Hi Kate,
I have enjoyed your blog since discovered it during the election.
I trust if you share any of my email that you would keep me anonymous please. I am still having *issues* to say the least with regards to my husbands death.
[The investigation into the circumstances of his death during a training exercise] is still ongoing, at least I think it is. I have never EVER been officially updated on it. That said, the only thing that has been confirmed is there was no pilot error (important for me and my husbands memory to bring that up).
The reason I am emailing you is the issue of banning the media from the base when the soldiers’ remains are returned to their families. While my husband was not overseas, I will share with you my personal experience with the media and a very public death.
Thankfully the media had yet to discover my house when I had to go see my husband for the first time. They found me by 6 AM the following morning. My parents had driven up immediately after my frantic phone call. My father stepped outside to get the papers and he was besieged (to say it lightly) with media camped out in my driveway! They were knocking at my door, putting the cameras on us as we opened it. There was always their cars there, with them sitting in them, waiting for someone to come or go. Phone call after phone call to the house when the lines were needed for more important issues. Our grief was made very public. I was asked if I wanted media at the funeral and I agreed to have them there. I wanted the people of Canada to know that even when Canada’s sons and daughters do not go overseas, lives are put on the lone on a daily basis for the safety and security of every Canadian. To show them how the phrase “military cut backs’ translates into real life in the forces. I had insisted that there not be a close up on any family member. I was sure Joe Blow watching the news did not need to see my tears, or those of my children to know we were distraught. Yet this rule was broken.
The media also pushed for the release of the names of those killed ASAP. Why?? Does it matter to Joe Blow? Shouldn’t it matter more that ALL family (not just immediate) and close friends are informed personally even by phone than to hear it on the news? Families of victims killed in auto accidents can request that the names not be released and Joe Blow doesn’t complain.
About the Peace tower and the flag flap, if anyone understand tradition it is a military member and his family. Did I expect the flag at the Peace tower to be flown at 1/2 mast for my husband?? oh hell no! But I did expect a phone call or something from our Prime Minister? Just the letter with his stamped signature would have to be good enough. He was in Europe and there is no way that letter was written there and sent to me to receive so quickly. It is also noticeable the signature is from a stamp and not hand signed. I did get a touching phone call and a lovely letter from the Governor General, HE Clarkson.
I will end this letter now. I could go on but I am sure you don’t want to hear all the sordid details of how a military widow is really treated.
Except to add, that if I were to walk into funerals of people I didn’t know stating it is my right to know who they are etc I’d be frowned on or even thrown out.

Think of this email when you see the tape replays shot by CTV news yesterday from over the fence at CFB Trenton.
If you’ve never forwarded a post from SDA to family and friends before – consider doing it with this one. The media has been screaming for tranparency. Well, let’s give it to them. Turn the “camera” back on the microphone holders for a change, and let ordinary Canadians see the mob for the self-absorbed ratings vultures that they are.

Reporting From Indianville

An open thread on the Caledonia standoff at Dust My Broom. Rasky writes;

No other right-leaning blog out there is doing anything like this, and
I want to hear what people have to say. I’m getting really sick of the
MSM lapdogs and IndyMedia anarchists hogging the web.

Lots of updates and commentary.
Be sure to contribute your comments there first – not here. Crosspost afterwards if you wish.
Update – from DMB comments, the QOTW;

“They have counted coup on the all-season radial. Warriors indeed.”

Tommy Douglas: Thankyou For Waiting

The Paige Hansen story isn’t going away. The radio airwaves have been burning with angry callers and others relating similar health system horror stories. CKOM broke the story, and has been following it closely ever since. The Saskatoon health authority is launching a review – an internal review.
From Question Period yesterday. (PDF) (The whole exchange is quite a read)
calvert_paige.jpg
Babies come and go. But fundamental principles endure.
That of course, doesn’t mean that under the Calvert NDP, the system hasn’t done everything in its power to streamline – the Saskatchewan Surgical Care Network has a website that allows tracking of surgical wait times. They also feature a phone number you can call to find out where you are on the waiting list: 1-866-622-0222.
*RRRIIIINNNG*

“Due to the high volume of calls, it may take us a few days to get back to you.”

“‘Canada’s Iraq’ Indeed”

(bumped to top due to continuing updates)
From Army.ca, a military message forum, reaction to media coverage over the government’s decision to return to previous traditions when honouring fallen soldiers;

Once again, I’m fed up and disgusted with the media and their “spinning” of non-issues into something more. Yet again, TV tonight is awash with “Conservatives won’t lower the flag” stories – presented with no background and with plenty of people saying what an “insult” it is to soldiers. They have no idea what soldiers think of this issue, yet are ready to jump to conclusions in an effort to speak for us.
To the media reading this (and I have no doubt you are): how much is enough? You have plenty of coverage of the coffins being put on the plane and I have no doubt you’ll have plenty of the funerals – invited or not. Get a grip. We are the Army; it is a sad reality that part of our job is to take casualties on behalf of Canadians and our elected political masters – of whatever stripe. Don’t denegrate that sacrifice with an unseemly and politically motivated display of spin designed to promote controversy and generate ratings. “Canada’s Iraq” indeed…

h/t Mark Collins in the comments. (Mark is also now blogging at Daimnation).
More from Chris Selley, who also agrees with the Conservative policy (and looks back at contrasting news coverage during WWI). No nation can fight a war wallowing in a state of perpetual mourning. The flag should fly high and defiantly.
(As an aside, this debate over the growing frequency of flag lowering is not new – I recall reading a few weeks ago an anecdote about a school flag being lowered on the occasion of the death of a janitor.)
Another comment from an army reservist;

As a member of the army reserve I am sick of the MSM�s facination with flag draped coffins. They are always ready to show the coffin but but there�s barely a mention (maybe one or 2 sentences)of the work done by the men in those coffins.
Journalists are scumbags who are too lazy & dumb to do anything of any value themselves so they have to achieve cheap fame by leeching off the triumphs or tragedies of others. They then justify being the town gossip by pretending everything they utter is in the public�s interest. � Yeah right. Running up to a plane to photograph coffins is in the public interest? geezuz!
What do you low-lifes in the press do for fun? Go down to the dog pound with some pop & chips and watch them euthanize strays?

If you want to register your objection to Craig Oliver’s nakedly political editorializing, you can do so here. If anyone has his personal email address, drop it in the comments.
Commentor ET points to a Globe and Mail message board, where Lew MacKenzie is fielding questions link;

MacKenzie asks readers – ‘We lost 27 killed in Bosnia/Croatia in the 90’s”…and no-one paid any attention…Same in the Sudan, Congo, Golan Heights – “absolutely no-one called for the flags to be lowered”.
He further comments “I’m glad to see the public paying attention for a change – particularly those who slashed the budget and personnel strengths during the same 90s'”
So- why didn’t the Liberals lower the Peace Tower flag before? And why did they reduce the capacity of the military to protect themselves and us?
That is -point two- the flag lowering, once, on the Peace Tower, for those four soldiers killed by US-Canadian error – was a deliberate partisan political tactic of Chretien. It had nothing to do with respect, but was actually disrespectful, for Chretien/the Liberals used those soldiers.

Canadian Media Adopt American-Style “Drive By” Reporting

Stephen Taylor has begun to document the flood of gratuitous comparisons between Stephen Harper and Darth Bush’s Rethuglamericans.
Stephen – that’s a job for a team of bloggers.
Definition: Drive By Media
The perplexing part about this growing trend to tie Harper’s policies to those of Bush is that it’s taking place in the duly diligent world of fact-checking, editor supervised, professional journalism. WaPo, 2003;

A Pentagon spokeswoman said the military-wide policy [barring media from covering return of “flag-draped coffins”] actually dates from about November 2000 — the last days of the Clinton administration […] Dover Air Force Base, which has the military’s largest mortuary, has had restrictions for 12 years, others “may not have been familiar with the policy,” the spokeswoman said. This year, “we’ve really tried to enforce it.”

“Harper’s policies on Afghanistan sounding increasingly Clinton-like”. Somehow, I doubt we’re going to see that in the headlines.

End Run On The YCJA

A reader points to this Globe and Mail coverage of the multiple murders in Medicine Hat over the weekend. A 23 year old Jeremy Allan Steinke, and a 12 year old girl, whose identity is protected under the Youth Criminal Justice Act, were arrested in Leader, Sk.

Now, three members of that family — Mr. and Mrs. Richardson, and their grade-school-aged son — are dead, killed in their tidy four-level house some time before Sunday afternoon, police say. The elder child, a girl, is not dead.

Of course, there’s always Google News, where memories last a little longer.
More here. (Parents – get the computers out into the family room, where you can watch what your kids do, ok?)

Oil-For-Wheat Scandal

The Australian Wheat Board – OFF scandal is updated in this piece by Prime Minister John Howard, appearing in today’s WSJ. (Behind subscriber wall);

The Australian government is serious about prosecuting the perpetrators of Iraq’s Oil for Food scam. In fact, my government has gone further than any other to investigate what part any company played in Saddam Hussein’s vast, illegal profiteering of public funds.
Australia’s wheat exporter AWB Ltd. figured prominently in last year’s United Nations report, prepared by former U.S. Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker. Mr. Volcker identified almost 2,400 companies from more than 60 countries that paid $1.8 billion in kickbacks to Saddam’s regime. Of those companies, the Volcker report found that AWB had funneled more than $211 million to the Iraqi government, in the form of contract kickbacks. Mr. Volcker’s remit did not extend to prosecuting those named, nor did he discuss AWB’s knowledge of any wrongdoing. But he strongly suggested that nations follow the trail.
My government responded swiftly to the Volcker report, establishing a public judicial inquiry with wide-ranging powers headed by one of Australia’s most respected legal figures, former judge Terence Cole. We empowered the inquiry to subpoena witnesses, compel the production of documents and refer possible criminal charges to the director of public prosecutions. The Cole Commission, as it is known, carries the full powers of the Australian legal system.
[…]
It should also be remembered that the overthrow of Saddam’s regime provided, for the first time, access to documents which helped reveal to a greater extent the systematic defrauding of the Oil for Food program by the former Iraqi government. If Saddam Hussein were still in power in Iraq, the depth of the Oil for Food swindle would remain hidden amongst secret documents scattered through government offices in Baghdad.
Others charge that my government limited the inquiry’s terms of reference to prevent it making a finding against a minister or myself. This too is a falsehood. Mr. Cole has the power to make findings on the government’s knowledge of the kickbacks. I have said there will be serious consequences for any minister identified as possessing that knowledge and failing to act. This includes me.
We will act on any recommendations of the inquiry, whatever it finds. But I shall not allow my government’s reputation, nor the reputations of our farmers, to be maligned. Attacks upon the latter are particularly unfair, given that our farmers’ incomes are only now beginning to recover from the effects of a long drought, one of the worst in our nation’s history.
The corruption by Saddam Hussein of the Oil for Food program was a heinous act of public graft. I am proud of my government’s ongoing commitment to meet its international obligations, by ensuring that any alleged breaches of the law by its nationals and corporations are comprehensively addressed.

Australian media reports indicate that it was well known among wheat traders that kickbacks were a cost of doing business under Saddam Hussein’s Oil-For-Food scheme. What isn’t so clear is why there is so little curiosity in that regard about the sales to Iraq by agents of the Canadian Wheat Board.
I’ll say it again – we are asked believe that a) it was “common knowledge among grains traders” that kickbacks to Saddam Hussein were a cost of doing business under the oil-for-food program, and b) Canadian grain traders were exempt.

Comment Policy

I’ve warned several of you in the various threads that my patience is growing short. There are a few simple rules here. If you cannot observe them, keep your fingers off the keyboard.
1. Stay on topic. That means everyone. There are Reader Tips threads for link dumping and general commentary.
2. Cut the profanity – there are people reading who are on work computers.
3. All points of view are welcome, but trolling is not. Those who persist will find their access denied without further notice. On that score, let me deal with the “drive by’s”. Don’t respond to them. (Troll definition)
4. This is not a chatboard. If you wish to pursue ongoing debate/chatter with another individual, get their email address and do it privately. Otherwise, send me a check for your share of the bandwidth.
Back to regular programming.

Tommy Douglas: Not Dead Enough

18 month old Paige Hansen is currently in a hospital in Edmonton. Her family finally decided Thursday to seek help elsewhere (doing so without “permission” from SaskHealth, and therefore at their own expense) after waiting three weeks for diagnosis of her pain in Saskatoon. The child was “screaming every waking minute”, and had stopped walking 6 days earlier. In the meantime, they were advised to give her children’s Tylenol.
According to a family member being interviewed, the care they received in Edmonton began immediately, testing was done during the first night there. This morning they have a preliminary diagnosis of leukemia.
You can listen live as the story is discussed this morning on John Gormley Live. (The show repeats in the evening for those who missed it – check the link for programming details).

For “Tony The Media Moley”

Near the end of this lengthy and contentious comments thread arising from the Aaron Harris photo post, “Tony” suggests that my criticism of the “mainstream media” arises from …. jealousy.
Hell hath no fury like a wanna-be journalist scorned, goes the theory.
It’s not the first time that accusation has been floated, nor am I the only blogger who’s been confronted with it. After I’d addressed that question, Tony repled;

Like hundreds or thousands of other people (and like dozens of MSM types) I enjoy your blog, even if I don’t always agree with your take on things, and like the vast majority of your readers I’m grateful that you take the time to do this and am glad you’re doing well enough to find the free time.
Thanks for addressing my note.
But I thought your post on Aaron Harris was ill-informed and unfair.
There are plenty of reasons to find fault with the MSM and your blog serves a valuable purpose in challenging its approach sometimes.
But please excuse some of us for reacting angrily when you paint the entire fourth estate with one brush, and malign a whole institution under imagined or erroneous pretenses, which is what I believe you have done in this case.

Because this goes to a broader issue, and because I believe I can speak for at least some of my readers – I’ve decided to reply here instead of continuing the comments thread.
I’ll plead guilty to generalizing about the “mainstream media” insofar that I assume most readers know (or will figure out) that I’m referring to the general inclinations of the major players in the industry and the liberal “default setting” through which most of our news is filtered.
The generalization is mostly a result of the brevity required of blogging and not intended as a wholesale indictment of every individual practicing journalism.
However, as he is a self-described member of that fraternity, my response to Tony about his “angry reaction” is this: you have a lot of work ahead if you hope to undo the slow-motion suicide of the news industry – and don’t bother protesting the validity of that premise. The decline in newspaper and magazine circulation, and the ratings numbers of the major networks speak for themselves..
We may agree to disagree on whether the Aaron Harris “serial crownings” at the Empire Club are worthy of a closer look and open questioning. Again, that’s the nature of blogging. Sometimes people agree, sometimes they don’t. Sometimes they don’t care. Sometimes they think it’s unfair. I would point out that this is the nature of news reporting as well.
Unlike the news industry, however, when I present a topic, the readers look at the evidence, hash it out, bring new information to the debate, and sometimes I even change my mind. (As a footnote: the Aaron Harris post was originally prompted by an ordinary reader who directed me to the CBC item privately, in the belief that the photo had been willfully defaced. That should be a signal that something might be wrong.)
But in this case, what isn’t in dispute are the growing list of examples in the “mainstream” media of manipulated news “reporting”, reporter editorializing, and altered/staged photos. These examples are contributing to a significant problem with consumer cynicism about integrity and possible political motives within the MSM. The blogosphere has enabled comparison and criticism – and with that an unsettling realization that media sleight of hand and sleight of word are hardly new practices.
If members of the industry can’t withstand open scrutiny on this lowly blog without turning to rationalizations that I’m nothing more than a would-be journalist with a chip on her shoulder – then, you haven’t gotten it yet.
I’m not a competitor. I don’t want your job. I’m a frustrated news consumer. I’m sick of being spoken down to by people who can’t pronounce words correctly. I’m fed up with reading transcripts that reveal that reporters have quoted people out of context to support a pre-ordained script. I’m tired of having speeches and statements “explained” to me by pundits after I’ve listened to them.
I’m not interested in news stories created by polls commissioned to create news stories.
I’m tired of reading that wire services have stringent “ethical guidelines”, and that to suggest that a photo might be altered is well, just the realm of tin foil hat conspiracy mongering .



condi_eyes.jpg

Better to ask yourself why so many of your former customers like myself – news “junkies” – no longer accept your stories and images at face value.
Call it the “fool me once” approach to news consumerism.
You’ve lost our trust. The question is now thrown back to you, Tony – how do you propose to earn it back?


Related: “Does the country really need 370 journalists to cover 308 MPs?”

Reader Tips & Quick Links

“He dropped back, running while smoking a cigarette“.
The Genesis Code.

“The Rev. Jesse Jackson has said he plans to challenge the election outcome in court regardless of the winner…

Why? Because it just got his name in print, that’s why!
Nicola Valley Teachers’ Union – why buy votes, when you can extort them!
The law of unintended consequences.
Gerald Ford on retired generals.
Islamic Thinker’s Society (video)
Leave yours in the comments.

Heil Harper

At Dust My Broom, an especially compelling comment from Jack;

Canada is presently governed by a very scary individual, we all have to be aware of this individual. A person who shares the same birthdate as Hitler, a person who is only concerned about his desire for power. This country will be lifting their arms and saying, �Heil Harper, Heil Harper, Heil Harper!!!�”� Now that is scary.

Except, Adolf Hitler was born April 20th. Stephen Harper on April 30th.
However, he missed this.

Whites Only Medicine

Reason;

The pharmaceutical company Schering-Plough is excluding African-American patients from the Phase II trial of its new Hepatitis C (HCV) anti-viral drug. Activist groups are denouncing this exclusion as racist. For its part, Schering-Plough argues that it has valid scientific grounds for limiting the research at this stage to other racial groups. Company researchers point out that for unknown reasons, black people do not respond as well to HCV treatments as do members of other racial groups. One prominent activist, Judith Dillard, told the Newark Star-Ledger, “The bottom line is that African-Americans have been left out of this study to make the drug look good.” Which is precisely the point.
In the past, drug trials would generally include members from diverse racial and ethnic groups. If the drug being tested was effective in all groups, then that was great; the company testing it had a potential blockbuster. If, however, some groups in the trial did not respond well to a treatment, then it would appear to be ineffective compared to placebo, and it would not be approved. Eventually researchers began to notice that not all groups respond the same way to the same medicines.

Researchers worry however, that the introduction of race-specific drug therapies may cause side effects in other groups, including the poorly-understood phenomenon known as “spontanious head explosion”.

So is the Schering-Plough HCV anti-viral study “racist”? Not really. The researchers have identified a patient subpopulation that they believe is more likely to benefit from the new treatment. If Schering-Plough can demonstrate that the medicine does work for whites, then the company can get it approved for sale by the FDA for that patient population. Admittedly race is a crude biomarker, but it would surely be bowing to political correctness about race to deny patients the benefit of treatments that are more likely to help them.

Of course. But that won’t stop some from trying.
Related.

70,000 Unsolved Murders

apv_11-791061.jpg
Darcey, at DMB;

The Canadian coverage of the issue as seen on CTV and CBC is almost apologetic and provide more focus on the pro-Chavez demonstrators. Its no wonder we have so many Chavez sympathizers in this country.

Reader Stephen Bloom wrote me a while ago with these observations;

I am appalled by the coverage of the subj. by Cdn media. [of the kidnapped and murdered Faddoul brothers -ed ]. A few reports when they were abducted and then virtually nothing until their tragic demise. Contrast that with the media’s obsession with the ‘Christian Peace Makers.’
I rule out the possibility that the children were ignored because of their hyphenated nationality (consider the Cdn/NZ ‘nationality-of-convenience’ of one of the CPM). It occurs to me that they have been ignored because of the bad light that might be cast upon the ‘socialist paradise’ of Venezuela with its rampant corruption under the lefts favourite Bush-baiter. What do you think?

I think he’s figured it out.
There’s a photo essay up at Venezuela News And Views.

All The News That’s Fit To Omit

The cool thing about the net is that it’s no longer necessary to subscribe to five different papers to find out how the news is presented differently from city to city;

Wow, we said. The Canadian military says the Liberals were foisting equipment “considered lemons or irrelevant” on them. They want to scrap “questionable” Liberal projects and replace them with equipment the military “needs.” Why wasn’t this on Page One?
Or was it?
Maybe it had been covered properly in other cities, we thought. We went looking. And we discovered, instead, a textbook case of story spinning.
It seems, as far as we could find, that this story was printed in four newspapers–The Winnipeg Sun, the Ottawa Sun, the Toronto Sun and the Edmonton Sun. And it was rewritten depending on where it appeared.
To begin with, the headlines were better in Edmonton and Ottawa.
Tories and military are in tune (Edmonton Sun)
Liberal promises put on ice (Ottawa Sun)
Forces may ice ships (Toronto Sun)
The leads varied from paper to paper:
OTTAWA — The military is set to scrap major equipment purchases announced by the former Liberal government. (Ottawa Sun)
OTTAWA — The Canadian Forces is reviewing its shopping list to find extra funds to pay for expensive Tory priorities. (Toronto Sun)
OTTAWA — The military is set to scrap major equipment purchases announced by the Liberals that are considered by brass to be lemons or irrelevant. (Edmonton Sun, Winnipeg Sun)

That’s only scratching the surface, as it turns out.

Navigation