Michael Rubin thinks it’s time for a “passive voice watch”;
A writer with whom I spoke about two weeks ago pointed out a very interesting trend in the press reporting and political commentary about the war on terrorism. All too often, reporters and politicians use the passive voice. Take British Foreign Secretary Margaret Beckett in yesterday’s USA Today: “”It’s widely argued now that the existence of the camp is as much a radicalizing and discrediting influence as it is a safeguard for security.” Well, who argues? A McClatchy story yesterday read, “Nearly 2,700 Iraqi civilians were killed in the city in September.” Well, who killed them? Baathist insurgents or Iranian-backed militias? If the public read that Iranian-backed militias killed nearly 2700 civilians, we might be less willing to reward their murderers. From today’s New York Times: “Most of the 500 municipal workers who have been killed here since 2005 have been trash collectors.” Again, someone did the killing. Why hide it? It’s important to know what we are up against. I’d submit two conclusions: Journalists do not use the active voice because they do not know the subject of the action—in which case their editors should send them back to ask tough questions—or the editors wish to absolve the subjects for political reasons. Either way, it’s poor journalism and irresponsible punditry.
Also at the Corner, military historian Victor Davis Hanson notes another curious development in journalism;
Another journalistic trait besides the rise of the passive voice to deflect culpability is the new virtual footnote that references nothing. You flip to the back in the endnotes section, only to see cited, “Senior official” or “Unnamed Pentagon planner.” These pseudo-footnotes are increasingly popular in the post-Jason Blair era, as if they can give a veneer of credibility to use of the old sensational, unnamed (and sometimes dubious) source.
It may be that these tactics are just a defensive response to the rising corrective power of the blogosphere – one can’t fact-check a journalist who is careful not to provide any.
The passive voice is a close cousin to the highly selective “Canadians/Americans believe” reporting, so-called “man on the street” interviews, and News Created By Polls Created To Create News.
For example, you’ll have no difficulty finding articles written over the past two years in which “ordinary Canadians” are quoted about their beliefs that “Conservatives are scary”, that “women don’t trust” Stephen Harper, or that George W. Bush “lied” about Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction, as though that person’s opinion is representative of a significant number of citizens – which it may well be.
However, try to find similar emotion-based reports quoting Canadian voters who hate Jean Chretien with all the fury of the most ardent Bush basher, or bi-monthly polling measuring how many “still believe the Liberal Party has flirted with organized crime” and you’ll search long and hard.
Canadians who are fearful of where the Liberals would take the country exist in significant numbers, but those views aren’t worthy of exploration or measurement, because they don’t fit the liberal-left default setting of the majority in media. Why should anyone “fear” the left?
Emotional reaction to the right is quite another matter, however – in the eyes of most in media, those fears are legitimate – thus, newsworthy. So, they work to reinforce and validate the emotional memes they have arbitrarily chosen to be politically relevant, returning to the streets every few weeks to ask “Do you still find Stephen Harper “scary” now that soldiers are dying in Afghanistan”? Just in case we’ve forgotten.








