Fact-Free Reporting

Michael Rubin thinks it’s time for a “passive voice watch”;

A writer with whom I spoke about two weeks ago pointed out a very interesting trend in the press reporting and political commentary about the war on terrorism. All too often, reporters and politicians use the passive voice. Take British Foreign Secretary Margaret Beckett in yesterday’s USA Today: “”It’s widely argued now that the existence of the camp is as much a radicalizing and discrediting influence as it is a safeguard for security.” Well, who argues? A McClatchy story yesterday read, “Nearly 2,700 Iraqi civilians were killed in the city in September.” Well, who killed them? Baathist insurgents or Iranian-backed militias? If the public read that Iranian-backed militias killed nearly 2700 civilians, we might be less willing to reward their murderers. From today’s New York Times: “Most of the 500 municipal workers who have been killed here since 2005 have been trash collectors.” Again, someone did the killing. Why hide it? It’s important to know what we are up against. I’d submit two conclusions: Journalists do not use the active voice because they do not know the subject of the action—in which case their editors should send them back to ask tough questions—or the editors wish to absolve the subjects for political reasons. Either way, it’s poor journalism and irresponsible punditry.

Also at the Corner, military historian Victor Davis Hanson notes another curious development in journalism;

Another journalistic trait besides the rise of the passive voice to deflect culpability is the new virtual footnote that references nothing. You flip to the back in the endnotes section, only to see cited, “Senior official” or “Unnamed Pentagon planner.” These pseudo-footnotes are increasingly popular in the post-Jason Blair era, as if they can give a veneer of credibility to use of the old sensational, unnamed (and sometimes dubious) source.

It may be that these tactics are just a defensive response to the rising corrective power of the blogosphere – one can’t fact-check a journalist who is careful not to provide any.
The passive voice is a close cousin to the highly selective “Canadians/Americans believe” reporting, so-called “man on the street” interviews, and News Created By Polls Created To Create News.
For example, you’ll have no difficulty finding articles written over the past two years in which “ordinary Canadians” are quoted about their beliefs that “Conservatives are scary”, that “women don’t trust” Stephen Harper, or that George W. Bush “lied” about Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction, as though that person’s opinion is representative of a significant number of citizens – which it may well be.
However, try to find similar emotion-based reports quoting Canadian voters who hate Jean Chretien with all the fury of the most ardent Bush basher, or bi-monthly polling measuring how many “still believe the Liberal Party has flirted with organized crime” and you’ll search long and hard.
Canadians who are fearful of where the Liberals would take the country exist in significant numbers, but those views aren’t worthy of exploration or measurement, because they don’t fit the liberal-left default setting of the majority in media. Why should anyone “fear” the left?
Emotional reaction to the right is quite another matter, however – in the eyes of most in media, those fears are legitimate – thus, newsworthy. So, they work to reinforce and validate the emotional memes they have arbitrarily chosen to be politically relevant, returning to the streets every few weeks to ask “Do you still find Stephen Harper “scary” now that soldiers are dying in Afghanistan”? Just in case we’ve forgotten.

Stop Calling Them Violent, And You Won’t Get Hurt

Hamid Rizvi (Toronto), in the National Post;

What French philosophy professor Robert Redeker has to realize is that Muslims in the world are not against him because he is practising freedom of speech. Islam values the rights of every person and their right to express their opinion. Expressing their opinion is different, however, from openly denouncing or insulting the beliefs and religion of someone else. When Muslims in the world retaliate against such opinions — or the Danish cartoons — they are not trying to eliminate freedom of speech. Instead, we are trying to eliminate the unnecessary hatred against us that is based on completely false facts and analysis.
The fact that someone could call the Koran a “book of inherent violence” tells us how ignorant and uninformed that person is about our religion.
Secondly, what I found interesting was Prof. Redeker’s comment, “We must distinguish between Islamists and those responsible Muslims out there who should without a doubt support me.” I find it hard to understand what he is looking for. Does he want moderate Muslims to support him when he is insulting the basis of our religion without putting in the time and effort to understand it completely? Even though he will not face a violent backlash from moderate Muslims, Prof. Redeker will not gain any kind of support or encouragement either.
Muslim “reactions” and “retaliations” against supposed “free speech” are not coming out of thin air. In fact, authors such as Prof. Redeker are adding fuel to the fire and expecting it to extinguish itself. There is a simple solution to these “violent” retaliations. Let’s keep practising free speech, but eliminate the ignorant insulting of Muslim beliefs. The retaliations will stop. It is pretty hard to clap with just one hand.

Making Sense Of The Senseless

A Popular Mechanics article, by pilot Jeff Wise, on the possible cause of the Cory Lidle crash in Manhattan.

For pilots taking off from Teterboro, a general aviation airport in New Jersey, 12 miles north of midtown Manhattan, the typical procedure is to head east under the control of Teterboro tower and then switch frequency to a radio channel that’s monitored by everyone going up and down the Hudson. At the Alpine Tower, a radio mast on a New Jersey cliff overlooking the Hudson, you turn right and descend to 1,000 feet and then follow the west bank. It’s like driving down a highway: southbound traffic on the west (New Jersey) side of the river; northbound on the east (Manhattan) side. The view of the city is incredible: You’re lower than the tops of the highest buildings, and as you pass over the George Washington Bridge linking northern Manhattan and New Jersey, it almost feels like the top of the span might snag your undercarriage.
Essentially, you’re flying in what amounts to an invisible tunnel carved out of the heavy-duty Class B airspace that surrounds the region’s three airports: Newark airport, 16 miles southwest of midtown Manhattan; LaGuardia airport, 10 miles east; and JFK airport, 18 miles southeast. Class B is for the big boys—airliners flying heavy loads of passengers at high speeds. Class B is the Carnegie Hall of aviation, the Yankee Stadium. The thought of wandering into it by mistake gives most recreational pilots palpitations.

h/t

Citius, Altius, Crybabius

Cue theme music for Chariots Of Fire…

The 2012 London Olympics have been plunged into controversy by the discovery that the Games will clash with Ramadan, the most holy month in the Islamic calendar.
The clash will put Muslim athletes at a disadvantage as they will be expected to fast from sunrise to sunset for the entire duration of the Games.
[…]
Massoud Shadjareh, chairman of the London-based Islamic Human Rights Commission, said: “They would not have organised this at Christmas. It is equally stupid to organise it at Ramadan.
“It shows a complete lack of awareness and sensitivity.

Somebody needs to inform Mr. Shadjareh that it’s not called “Christmas” in our sensitive and aware secular Western society. Speaking of which – Muslims might consider coming up with a new secular word for that Ramadan thing before somebody gets offended.

Reader Tips

A few quick links for now – snow is on the way, and I’ve a lot of winterizing to get done around here today.
New generation recruitment ads – vote for your favourite.
BBC’s language guidelines for coverage of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

FENCE
See Barrier.

Another chapter in the CBC’s never ending quest to scratch and claw their way to the bottom.
Gerry Nicholls on Election day freedom
Use the comments for your own finds, and related commentary.

The “Make It Yourself World” Of Michael Ignatieff

From the comments;

I’m an academic; I know that it is, except within the sciences, a self-organized, self-created reality. It is entirely and completely fictional. There are no consequences to what you think and say. It is an entirely rhetorical world; you can write, say, read, talk – anything. And there are no real world, hard time, practical, material reality consequences.
That was obvious in the TVO interview. The fact that Ignatieff’s three statements about Israel and War Crimes were all contradictory to each other puzzled Steve Paikin who kept trying to get Ignatieff to, as we do in the Real World, select ONE. Ignatieff held to all three statements. You can do that in the academic world of semantics, the world of fiction, of postmodern relativism, where statements just ‘hang in the air’ but don’t have to operate in concrete, material reality. Therefore opinions don’t have to be consistent.
The fictional academic world can say three different perspectives, the fact that they are contradictory is irrelevant, for you can verbally, semantically, link them in an emotional surge.
Ignatieff uses this emotional underpinning to ooperate as the ‘cohesion’ in his opinions. Rather than logic, rather than hard core reality, he uses emotion to tie togther concepts which do NOT relate to each other.
So, he can define Quebec as a nation and use the emotional threat of ‘civil war’ to justify it. He can bring in trivia such that Quebecers are upset because their health cards aren’t recognized elsewhere as a justification for their being ‘upset’ and wanting a nation. ?? The fact that this would open up the country to a set of at least five distinct nations (Alberta, Ontario, north etc)..he hasn’t a clue, because he’s not emotional about them.
His rubbish about ‘absence makes the heart grow fonder’ is another tactic of emotion. He’s not running on practical agendas of fixing things, as is Harper. He’s running on pure emotion. That’s been the Liberal strategy for years.
Remember Chretien and his emotional plea for ‘da little guy from Shawinigan’? A lie of course.
Chretien and his emotional plea for ‘sponsorship funding’? Yet another lie; it was money laundering to retain Chretien in power.
Ignatieff is the same. No practical ideas, as we are getting from Harper. Instead, it’s all rhetoric and emotion. The rhetoric is filled with contradictory opinions, which is the norm in the academic world, for there are no consequences to verbal spouting of your opinions in the academic world. The emotion is a tactic to woo the plebeian and ignorant voter – a stance basic to the Liberals, who view the voter as ‘beer and popcorn’ types who must be appealed to via their emotions.
As I said, I like Ignatieff’s books, but, it isn’t that he isn’t a politician. It is that he cannot exist outside of the fictional make-it-yourself world of academia. He can’t exist in the real world where you can’t operate with contradictions, where you can’t operate with a perspective that is a generation out of date. Ignatieff should go back to the safe rooms of academia.

Emphasis mine.
More from Toronto Sun columnist Michael Coren (who’s been reading blogs).

WaPo Goes Skin Deep

Byron York defends the Washington Post;

Today’s front-page article, “Democratic Faces That Could Launch Thousands of Votes; With a Parade of Attractive Candidates, the Party May Benefit From the Politics of Beauty,” which includes the passage

By a combination of luck and design, Democrats seem to be fielding an uncommonly high number of uncommonly good-looking candidates. The beauty gap between the parties, some on Capitol Hill muse, could even be a factor in who controls Congress after Election Day.

is a work of straight-down-the-middle journalism, and no one should suggest otherwise.

“Loyalty, Loyalty, Loyalty”

A story from the May 2006 issue of Macleans that was sent along by reader;

It should have been a moment of pride for the Canadian army. Five of its most talented snipers — men trained to kill without remorse, then turn around and kill again — did exactly that. They destroyed al-Qaeda firing positions, saved American lives and tallied a body count unmatched by any Canadian soldier of their generation. U.S. commanders who served alongside the snipers nominated all five for the coveted Bronze Star medal. “Thank God the Canadians were there,” is how one American soldier put it.
Yet days later, their heroics on the mountain would be overshadowed by suspicion, including stunning allegations that one sniper, in a subsequent mission, sliced himself a souvenir from the battlefield: the finger of a dead Taliban fighter. Military police launched a criminal investigation, but uncovered nothing but denials. As the months wore on, there emerged so many conflicting accusations and supposed explanations that no charges were ever laid. Even Rob Furlong’s record-breaking shot became lost in the confusion. In fact, until now, a different sniper has been widely — and incorrectly — credited with pulling the trigger on that long-distance kill.
Today, more than four years later, three of the five decorated snipers who served in Afghanistan are no longer in the army, brushed aside by a military machine that seemed all too willing to watch them go. Persecuted instead of praised, they fell victim to what many still believe was a witch hunt driven by jealousy and political correctness.
[…]
Pat Ragsdale, Graham’s father, wanted some answers. After the tour, he watched his son suffer through an unthinkable depression, and he wanted to know why. For months, he wrote letter after letter to government officials, from the Prime Minister to high-ranking generals. “I wasn’t happy with the treatment they got in Afghanistan or the treatment they got subsequent to Afghanistan,” he told one reporter.
In September 2004, Pat Ragsdale finally received a response. Gen. Ray Henault, then the chief of the defence staff, personally asked the ombudsman to launch his own investigation. Unlike the NIS version, this one would focus not on fingers and signs, but on whether the military mistreated its snipers. In other words, did these men — lauded as heroes by the Americans but treated as criminals in Canada — deserve better?

The ombudsman’s report is supposed to be in the hands of defense minister Gordon O’Connor by now, but I can find nothing to indicate that it’s been released to the public.
Update – Damian Brooks has a response about the release of the report from the Ombudsman for the Department of National Defence and Canadian Forces.

Nowhere To Be Seen

Medienkritik on the selectively angry left;

Putin is visiting Germany. He is visiting Dresden, the city where he served as a KGB agent with the express purpose of keeping an oppressive dictatorship up and running. He is visiting shortly after the brutal murder of yet another independent journalist who dared to question his regime. He is visiting in the midst of a protracted, bloody military campaign in Chechnya, in which tens of thousands have died or simply “disappeared.”
And where are the throngs of angry protesters??? The media reports that Mr. Putin was confronted by a heckler or two and a few “uncomfortable” questions from journalists and politicians. Where are the masses of drum-thumping, flag-waving, dreadlock wearing, morally superior protesters who gathered by the thousands when Bush was in country?

Fair Political Dialogue

“Stephen Harper said most Liberal leadership candidates were ‘anti-Israel.’ What do you think of this?”

Vote on the main page at CTV.ca.
As one commentor remarked a few days ago, let’s see another online media poll go “horribly horribly wrong”!
Related: “The wife of prominent Liberal MP Irwin Cotler has quit the party in a fury over leadership front-runner Michael Ignatieff’s assertion that Israel committed war crimes.

(link fixed)
Steve Janke has more.
UPDATE – it’s getting lonely on the Ignatieff campaign bus.

Friday, October 13, 2006
My Resignation
As President of the Thornhill Young Liberals and as a delegate from the riding of Thornhill, I stand by Susan Kadis MP in her decision to resign as GTA Co-Chair of the Michael Ignatieff Campaign. I do believe Michael to be a strong leader but unfortunately at this time, I cannot reconcile his recent statements characterizing Israel’s action in response to the kidnapping of its soldiers as a “war crime”. As a matter of conscience, I, like Susan, am resigning as Director of Strategy and Operations for Ontario.
posted by Michelle Oliel @ 12:46 PM

h/t Jeff Drebit, in the comments.
Oct.14 morning update
pollresult.jpg

United Nations Save The Children From Parents Fund

Mark Peters confesses;

Now, unfortunately it appears that our son is a victim of domestic violence at the hand of both his mother and me. This evening we will have to turn ourselves in at the nearest RCMP station and make our children wards of the state lest we commit any more violence against their fragile bodies and minds. After all, the 21st century world government has determined that parenting is illegal.

Tripmeter

I’ve been home just over 24 hours now, and the road fog is finally starting to lift.
To review – the show circuit began on September 21st with shows in Bozeman and Helena, Montana. I finished Sunday just after noon and headed for La Crosse, WI.
Note to hunters – approximately 4 million mule deer gather after dark along the shoulderless edges of Hwy 212 between Lame Deer and Belle Fourche. Perhaps they enjoy the sound of screeching tires, perhaps they’re just trying to catch a glimpse of their splendid racks in the mirrors of passing cars – whatever the case, shooting them should require all the effort of rolling down a window. Please consider doing so.
I arrived in LaCrosse Monday night, where I picked up my friend and co-driver Mary, (along with two more dogs for a total of 8) to continue on to the Monroe, Michigan shows. After showing finished Sunday, we hit the road again for a 10 hour trek to some place in Maryland northwest of Baltimore, where we stayed with friends. After a two day “break” grooming dogs and doing laundry, it was on to Philadelphia, where the four days of shows that are the “high point” of the trip are held in three inconvenient, outdoor locations in the countryside north of the Pennsylvania Turnpike.
We employ the usual techniques to help the miles go by. The most effective, of course, is trashing your dog show enemies. There’s also Rush and Sean Hannity, swilling Mountain Dew, arguing over what constitutes a good road tune (I became hooked on Dire Straits this trip, much to Mary’s dismay) and when things get really boring – teasing the dog in the top crate.
teasing_biscuit.jpg
Montgomery County Kennel Club is the world’s most important show for terriers – winning Best In Show at “Montgomery” is arguably more important for us than winning the more heavily publicized Westminster. It’s also often one of the coldest and wettest – though the showers and wind we endured this year paled in comparison to the nearly 10 inches of rain that fell in 2005 that washed out one of the show sites.
The dogs did well. Everyone in the van placed in the ribbons each day, with dogs of our breeding in the top awards every show save one.
We were packed and on the road by 6 pm, arriving back in LaCrosse Monday evening. A 4:30 am morning ensured I crossed the border into Saskatchewan before the Port of Northgate closed. I overnighted at the family farm, then it was just other 5 hour hop to Delisle with nothing left to do but housecleaning, unpacking the van and getting up to date on three weeks of mail, bills and the work waiting for me.
All of that is to help explain why blogging will be slow for a day or two. My energy levels are pretty low.
I didn’t take a lot of photos along the way this year – the interstates aren’t known for their scenic qualities. But I did stick the camera out of the window near Bowbells, ND. on the way home. Those who live on the northern plains will recognize the indigo blue clouds that blow in with the first cold front – I call them “winter clouds”. They signal the end of autumn, and are particularly beautiful when contrasted against the clear turquoise sky and golden stubble fields.

winterclouds3.jpg

winterclouds2.jpg
(Click the images for a larger version)
Here’s another that better illustrates what I mean, though this was taken near Regina a few years ago.

One photo didn’t turn out – it’s the one of the tripmeter on the van that reads 9,397.3 km. That’s 5,828.03 miles for our non-metric friends.
I’m glad I have a week to rest up before I head back.
Someone asked about more dog pics – this one was sent along by a friend. A ring shot of my puppy, “Diesel” – Am.Can.Ch.Minuteman Locomotion, who was First Award of Merit at Hatboro KC.
dieselmove.jpg

Leopards To Afghanistan

Thanks to the 817th Expeditionary Airlift Squadron;

The C-17 Globemaster III “Spirit of McChord” and its crew made two trips to Kandahar AB, Afghanistan, in one day to transport the equipment for Canadian ground forces supporting the NATO mission.
Col. Michael McLean, Canadian Defense Attaché, said the Leopard tanks will support Canadian troops by providing greater mobility on the ground and more flexible options.
“The enhancements will enable troops to counter threats more effectively and safely,” said Colonel McLean. “The sooner we can provide the security and stability, the sooner we can help the Afghan people develop a positive and independent future for themselves and their children.”
The 817th EAS, deployed from McChord Air Force Base, Wash., supports the mission of the 376th Air Expeditionary Wing, NATO forces, and operations Enduring Freedom and Iraqi Freedom.
“It filled me with pride watching a (Canadian) tank being loaded onto a McChord C-17,” said Senior Airman Bryan Mumma, 376th Expeditionary Aircraft Maintenance Squadron crew chief, also deployed from McChord AFB. “We work hard to keep our aircraft operational as the supplies we deliver downrange are crucial to our troops and in this case, to the Canadian ground forces.”
[…]
“It has been an awesome deployment for us,” said Maj. James Hall, 817 EAS Det. 1 commander. “We have had the opportunity to haul stuff for just about every member of the International Security Assistance Forces. The Dutch, Romanians and now the Canadians have had major moves since we have been deployed. It is a great experience working with the militaries from all over the world, especially when it is carrying something as cool as tanks for our great neighbors from up North.”

We’re Not The Worst!

The Fraser Institute released a study yesterday comparing market performance of auto insurance in jurisdictions across North America and in Great Britain.

Data were collected on 15 variables describing the regulatory policy environments and outcomes in each jurisdiction using comparable measurement units. From these 15 variables, five indices were constructed that comparatively measure market quality and regulatory severity across international jurisdictions. Two indices measure market quality outcomes from the perspective of consumers regarding cost and choice; one index gauges market quality outcomes from the perspective of insurers regarding the business climate for auto insurance; a fourth index measures the regulatory severity of auto insurance policy in each market; and the fifth index measures overall market quality combining the scores for each jurisdiction across all 15 variables. This study also examines statistical correlations between variables that can be conceptually separated into distinctly dependent and independent categories.
insurance.jpg

PDF
(Note – some commentors are having problems getting through the spam filter. The word “insurance” is the problem. Try spelling it in abbreviation, and I suspect the problem will alleviate.)

Navigation