I Smell A Human Rights Complaint Coming On

Dr. Elmasry, call your office….

Michelle Malkin;

The person who posted it claims: “I don’t know what happened here. But this happened on my Air Canada plane ride to London, England in December 6th, 2007 from Toronto…My partner and I decided we should videotape this in the interest of sharing the experience we went through on this plane with those interested.”

(Emphasis mine.)

89 Replies to “I Smell A Human Rights Complaint Coming On”

  1. I’m sorry and apologize for my statements above if this guy is mentally ill — as I expect upon further examination…

  2. I experienced something similar on a non-stop flight from Beijing to Toronto in August 2007. The man sitting next to me across the aisle (very drunk) took offense with me when he asked if I was a Canadian citizen. I replied “Yes, 2nd generation in fact”. The entire rest of the flight he proceeded to taunt me, 2 inches from my face – then started kicking me and grabbing my arms. AC personnel intervened, advising me I could have the Captain arrest the man. I declined. The man was a Sikh, and I feared his community would firebomb my house. China seemed so civilized in comparison! Welcome home!

  3. Sorry BL@KBIRD and Boss429, only I, the great Infidel, am qualified to denigrate these individuals.

  4. You don’t have to catch a flight to Britain to get this- just catch a TTC bus, (the ‘better way’), to work- in Toronto.
    Does the TTC care?- nope! (Were it not for the offensive third-world dogmeat, (turning civilized people off public transpo)- they would not be able to meet the demand!
    (Welcome to ‘multi-culti).

  5. I think it’s a stretch to suggest he’s some sort of religious nutjob terrorist-wannabe…the man clearly has mental health issues, and it looks as if the people sitting next to him may be escorts. They can clearly be heard saying ‘you’re going to your mother’ so they must know something. As for shouts of f*****g white people, allahu akbar etc. etc., allow me to point out his agitated state (in case no one noticed)? A white Christian having a panic attack would yell out ‘Jesus help me’ or the like, and any slurs he throws around could just easily be contributed to his apparent mental health issues. We should have pity on a man like this, not attack him.

  6. I’d have jumped on him off the top rope,applied a step over toe hold and finished him off with a boston crab.

  7. These are exactly the idiotic comments that make immigrants fear the conservative party.
    Posted by: Aaron at December 14, 2007 1:35 PM
    say wot!!!!!!!!!
    this immigrant would never vote LIEberal

  8. I’d have all the pity in the world for him… after I got off the plane. While I’m ON the plane I want this guy face down on the floor, hog tied and a big friggin’ chunk of duct tape over his pie hole. In the galley, if possible. Don’t want him hurt, just out of action.
    Any of you bleeding hearts (Aaron, Aunty Em et al) have any appreciation for how astoundingly stressful this was for the other passengers? Ever think there might be kids on this plane? Kids don’t need to see that.

  9. You are right Phantom, I almost added as much to my post.
    Not sure I could be very compassionate if I were sitting next to the guy, but I suspect that the “shirts” with him were there for a reason. Looking at the tape, it seemed to me that they knew him and were aware of his disability(?).
    I don’t think they would have been so gentle if it had been a case of somebody that presented a real danger to other passengers.

  10. Cal…sorry,I guess I am just a sensitive trolley dolly,fact is,I don’t even like the company I work for,but love the job,once again,please accept my humble apology.

  11. I may be wrong, but I assume that when Kate says, “I smell a human rights complaint coming on” she was suggesting that the CIC might take offence, resulting in a HRC complaint against the filmaker, and Air Canada. After all, a man who looks like an Indian or Pakistani and who yells “Allahu Akhbar!!”could be a Muslim. And this video shows him in a bad light. Whatever the reason for his behaviour, the simple fact that the video is being shown on “YouTube” could be contorted as yet another “racist” insult to Islam. And, in the reasoning of the CIC and the HRC, just the possibility that this could be perceived by some Muslims as discrimination on the basis of religion, is grounds enough for a complaint.
    While most commenting on the video have taken the tack that the man must have been having a panic attack or some other such mental breakdown, I was rather dismayed at the few who jumped to the type of conclusions that just feed fuel to the fire. If just one white person, through his/her comments wishes to justify Elmasry, then these less than savoury comments are the way to go. If, on the other hand, we wish to disabuse Muslims of the notion that any real and justifiable problems we have with some of them (terrorism, honour killings, misogyny) are just “religious bigotry” then I suggest a personal policy of “engage thy brain before opening thy mouth!”

  12. Judging by the comments and demeanor of the 2 guys restraining the nutter,this sure looks to me like a standard,commercial flight,escorted deportation operation.
    He probably was a low priority,non-violent, voluntary removal,which is why he wasn’t in handcuffs,but of course when he went berserkers they had to slap on the white flex-cuffs you can see dangling from his wrists in the video.

  13. I would like to see the 9 Justices of the SCOC, and numerous Human Rights Tribunal adjudicators on this flight and ask them in the heat of the moment about the rights and freedoms of this passenger and the way he is acting. His mental illness or no mental illness involved, does he have the right to terrorize the flight. Does the well being of the rest of the passengers fit in to the equation anywhere. The answers would be interesting indeed.
    mid island mike

  14. Wow Kate, you are a sad sad woman. You deserve no better than to be told how pathetic you are. With a personality that is as repulsive as dung and as abrasive as 40 grit sandpaper it should come as no surprise you are single at your age, but then again, that’s probably why you’re as angry as you are at the world.
    You spare no expense in vilifying the Canadian Islamic community and Islam as a whole. Insinuating that this man is likely to file a human rights complaint because of his faith is nothing but racist. Kate McMillan, you are a biggot and nothing more, a lowly piece of white angry trash who’s contribution to Canadian society amounts to nill.

  15. Jen
    If you looked into Islam yourself, you would not make such a pathetic mess on the floor with a very credible offering of your incredible ignorance of Islam. Learn before you let your lips dribble drivel.

  16. “it should come as no surprise you are single at your age, but then again, that’s probably why you’re as angry as you are at the world.
    You spare no expense in vilifying the Canadian Islamic community and Islam as a whole. Insinuating that this man is likely to file a human rights complaint because of his faith is nothing but racist.”
    Yeah Kate what she said, who cares if muslim leaders are trying to stifle free speech! Who cares if a Canadian muslim leader once said that every Israeli over 18 is a legitimate target for terrorist attacks! What’s wrong with that?!
    /sarc off
    For the record I once met a perfectly horrible woman who was married. I also have a really nice relative who is single. Personal attacks like that from someone anonymous against someone public are pretty tacky. For all we know Jen, you are a fat ugly creepy guy in a loveless marriage. I guess though, since you are a lefty you can say anything you like and be morally superior about it.

  17. Hey Jen ,Duct tape too spare,please read what you rite,,Can you actually say insinuate and likeley,into someting racist.Oh I see ya don’t like whites neither ,isn’t that a tad racist,So sorry Kate “Why don’t you F##k off into the twilite

  18. Good point soup…
    Can I have the attention of all the apologist leftists/socialists viewing these words for a moment…..Islam/Muslims are not a “RACE”. You sound like the intellectually lazy tards you are when you open your blovation with this. Can I see a show of hands among the tards that understand now?

  19. JBS
    “we wish to disabuse Muslims”: I think you have things in the wrong order.
    Cheers

  20. Jen might at least have made sure that his/her ad hominem insults were spelled correctly!
    This person wrote that Kate is a “. . . a biggot [bigot] and nothing more, a lowly piece of white angry trash who’s [whose] contribution to Canadian society amounts to nill [nil].”
    Smarten up, Jen.
    For my part, I find Kate highly intelligent, honest, and insightful (attractive too!): a woman of resolve and get-up-and-go, who’s providing a vital service to the citizens of this benighted country. (For Jen: “who’s” in the previous sentence stands for “who is”. It’s a contraction. “Who’s” can also stand for “who has”.)
    Although our lefty Canadian elites, especially those in the media, pay lip service to tolerance and diversity, they honour no such thing. Kate has provided a very welcome forum, where issues, such as Islam’s negative impact on our society, which are stifled, spun, and/or censored by the MSM, can now see the light of day.
    Bit by bit, blogs like Kate’s are giving ALL Canadians a chance to have their voices heard. For a person who apparently approves of diversity and tolerance, I’d have thought someone like Jen would be pleased to see such attributes in action.
    Psst, Jen, “tolerance and diversity” does not mean just making nice: by definition, it must embrace dissent as well. Our education system and MSM have brainwashed generations of kids with the “make nice” model: dishonest and counter productive—destructive, even—to the nth degree. In fact, Jen seems to be a perfect example of the totalitarian, brainwashed tendencies the elites hope to instil in the unwary. What small minded hypocrites—all of them. Thank God Kate provides some relief!

  21. “Wow Kate, you are a sad sad woman…”
    Actually, Jen, it’s you who are truly sad. Misinformed. Ignorant. Self-righteous.
    And tapdancing into dhimmitude.
    Islam is the religion taking offense at Miss Piggy coffee mugs. And cartoons. And ice cream maker logos swirled into shapes that “look like Allah”. And declare war on and blow up 3000 year-old statues that bear human likeness. And believes that gang-raped women deserve 200 lashes. And a woman should be jailed, lashed or put to death for allowing a teddy bear to be named “mohammed”. Or that saudi girls in a private school should perish in a fire because they aren’t permitted to leave the burning building without wearing their veils. That adulterers and homosexuals should be stoned. Or that a 16-year old girl should be strangled by her father for not wearing islamic dress.
    Or other atrocities committed in the name of “allah”, here.
    These are the facts, idiot. All of your ad homs and insulting conservatives change nothing: islam is the problem, not the west’s increasing awareness of it.
    In the 1980’s the west was fearful of WWIII, to be fought between the US & the Russians. As it turns out, this was not a concern because neither side believed “winning” that war was worth the cost of victory (that & Reagan’s pushing the Soviets into total bankruptcy).
    However, WWIII can be thought of as a more insidious, elusive war: it is a war of western culture against islam, which is spreading across the globe like a cancer, leaving agony and bodies in its wake. The MSM and liberals alike are working assiduously to ensure we lose this war; incidents depicting islam in a negative light are either glossed over entirely or whitewashed (ref. Aqsa Parvez’ recent murder).
    To win a war of culture, first you must actually want to win; islam has the will to win, but it’s not appearing we do. It’s not bigotry to proclaim western culture superior to that of the islamic world: just follow the immigration. That’s why you have hundreds of thousands from the middle east uprooting to the west, and nobody on the return flights. All PC hogwash aside, even the muslims know where the culture is inferior and where the opportunities lie.
    People like jen are helping us lose the battle, with their reflexive PC slurs of bigotry against people who honestly object to the tactics of the enemy. This war must also be won on the home front by the citizens of the west; islam understands this and exploits our own weakness (e.g. HRC complaint against Macleans Mag & Mark Steyn, & others).
    Before jen et al predictably accuse me of bigotry and racism, I will qualify I have nothing against muslims who immigrate to this country to live as Canadians and leave their religous baggage behind. This is a challenge, considering the damaging liberal doctrine of multiculturalism that provides no incentive for immigrants to assimilate. However, where are all those “moderate muslims” in decrying the atrocities committed in the name of their religion? Maybe they are in England, where 36% of muslims polled believed Britain should be ruled by shariah law, eh? Tarek Fatah notwithstanding, they seem to be missing in action here in Canada.
    It’s high time this country once again took an active interest into who they are freely admit into its boundaries, and start turfing those who don’t deserve the freedoms and opportunities it offers. Perhaps the Khadrs should be first on the next plane outbound.
    mhb23re
    at gmail d0t calm

  22. Gee, he asked for someone to “Shoot me.” I would have thought Air Canada could have at least obliged….I’m certain a few passengers would have been thankful for the peace and quiet.
    Jen, no need to shoot the messenger, and I bet you wouldn’t say those words to Kate’s face.

  23. Sounds to me like the guy was having an unhinged-moonbat moment.
    Maybe he’s the new “Islamic Rage Boy”? Ok, to see what I mean:
    http://www.snappedshot.com/archives/976-Islamic-Rage-Boy-Parody-Roundup.html
    Nah… something tells me he’s no fundamentalist Muslim. Ever seen a devout Islamist man with an earring in his left ear? I think he’s just a moonbat, and likely a “gay” one at that, although he didn’t seem to enjoy it when the guy with the beard put his arm around him…
    He’d make a great addition to the photojournalistic site exposing the most extreme fits of moonbattery, zombietime.com
    Anyway, I wouldn’t be shocked if the CAIR-Can stands up for him…

  24. Lookout,
    You beat me to it and said it far better than I ever could, but thanks for Your accurate potrayal of Kate!

  25. My intent to join in with the general condemnation of this man has been cut short.

    The very end of the showing, was of a young woman. The sadness and comiseration for the unhappy situation shown on her face, will live with me long after all else.

  26. Jen, have you been seeing clearly through that Burka? Now go off to your prayer and thank your lucky stars you have the freedom to spout off venom without cause. There are places, no doubt you’ve heard of, where dames like you would be stoned to death for having an opinion on anything.
    At this point, I would much prefer to keep KH Schreiber and deport a real waste of skin named Elmasry.

  27. mhb: It’s high time this country once again took an active interest into who they are freely admit into its boundaries
    …unfortunately it is too late my friend. It would take at least two generations to undo the mess, but that is if the generation changes. Right now the demographics don’t support it. With retiring baby boomers, or going off the map so to speak, the younger generation will have to fill the gap. Now tell me, which younger generation is willing to do service jobs like Wendy’s, Hotel clerks, or become Retirement Homecare personnel?
    We are doomed as a society unless the youth today take responsibility for their parents (white and others) mistakes.

Navigation