We Are What You Eat

Writing in the Washington Post, Professor James E. McWilliams, author of “Just Food”, recounts giving a speech in Texas on the “environmental virtues” of a vegetarian diet. It was not well-received. One man told him, during the Q&A, “what I eat is my business — it’s personal.”
McWilliams:

I’ve been writing about food and agriculture for more than a decade. Until that evening, however, I’d never actively thought about this most basic culinary question: Is eating personal?

We know more than we’ve ever known about the innards of the global food system. We understand that food can both nourish and kill. We know that its production can both destroy and enhance our environment. We know that farming touches every aspect of our lives — the air we breathe, the water we drink, and the soil we need.

So it’s hard to avoid concluding that eating cannot be personal. What I eat influences you. What you eat influences me. Our diets are deeply, intimately and necessarily political…

Watch out – he’s making a move for your fork:

We know that something has to be done to save our food from corporate interests. But I wonder — are we ready to do what must be done? Sure, we’ve been inundated with ideas: eat local, vote with your fork, buy organic, support fair trade, etc. But these proposals all lack something that every successful environmental movement has always placed at its core: genuine sacrifice.

Until we make that leap, until we create a culinary culture in which the meat-eaters must do the apologizing, the current proposals will be nothing more than gestures that turn the fork into an empty symbol rather than a real tool for environmental change.

(emph. mine)

103 Replies to “We Are What You Eat”

  1. batb your comment about health food stores is bang on! That was a good laugh for my morning.
    My wife and I occasionally visit a health food store to get something unusual (good quality wild-flower honey for example), and we always chuckle at how incredibly unhealthy everyone looks.
    This is especially true for the people that work there, who you would think would be radiating with colour.

  2. “So it’s hard to avoid concluding that eating cannot be personal. What I eat influences you. What you eat influences me. Our diets are deeply, intimately and necessarily political”
    By the same token…
    “So it’s hard to avoid concluding that INSERT WORD cannot be personal. What I INSERT WORD influences you. What you INSERT WORD influences me. Our INSERT WORDS are deeply, intimately and necessarily political”
    Nothing is personal, I guess.

  3. So, excepting bleet, we all agree this guy’s a twit, right?
    And we all agree bleet’s a twit, right?
    Okay then.
    (More annoying than vegetarians are people who sniff about that ghastly Sarah Palin, who hunts, shudder, even as they are in the act of tucking into their meaty dinners. I have seen this. At least veggies have principles, arguably silly as those principles may be.)

Navigation