As I type, Stephen Harper is in the process of introducing a non-confidence motion. Seems like a good time for an open thread on the upcoming election.
Have at ‘er, but keep it civil, keep the language under control and have fun!
As a side note, I don’t share the same level of consternation some of you have expressed over “King Ralph’s” comments featured last evening. If he was intent on damaging Stephen Harper, he pulled the trigger suspiciously early. As has happened with Joe Clark, subsequent statements will lose their novelty. One thing that his musing about the return of a Liberal minority does achieve is this – it reinforces the “underdog status” of the conservatives, while motivating the base (a lot of you were angry at him, right? That’s good. More importantly, an Alberta premier musing openly about the shaky prospects of his federal counterpart helps calm those would be Liberal voters who aren’t all that enthusiastic about trudging through the snow on behalf of the party of comfy fur. That’s even better. So keep talking, Ralph, Keep talking.
As I’ve said before – if there’s a single word that makes Liberal strategists’ blood run cold it’s this one – motivation.

Save the Liberals. Send them into the political wilderness. There, after eliminating themselves of the cronies and hacks, they can reform themselves.
The party as it is currently constituted is flawed. Graft, entitlment, hubris, etc. are all indemic to the party. The only way to reform is outside the government.
Ralph Klein is minor league compared to the awesome Howitzer power of First Mate (Number One) Scott Brison aiming his blunderbuss weapon (his mouth, strategically disconnected from his mind) at the deck of Paul Martin’s Kyoto christened Love Canal Boat Steamship Line and blowing holes in it large enough to get a Conservative Minority Government through.
Exit, pursued by a bare minority.
My thoughts exactly Kate. I thought the reactions to Ralph’s musings were a little strong, but then that is perhaps what he wanted.
If Klein gets worse… Peter’s going to be doing a media event in the potato patch about his big bud the next PM.
You’re right on the money with your Ralph analysis Kate. If most Canadians don’t want an election right now, then it follows that only the most motivated will get out to vote. Right now the anger towards PMPM is massive and intense whilst the desire to keep the CPC out of power isn’t a unifying force.
I thought that Ralph’s comments were just silly to make, but not the big deal that the media and Peter MacKay made of it.
His guess that [many] Ontarians won’t have the backbone to vote out the Libs is a definite possibility. Doesn’t mean that he’s hoping that happens.
Kind of sad that the lede on last year’s #1 conservative blog is “Have you tried Flock yet?”
What riding is Mr./Ms. Flock running in?
I should have added that Klein is also creating a perception of “distance” between himself and Harper. Again, that’s not a bad thing.
Paul Martin has ED.
Electile Dysfunction.
please refrain from using Scott Brison and Love Canal in the same sentence.
bad image , bad image.
though I am reminded of Joe Taxpayers predicament.
A Christmas election is the best the CPC could have hoped for. The motivation for change is always greater than the the inertia of the status quo.
There is a poll coming out that shows the voting preferences of those people that are actually going to get out and vote….it’s called the election. All other polls a bunk.
Like Ralph, if I had to bet on the next election I would probably have to put my money on another Liberal minority. It’s not the result I want, but realistically Harper has still not won over the Ontario electorate. I also think Ralph is doing a noble thing by engaging the Canadian public in an “honest debate” on healthcare.It’s certainly long overdue, and the public seems a little more receptive as of late. However, the timing is a bit suspect. As much as I like Ralph, this does nothing to ease my suspicions of his past life as a Liberal.
Seems to me Ralph simply stated the truth. That’s what I think will happen too.
Andre Coyne’s assessment that regardless the three oppositions will agree to make Harper PM may well be what results.
Meanwhile for a morning laugh .. visit …
Duke’s blog
What worries me is the possibility of more NDP seats.
Two words, Kate – motivation and audit. Missed the part in the House where David Anderson tried to link Conrad Black to the Tories. But Jim Travers and Don Newman were musing on how bizarre it was. Anderson was trying to say the Tories would benefit from Lord Black’s ill-gotten booty somehow. The Libs are scared and their mouths are running off, totally disengaged from their brains.
Cheri: More NDP seats is good if they are the seats they bled to the Liberals the last week of the campaign.
First objective for the CP is a strong minority with PC+NDP>153 (Assuming PC>Lib and BQ>NDP that also guarantees Lib+NDP
‘allo, Helene, Paul. … Paul Martin (maudit). The new G-G, what’s his name, again?
No, not Jean, the other one… what’s his name again? >>>>
Stage set for government defeat
Last Updated Thu, 24 Nov 2005 08:16:08 EST
CBC News
Conservative Leader Stephen Harper introduced a no-confidence motion in the House of Commons on Thursday, setting the stage for a vote that could topple the minority Liberal government and spark an election campaign that would stretch over the holiday season.>> via cnews
The Liberals are beginning to resemble Manuel in Fawlty Towers. You may recall Fawlty Towers was cancelled after only 1 season.
I think the analogy holds.
Craig Oliver has provoked the Corbemite Maneuver.
The most important election of our lifetime. Not an election actually but a trial on voters from Ontario. Will they actually vote for the liberals after adscam and learning first hand that Mr. Martin has feet of clay. A man with no principles who would do anything to hold power.
If the Liberals win again then Conservatives will know for sure that a conservative leader from the west will never be acceptable to the masses from Ontario. This is a slap in the face but better to understand the reality then to continue to live the illusion that the problem might be that Mr. Harper or Mr. Day or Mr. Manning were just not up to grade and the fix is just to find a better leader. Well at this point a toad should be better choice then the liberal leader and if you can’t beat them now – you will never be able to. Time to move on and consider other options.
Steve L from OnTARIO
Man I hate people complaining about when an election is. As Rick Mercer wryly pointed out, it takes 20 minutes to vote, plus 1 minute to get rid of each party hack that comes by to talk to you. A grand total of 24 minutes of your precious holiday wasted! Oh the horror.
I look at Iraqi’s dodging bombs to reach the polls, and then look at the complainers here, and I see a very sorry and pathetic lot.
Lets get on with it, though I fear Ontario will fall to the Libs again.
Hey, no fair! Kate gets all this credit for her analysis and I already said it this morning over at Comments Please (WK’s 50 Cent post):
“As we’ve read here and elsewhere and seen in the ads, part of the CPC strategy is to come across as the underdog regardless of whether they are up or down in the polls. This removes the arrogance and scare element that they screwed up in the last election. Plus, if Klein, a conservative, is saying Martin will win then (a) maybe some Liberals will feel a little over-confident and (b) maybe some Conservatives get even more fired up. I don’t think it is the result of collusion between Klein and Harper, but this helps Harper more than Martin.”
Dare I say great (but opposing) minds think alike? OK, OK, you are all free to jump all over me for that.
At any rate, Klein’s handling of the questions made to him are not helpful to our (i.e. Liberal) cause.
TB
Cerberus
Ontarians will then have to live with the fallout in Quebec where the Libs are seen as a threat to unity. And there’s not a lot the Libs can do to buy votes in Quebec without reminding everybody of Gomery-New and Updated Version.
I as a Ontario voter deep in Liberal land. It does look like the Liberals will win again.
Agree with Steve L. This has gotta be just about the last chance for Ontario to step up to the plate and demonstrate that they’re willing to at least try a government that has a strong base of support in the west, and that they do have enough of a sense of decency/outrage to send the Liberals to the opposition benches where they belong for a few years at least.
If not — I’d say the west should get started on firewalls and eventually independence.
Cerberus, an honest question. Do you honestly think a liberal govt. can clean up the liberal govt? I ask because I don’t think they can. Too much possibility of conflict of interest. I know for myself, as a person with conservative values if the cons were involved in this mess I would spoil my ballot and email the cons and tell them to get their act together. With the whole east west thing. If the libs win then it proves that your guys have really devided our country. That may come back to haunt them.
The sad fact is that everything in Ontario is showing that the usual cowards are just going to follow the same old line like the Liberal drones they are. It looks like it will be a repeat from the last election – start off looking hopeful and then the scare tactics start to work and people switch their vote to Liberal. Seriously, if you say you are a Conservative here, the majority of people get a look of fear in their eyes.
In the riding I worked on a campaign during the last election, the research and polling was showing that 55% of residents were going to vote CPC. On election day, we lost by 5000 votes. What changed during that period of time? Liberal scare tactic campaigning.
As an exasperated Ontario Conservative, I’m overjoyed at the possibility of trouncing Dithers & his corrupt bunch in favor of a minority Conservative government.
As I say to many of my liberal neighbours: “What is the worst that a minority Conservative government can do”?
Cue the “Hidden agenda”, “Harper is scary” schtick…
Harper has to fight dirty on this one, and not play receiver to whatever crud-filled propaganda is thrown by the Liberals. Best offense is a good defense, and all that.
And it’d be a good time to forget about SSM, at least for now; there may be a time in the future to revisit that issue. It ain’t now, however, as it plays perfectly to the liberal “hidden agenda” smear.
There was a great editorial in today’s Toronto Sun:
http://www.torontosun.com/Comment/Commentary/2005/11/24/1320530.html
The key excerpt that I’m quoting verbatim to all liberal supporters I know:
“After 12 years of Liberal rule, is our health care system better or worse? Is our justice system more focused on the victims or the accused? Is Canada more united or divided? Is our military stronger or weaker? Are conditions on reserves better or worse? Is our immigration system well-run and secure? Did the Liberals’ $2 billion gun registry reduce urban street crime? Finally, have the Liberals demonstrated to your satisfaction that they spend every tax dollar they take in as carefully as they would their own money?”
This election, I hope, will be the best belated Christmas present I’ve ever received.
sjd(at)cogeco(d0t)ca
Klein has touched on the most obvious of what lies ahead. Ontario will again decide the election.
The ballot question in Ontario is straight forward; Would you rather have a corrupt liberal government or Stephen Harper?
Klein’s fellow Albertan Mr. Manning may be on to something. If Ontarians pick the former we may all find ourselves in crisis.
In case there were any doubt that Bell GlobeMedia – owner of CTV and The Globe And Mail – have a relationship well beyond incestuous with Paul Martin’s Liberal government:
“Charles Bird is a lobbyist for Bell Globemedia (owner of The Globe and Mail and CTV) and is the Ontario campaign chairman for the federal Liberals. He told Ontario MPs the electorate is “very volatile” and warned that “it’s going to be a very negative campaign.”
Here’s a good test. Pick some random countries and go read one of their online newspapers. It’s pretty difficult to find a country with a media more compromised than what we have here. Take a look at Colombia’s “El Tiempo” or Thailand’s “The Nation”, for example, and try to tell me either of those is not of higher quality than “Canada’s National Newspaper”.
I’m looking at the front page of Pravda right now and am actually somewhat envious of Russians and their better, more truthful media. No biggie, though; Martin is a chump, a tomato can, a palooka, and all the whored-up media in the world won’t change the fact that he’s going down.
Kate, Liberal strategists (all strategists for that matter) are cold blooded to begin with.
I have a hunch that Jean Chretien may have some choice words to share with us all during this campaign.
Those comments may make Klein’s seem rather insignificant.
Ontarians praying for a Conservative victory had better put their money where their mouths are and help their local candidates as well as the provincial party. Doubt those voting Liberal will come across generously – they’re too complacent. Help get the word out with a contribution and CRUSH the Liberals before it’s too late. This is a critical turning point in Canadian history.
(An aside – maybe we could pray that God will send a major snowstorm to hit the GTA area on voting day and paralyze them all. The Army won’t help them out this time!)
What kind of democracy do we have in this f”’d up excuse of a country if a lobbiest can run an election campaign for the party he is paid to lobby.
Or for that matter a Priminister who owns a company that is allowed to flee from the punative excess taxation that he himself created.
I live in Ontario, and my friends and family all want to vote blue badly…but we don’t have a lot of faith in any of the parties right now.
The mainstream view is that the tories are full of fanatic Christian wackos……and the mainstream view seems right on the money.
I’ll vote Conservative, but I won’t like it. I won’t like it until we have a new leader…someone a little bit more red or small-c….
The current party is too far right, and far too fundamentalist for my liking. I miss the Progressive Conservative Party….and like many others I’m sure the idea of splitting the right again holds some appeal, though it would only lead to many more years of Liberal governing.
I really wish you westerners would ease up a bit.
The gay marriage thing…get over it. Don’t talk abotu it. It’s done….deal with it. Keep talking about it and it justs keeps all right wingers painted into a corner with all the other rascist homophobes out there.
The Tradesports betting market is currently assigning less than a 30% chance to the Tories winning the most seats in the next election. That is to say you can buy for under $3 a ticket that pays off at $10 if the Tories win the most seats. If you think the Tories have better than a 30% chance of winning, go put some money on it…. http://www.tradesports.com
I have one very important thing to say…
Shut your f*c*king mouth Ralph Klein.
Get your ass back to Edmonton where you belong, and take an Alberta Break. Please Christ.
I suspect that even if the Tories conceded the gay marriage issue, they would just be pilloried on some other issue, like Medicare.
The Tories face many obstacles, not the least of which is the fact that the business elite of this country is dominated by pals of the Liberals. This same business elite happens to control most of the mainstream media outlets. They’re going to pull out all the stops to make sure that their friends remain in office and continue to lavish subsidies and protected markets on them.
The only thing that might change things is the realization that a Tory government will not cause the sky to fall. I for one am sick of all the chicken-little nonsense cooked up by the Liberals and their fellow-travellers in the mainstream media and I suspect many other Canadians are too. We’ll have to wait and see if this trend grows. I’m not holding my breath, however.
Shhhhhh, don’t tap on the aquarium, Eric 😉
SJD, ask your lib neighbours why Belinda hasn’t spilled the beans on the hidden agenda yet.
Shank, I guess far right is in the eye of the beholder. The CPC is far too left for my liking. There’s no indication that they have any plans to cut the size and scope of the gov’t and act like conservatives. As for “someone a little bit more red or small-c..”, I hope there’s a typo in there. Those two terms are complete opposites.
I can’t wait to see PMPM’s face on election night when he learns of his new role on the opposition side of the house! Nobody does the “deer in the headlights” look better for the cameras than him. It’ll look great on the next Libranos poster for a new season of viewing. The episodes that show forensic audit details linking PM to other “money for nothing” ad-scams will be priceless.
LIBERALS HAVE THE HIDDEN AGENDA
The Liberals proved last night that they are the ones with a hidden agenda – an agenda to tax our retirement savings. It was the Liberals who created the income trust mess by threatening to change the existing rules. Last night they screwed up by reading a press release that indicated trusts would be taxed in 2007. That was later retracted with a policy to leave trusts alone and reduce personal taxes on dividends (the right decision).
What would have happened if the Liberals had a majority and were not facing an election? You cannot trust these people with your money!
PMPM belongs behind bars or at the end of a rope not anywhere in the house. Oh to have a republican to vote for. Then we could get rid of all the commies.
If the Libs have hired a professional manipulator from Bellglobemedia, perhaps it’s time we boycotted BGM. Don’t read the Globe and watch Global instead of CTV. The Sun chain are informative. And mass cancellation of Globe subscriptions might cause a stir or two. These guys hang together, so it’s open season on the Tories. Just hope they have the stomach to play the game from a higher ground, albeit a muddy one.
To Shank and all others who fear the Conservative “Far Right” agenda. Have a look around at Conservative platforms in Austrailia, New Zealand, Great Britain. The CPC’s platform is further to the LEFT than all of these. Pretty safe to say that the CPC is the most liberal conservative party on the planet.
Liberals do not seem to have a platform period. Their vision seems to be to focused on doing whatever they have to do to get elected.
Perhaps you could enlighten me with the key points of the Liberal platform that you find so appealing as to ignore all the corruption, graft, bribery and waste.
It is rather premature for those here who are predicting another Liberal minority. As the polls sit right now, a swing of 5-7 percent of Ontario voters to the CPC would turn the election into a CPC victory.
The CPC have yet to unveil their platform and the stench of Adscam will rise again in the election. All that is needed is to convince a small minority in Ontario to change their voting patterns.
What if the CPC only asked the voters for a two-year mandate to govern with a focus on cleaning up the corruption in Ottawa? That would enable the focus of the campaign to stay on Liberal corruption, reduce the fear of some Ontario voters, and yet give a CPC government time to uncover much of the corruption that is going on prior to another election.
In the eastern end of the GTA (Durham Region) there is a good chance that the CPC can get 3 ridings. Right now, Oshawa and Clarington are already held by CPC incumbents. In Whitby, Jim Flaherty is running and is well liked in the riding and has been consistently voted in as MPP. The only concern is really Oshawa – with the GM news that just dropped, if Sid Ryan runs for the NDP again, he might be able to woo the blue collar vote. But here is to hoping for a trio of side by side CPC ridings.
Ontario voters are not locked into the Liberals and are largely in play this election. At least those outside of the 416 code.
That being said that doesnt mean they’ll move, but don’t assume they’ll stay voting Liberal.
There is a palpable difference around here this time round.
However, I am going to point to it again, in many polls there are only two provinces that Liberals do not lead in, Alberta and Quebec. Even our hosts beloved Saskatchewan has had Liberals in the lead.
So dont hang Ontario, there is enough blame to go around. We’ll do our best out here but CPC cant get realistically form a government with only Ontario becasue they cannot crack 416 (Toronto) but such is life. The rest of the country needs to be involved.
How can people possibly buy into the whole “If you elect the Conservatives, life will end,” bit? It’s so naive. I don’t think that the Conservatives should go into the whole SSM thing either but irregardless, I will vote for them because they are the best choice. If they start to get radical, we can vote them out again. That’s the way a democracy works. It can’t be any worse than the mess the Liberal party has us in. Also, I’m sick of hearing people who won’t vote CPC because of the leader. Find someone better? Don’t you mean, “Find someone eastern,”? If the Liberals are in again, I would separate in a fraction of a heartbeat. As for Liberals being ahead in Saskatchewan polls – I don’t have any definite information on that but I highly doubt it. The anger out here is profound.
Remember that poor old Ralph was a journalist, and journalists tend to get their opinions from other journalists. Still, as many posters have said, he may be right.
Consider this: in two elections in Nova Scotia, John Godfrey came in at the *bottom* of the poll, and by a considerable margin. This is difficult task for a Liberal to accomplish in the East. Since returning to Toronto, he has recorded *majorities*.
Do folks recall how Jacques Parizeau was pilloried when he complained about the effects of “money and the ethnic vote”? Despite the opprobrium heaped upon Parizeau, has anyone yet produced any evidence to contradict him?
I figure Saskatchewan will go 13-1 again for the Conservatives, will Goodale the lone holdout with a reduced majority. As for what happens nationally, I think it hinges on what issue(s) dominate the campaign. If scandal and corruption dominate the campaign, then the Liberals are certainly in trouble and there is an opening for a Conservative minority government. But if the focus of the campaign shifts to other issues, then the Liberals may secure another minority government. I won’t make any predictions about what is actually going to happen; it is too soon to tell.