Y2Kyoto: An Open Letter To The Geological Society

Back in 2010, 43 fellows of the Royal Society wrote to its then president, Paul Nurse, to complain about the unscientific tone of the society’s messages on climate change. A few days ago, a group of 33 current and former fellows of the Geological Society wrote an open letter to their president in similar vein. The text is reproduced below.

h/t Neil

22 Replies to “Y2Kyoto: An Open Letter To The Geological Society”

  1. Excellent letter, wonderful if it will penetrate the closed minds of the left. I have Ian Plimer’s book “Heaven and Earth” and he blew away all the lies of the AGW crowd. Doug Ford is cancelling Wynnebag’s Crap and Trade and returning the theft to Ontario’s citizens. Trust my lefty friends will send the savings back to Ontario or the Liberal Party… yeah, right.

    1. Please shut up. If anything could penetrate a closed mind, it would have happened already.

      Willful malevolence never repents.

  2. “climate science” has turned into a parody of itself….the only science that depends on the data hiding some where

    Hiding in the deep ocean….ocean floor sinking…..land sinking under Greenland….land sinking under Antarctica…..ice sheets melting on the bottom….on and on

    …always somewhere that no one can get to it…and always something that has to be made up

    1. Much of it is hidden in the past by the almost universal reduction of historical temperatures to make today’s temperatures appear warmer. It is a clever, but totally dishonest, plot.

      1. true that…..my favorite is UHI….UHI adds at least 10 degrees
        …so they adjust temps down 1/2 degree to compensate……and then claim adjustments lower the temp

    2. It’s like crony capitalism.

      One word repudiates the other, that is actual capitalism, ie free enterprise, not Marx’s BS.

    1. I predict that a lot of people will be fired at the Royal Geological Society and be replaced by “diversity” people who will be strong believers in man made global warming.

      Leftists are bullies, when they can not win the debate they fire people or they open inquiries or they silence their opponents.

      1. “Leftists are bullies, when they can not win the debate they fire people or they open inquiries or they silence their opponents.” That has been the hallmark of the left since 1917 and these eco fraudsters and husctsters have learned well from their ideological brethren.

  3. The world is always in flux, dynamic and fluid.

    Because we have highly sophisticated equipment for measuring and calculating which translates into minutia data collection, our ability to observe our world at macro and micro levels is enormous. Unfortunately, the data is for our glimpse in time and space right now. Looking back in history using our current values and applying them to the past and to the future is a fool’s game.

    The money makers are relying on preaching the message of salvation of the planet, people and animals in its current condition, or something a few decades ago, as their Utopian pinnacle.

    It’s like trying to build a house on an escalator.

  4. A small group claiming they represent the thoughts and experiences of a vast group of individuals is a blatant act of arrogance and deceit. This includes progressive feminists claiming to represent all women, presidents and prime ministers who present their political policies as ones favored by all citizens of that nation, or a small group of scientists speaking for an entire group to provide ammunition for appeal to authority arguments for the CAGW political agenda. Everyone knows it’s BS when activists claim to speak for a target group but most people play along.

    This caught my eye : “The absence of the predicted tropospheric hotspot – the ‘fingerprint of AGW’.” The tropospheric hotspot is one of the few predictions in AGW that can be checked in the real world. To my knowledge, the hotspot that the computer models indicate must be present have not been found. Unlike The Pause and other inconvenient indicators that warming may not be catastrophic, the tropospheric hotspot problem cannot be fixed by “adjusting” the data or reworking the computer models. What is the explanation for the absence of the hotspot, the fingerprint of global warming?

  5. “While there remain other areas of disagreement over the science of Global Warming and Climate Change (which are not the same thing),”

    Yes! one is a fraud of Science (AGW) and the other is a political fraud allowing deniability of stupidity (who can deny that climate change is a constant fact) The political deniability has now failed because everyone knows that it is AGW that is the real reason politicians are destroying their economies… In 200 years we MAY revisit the science, but like dark matter we don’t “YET” have a valid theory that is falsifiable…

    JMHO… Not a climate Scientist, what ever that “IS”

  6. Obviously a bunch of frustrated so-called scientists in the employ of … BIG OIL … getting filthy rich $$$ exploring for oil and violating Gaia ! /sarc.

  7. Nice letter it will fall before the systemic corruption of our age.
    Kleptocracy rules.
    The policy based evidence manufacturing that dominates “Climate science” which is sympatico with “Environment Canada’s Science” is the mark of the mediocracy that is our “public service”.

    The current levels of corruption and stupidity are insurmountable,if we use Roberts Rules of Committees, leeches this entrenched will not move of their own violation.
    The new flag will feature a Guillotine; Cause it is our heritage.

  8. “Industrial effluents and plastics, deforestation and overfishing are dangerous– and are being side-lined by the focus on CO2 emissions.”

    Of course they are. The Chinese are doing most of the work of poisoning the earth and destroying its forests and oceans—and have financed a massive propaganda campaign devoted to sticking the West with the blame, and the bill, so the little emperor of every Chinese family can stuff himself with fresh pork at every meal and drive a fine SUV for a fraction of what Canadians must pay.

    The only winners in the West in the make-believe war against climate change will be a few thousand globalists, who, you may be sure, are making a point of arranging Chinese wives for their sons. As we learned last night, in the future, only people with Chinese blood will be admitted to top American universities if the globalists have their way.

    1. “only people with Chinese blood will be admitted to top American universities if the globalists have their way.

      Wut?

  9. I might send this link to my MP – that’s right, Catherine McKenna – but then she might not have any time for me.

  10. I’m glad to see Dr. Tim Ball is mentioned as a supporter of this group of geological scientists! His book “The Deliberate Corruption of Climate Science” is in my mind a game changer!!! It is a study but well worth the effort! Dr. Howard Dewhirst echoes Tim Ball’s book. Anthropogenic Climate change is a fraud! The sooner we can right the ship, the sooner we can deal with the real threats to Mankind!

Navigation