Change of heart?

A curious turn of events in Holland:

Prosecutors in the trial of anti-Islam Freedom Party (PVV) leader Geert Wilders say he should be acquitted of group defamation.

Public prosecutors Birgit van Roessel and Paul Velleman now say his comments on the Qur’an referred to Islam and its holy book, and not to Muslim people.

In explaining their call for acquittal on the defamation charges, the prosecutors also explained that statements contained in the MP’s film, Fitna, referred to Islam as a religion and not to its followers. Even though the statements could hurt the feelings of Muslims, that was not the same as defamation of the group.

Positive news, to be sure, but Wilders has not (yet?) been acquitted of all charges:

On Friday, the prosecutors will either press for Mr Wilders to be found guilty on the incitement charges or for him to be acquitted. If they call for a guilty verdict, they will also put forward what they consider an appropriate sentence.

22 Replies to “Change of heart?”

  1. The prosecutors’ arguments for acquittal are of course correct: Islam is a religion, with members
    of most ethnicities (the al Rashid mosque in Edmonton claims 62 ethnicities among its congregation), and
    Wilders has never to my knowledge defamed Moslems per se.
    But what took the prosecutors so long to figure that out?

  2. HOORAH!!
    They blinked…..
    Perhaps somebody rationalized that this would be a precedant with which to convict and then to imprison all the muzzies and the lefties….of whatever ilk.
    Damn!!

  3. ‘BEHEAD ALL THOSE WHO OPPOSE SHARIA!!!!’
    i dunno…i’m SURE i’ve seen that and far more provocative remarks written on placards carried by my muzzie buddies…
    but i don’t remember seeing any of THEM going in the dock…
    well…like i said a decade ago that there is a hard rain a gonna fall…

  4. Just think had Mr. Wilders said something defamatory about Christianity, there would be nothing going on.
    In other news, the first miner in Chile has been brought to the surface.

  5. The cowardly Dutch leftist political class have suddenly realized that making a martyr out of Wilders will only bring on their “downfall” that much sooner.

  6. Are more Dutch people finally starting to realize that their society is standing on the edge of a precipice?

  7. Uh, uh. actually it is not exactly good. You forgot that:
    A United Nations forum on Thursday ( 25 March 2009) passed a resolution condemning “defamation of religion” as a human rights violation,…….The U.N. Human Rights Council adopted the non-binding text, proposed by Pakistan on behalf of Islamic states, with a vote of 23 states in favor and 11 against, with 13 abstentions.
    Prosecutors may make him a martyr yet.

  8. I think its entering some minds he may be their boss. Besides you make a martyr of him , than they will have real riots.
    There may be some small hope yet.
    JMO

  9. We don’t want to prosecute him,
    but we want all the Musclemen dominating our country, and Europe,
    to know we left him hanging in the wind for 1 year 9 months.
    –
    –
    “An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile,
    hoping it will eat him last.”

    Winston Churchill

  10. The issue is not whether or not the charges stand. It is that the law exists at all.
    The difference between Newfie jokes or defaming (for example) Americans and criticizing pretty much any other identifiable group hinges on how the group in question is going to react to the joke or criticism.
    That is a very poor foundation for law.

  11. “Public prosecutors Birgit van Roessel and Paul Velleman now say his comments on the Qur’an referred to Islam and its holy book, and not to Muslim people.”
    Few people understand how the courts work in Europe.
    We have an adversarial system in the Anglo-sphere.
    In much of the rest of Europe the have what is known as an inquisitorial system.
    With our adversarilal system you get a prosecutor and a defence attorney/barrister fighting as adversaries over a point of law with a judge presiding to make sure it’s a fair fight and follows the law.
    With the inquisitorial system the prosecutor(s) IS/ARE the judge(s) and his job is to get the “truth” while the defence attorney/barrister is there to make sure the facts that represent his/her client are presented.
    If the prosecutor/judge has determined the facts show well for the accused then certain charges can be dropped.
    On the other hand, if the prosecutor/judge is being directed by political considerations then the accused is going to get a sentence.
    (which can be appealed)
    -just a basic outline of the different systems-

  12. Wilders will see his legal oppression relived in direct proportion to the growth in his support. The state does not want to make martyrs who may inspire those they hope to oppress.
    However, Wilders will always be stigmatized by the political oligarchy. They may drop their open persecution but the fall back is a life long low level oppression of stimatization. Ideoocrats are totally predictable, Wilders is not – that alone frustrates them. The other thing that has them running scared is that Wilders has tapped into a deep resentment in th grass roots towards arrogant meddling social engineering government. THe Ideocrats are shocked that their engineered sheep have grown fangs and are hungry for fat complacent Ideocrats.

  13. The socialists’ leftarded tyrants have accomplished what they set out to do, silence anyone who dares speak out against the Islamic Supremacists and the left’s alliance to garner complete political power in Eurabia. He’s just the lamb they chose to publicly slaughter.

  14. “A United Nations forum on Thursday ( 25 March 2009) passed a resolution condemning “defamation of religion” as a human rights violation,…….The U.N. Human Rights Council adopted the non-binding text, proposed by Pakistan on behalf of Islamic states,”
    After Wilders trial is over and he hasn’t received sufficient punishment in the Muslim view,we can expect them to lobby for this non-binding resolution to become law.
    Defamation of religion could become a real nightmare as every lunatic fringe religion extant searches for “defamation” by somebody,somewhere.Priests of Set the Snake God may one day conduct prayers at the opening of Parliament.
    Perhaps this IS a glimmer of intelligence seeping into the brains of the prosecutors,but more likely it’s just the usual progressives fear of popular support for the other side in any issue.

  15. Breaking news, priests of Set the Snake god?
    They have their own political party. In fact two or three.

  16. A partial victory. He was found “not guilty” of defaming a group, i.e. he only criticized the religion. As one commenter pointed out, the UN is trying to fix this.
    Rhetorical question: Should there be any such thing as defamation of a group?
    Some libertarians believe there shouldn’t even be such a thing as defamation of an individual; that we don’t actually have a “right” to a good public opinion of ourselves. I’m not quite sure myself. Clearly the “defamed” has plenty of opportunity, especially in this high-tech, heavily networked world to correct the facts of a slander and let the public decide. And clearly the threat of a defamation suit will chill the expressions of the less-well heeled. See: Arab potentates and libel tourism via the UK. See: Soros contra Ezra.
    Again, this whole thing is crowd control — state suppression of any resistance to the subversive Eurabian project.

  17. From the sounds of that prosecutor climb-down in the article, it seems like somebody higher up the political food chain finally figured something out.
    Nothing could be better for Geert Wilders than to be found guilty in this farcical show trial and sent to jail. If they do it, his party will form the next Dutch government. For sure.
    I, The Invincible Phantom, so prophesy.

Navigation