In the wake of the massacre in Bucha, I was joined this week by my good friend, David Goldman from Asia Times to discuss Russia’s war plan in Ukraine and Biden’s dangerous response to Russia’s actions. We then pivoted to India and it’s decision to support Russia then on to the Middle East to consider what Russia’s remorseless pursuit of Ukraine’s destruction means for Israel, with Russia in control of Syria and the direct avenues of approach to Iran.
h/t Adrian
Mostly nonsense. Start with this: “What is Russia’s strategic plan?”
There isn’t one. They are running away showing all the signs of an army in disintegration as bad as Germany in 1944, the British army retreating from Kabul in 1842, the British army retreating from Burgos in 1813. Drunkenness, indiscipline, looting are all the usual symptoms of this kind of collapse, and the Russian army is now going through this.
Strategic plan? What was Germany’s strategic plan in 1944? What was Argentina’s strategic plan in 1982? There wasn’t one. After the Ardennes offensive in December 1944, Germany was finished.
Now, the Russians are defeated, and their army is running away around Kyiv. Much of Ukraine is a de-facto no-fly zone given the Russian losses of helicopters and elite Spetsnaz. Sinking of the Moskva would show that Ukraine has barred Russian naval forces from Ukraine coastal waters, much as the sinking of the Eilat closed Egyptian coastal waters in 1967.
What does this tell everyone in the Middle East? That the Russian armed forces are at least as incompetent as when they invaded Afghanistan in 1979. They have made essentially no progress since the disasters of the 1st and 2nd Chechnya wars.
kinda agree.
if there was a plan it failed and any perceived ‘victories’ by the russkies now in Ukraine will peter out at some point.
resorting to the usual rape and pillage aint on track as far as how the komrads spend their time and
resources and follow orders.
l will NO LONGER think fondly and bittersweet and a certain gratitude for their victory in the fight with the facists.
no longer wonder how were the lives of those that put the hammer and sickle atop the blasted and burned out reichtag?
none of that now in 2022.
l got a paper flag stapled on some aspenite and screwed to front wall my place with the words
Ukraine
forever
translated into Ukraine and centered on the 2 coloured sections.
p.s. the revised spelling is Puketin.
“…the revised spelling is Puketin.”
I prefer Pootin.
I prefer Pootin.
Pootin’ is what Prinz Dummkopf does every time he opens his yap.
True. I have equal hate for all enemies of civilization, foreign and domestics.
“Start with this: “What is Russia’s strategic plan?” ”
I think we all agree that it is not what it was when Pootin launched his offensive. Utter miscalculation that will be studied by military and political historians for decades. So what’s plan B? And here is where I think you may be wrong. He knows he can’t conquer Ukraine but what if he can ruin Ukraine? He can try to pull a Richelieu in Thirty Year War and strangle Ukraine to the point on near uninhabitability, the way HRE was devastated in mid 1640s. Yes this can still backfire against him, but it is not impossible.
“Drunkenness, indiscipline, looting are all the usual symptoms of this kind of collapse,”
Yes and no. In a civilized country they are, but were talking about russia here. Russians behaved like this in 1914, in 1920, in 1939, in 1945, in 1956, in 1968. This a Mongol way, they know no other.
Colon loves the civilized countries where they teach the kids all about being gay, and hats those uncivilized barbarians who don’t.
…and wants to defund the police…and wants to ban bicycles…and voted for the CPC when O’Tool ran the show, and will now tell us that Pierre only voted to ban the Proud Boys and investigate the GFM because of the Convoy, or voted in favor of banning “conversion therapy”, whatever that is, because he was scared of being “whipped.”
LOL, vote for the whipping boy!!
We have discussed your limitation in the past, no need to demonstrate them again.
Only one limitation? I’m touched.
Stop touching yourself.
Stop touching me.
Stop fantasizing. I would not touch you with stolen appendages.
“Pursuing regime change with a nuclear superpower is a really, really reckless thing to do.”
https://twitter.com/davidpgoldman/status/1515012511874969601
A far more open question is why Joe Biden’s puppetmasters think trying to overthrow Putin is a good idea.
They’ve been obsessed with it since he arose to power. They don’t control and rob Russia like they did under Yeltsin. They want Russia’s wealth for themselves and people like Nuland just cannot get over the fact that Russia is not communist. Also, NATO needs a justification and bombing the Serbs and Libyans was too easy.
Loss of sovereignty via bloodshed a la Putin or loss of sovereignty and human rights via the bankrupting and seizing control of the West a la WEF.
Very few seem to be noticing the second one.
Ward
Exactly….that right there is Vlads Goal…180 deg opposite of what the WEF controlled West wants. And y’all better believe it’s the WEF running the West…..
The west: Thinks the world is evolving towards a progressive “new world order”
Russia: Screw that! History is a fickle beast, we learned it the hard way, and now you are about to learn!
I’m pretty sure Its Putin’s fault that every western leader is puttin’ the squeeze on their own people. Putin is a super-being, able to control western leaders like puppets. Him and Xi. If only they were gone, we’d all be so much better off, with freedom for all, smokin in bars and restaurants, dancin’ on the effin’ tables!/s
The quoted paragraph contains two whoppers:
1- “In the wake of the massacre in Bucha”. We really do not know this.
2. “Putin’s remorseless pursuit of Ukraine’s destruction.” Not true! The US neocon remorseless pursuit of Russia’s destruction is, however, clearly incontrovertibly true.
Therefore I did not feel compelled to watch the interview.
I’m afraid that the Russian’s world view is preferable to ours.
Manifest destiny is an obscenity against Nature.
All that is real is economics, which is actually the thermodynamic of very complex dissipative systems in very very far from equilibrium states. Pareto’s Law, etc. The more a society shies away from physical reality, the greater the catastrophe.
“We really do not know this.”
Yes we do.
“Not true! ”
True.
“The US neocon remorseless pursuit of Russia’s destruction is, however, clearly incontrovertibly true.”
I wish it was true. Russia has no right to exist.
Ah, now it makes more sense!
Obviously if Russia has no right to exist (one of two countries in the world that does not enjoy this privilege) anything it does to protect its security is axiomatically unjust. And anything done by its enemy — like running a massacre hoax with a single videotape it made with absolutely zero proof — should be accepted on faith.
Check out Lew Rockwell whose banner reads: anti state – anti-war – pro free markets. He manages to make a cogent argument in favour of Putin’s legitimate security concerns. Oh, sorry. The country does not have a right to exist.
Russia is NOT the Soviet Union which an ethnic Pole like yourself is justified in arguing didn’t have a right to exist. And it doesn’t anymore. Martin Armstrong argues that if Putin is brought down what would follow would be infinitely worse.
Come clean Colonialista. You’re horny for global nuclear war.
Ok first stop confusing might with right. If I could Dalek russia I would. In a heartbeat, and I would sleep like a baby after. But I can’t. Russia unfortunately has the might to exists. It does not mean the whore of nations has a right. Nor does it, at any point lead to the ridiculous conclusion that I am hoping for a nuclear war. That’s just stupid.
I would Dalek them not because of my Polish background but because of my civilizational allegiance. I might see it more clearly than delusional westerners, fair enough.
“With the Russians it is not a question of whether but of when”
“If you say why not bomb them tomorrow, I say why not today? If you say today at 5 o’clock, I say why not one o’clock?” ~ John Von Neumann.
This was said before they had hundreds of nukes, and he was right. That option is unfortunately off the table. But yes, we should be doing everything to stack the deck against them and to make them as weak as possible.
The Russian massacres are not a hoax, nor are the mass rapes, nor is sending thousands of Ukrainians to gulags, nor is kidnapping thousands of children. These are examples of russians being russian. The sooner you stop denying reality the better.
You want russia to exist? I don’t see why. They’re vile and worthless. They’re subhuman. They’re Mongols. World would be better off without them than with them. You dare to talk about “Putin’s legitimate security concerns.” ?????
F*** you, sideways, with a nail studded two-by-four. Hypocrite.
All this bullshit about russia’s concerns is simply about their right to dominate and enslave her neighbours. All people much more valuable than russians. All people who want nothing else but to be safe and free from the Siberian mongrels. What about their wishes? What about their rights? They don’t factor in your calculations, do they? Freedom is for russians only.
There is no coexistence with russia.
Ment
/\++++++/\
If I wanna know what’s going on at ground level in the Ukraine… it will be via 1 or 2 Totally independent reporters. Patrick Lancaster for one…and this guy speaks Russian as well as English.
The MSM simply switched off Covid Bullshit and went 100% all in on Ukraine Bullshit…as they were COMPELLED to do.
(some military minds here)
I never see mentioned Russia’s conventional long range artillery? Don’t they constantly have the option to roll the big guns down from Russia and Belarus? Cheaper than precision missiles. Expensive in lives, property and world opinion, but effective. With Russian air superiority, does Ukraine have any counter for that?
My (barely informed) prediction: Russia take what they want in Donbass, occupy/secure/pacify Mariupol and Odessa, then unleash on a medium sized city or 2 to the west(maybe not Kiev itself, but, maybe Kiev), go all Grozny/Sarajevo on them. Probably wait till around September to escalate. Close to winter. Germans will broker a deal even if they have to bypass the Yanks (because, like Victoria Nuland said all those years ago:”y’know, fk the Europeans”). Germany will ‘buy’ the Donbass from Ukraine and use the Donbass to pay for gas.
Hard to see the Yanks missing out on all the spoils, though. Sleepy Joe didn’t send Hunter over there just for the big paycheques
“… never see mentioned Russia’s conventional long range artillery? ….”
Then you’re not paying attention. They have been using them all the time 2S3, 2S7, 2S19 have been featured extensively. So did MLRS both Grad and Uragan.
Virtue single this nazi lovers
Exclusive Interview – Aiden Aslin – British Man Fighting for Ukraine, Captured in Donbass, Mariupol
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rNizGwjZbo0
Looks like phase two, or whatever you like to call it, is kicking off tonight; massive bombardments and mass attacks around the Donbas.
About those ‘massacre’s in Ukraine”:
https://thesaker.is/press-briefing-by-permanent-representative-vassily-nebenzia-on-the-situation-in-the-town-of-bucha-kiev-region-and-related-matters/
YouTube has banned any mention of this, you are required to accept that these are massacre’s, without question.
“War is all hell”, artillery, which Russia has a lot of, causes casualties, when the morgue fills up, you have to bury them somewhere.
Bagdad Bob is back.
Given that most of the Iraq War was theatre and posturing,I always figured Bagdad Bob would resurface with a new identity.
Working for the Media Party?
Oh yes I totally buy the “Russia Losing war” meme.
Just as I buy the pure intent and sacred goodness of Emperor Justine of Canada..
If Russia is so being defeated,what would winning this conflict look like?
Or have we moved to Justine’s Truth Theatre?
Where killing your enemies,means they win?