Why did the Greater Toronto Airports Authority donate $1000 to Paul Martin's Liberal leadership campaign?Posted by Kate at June 21, 2005 12:28 PM
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.smalldeadanimals.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/2154
That's only a start. Take a look at how many EDAs the airport authority donated to. They're just one of many non-profits donating exclusively to the Liberals.
Posted by: BBS at June 21, 2005 1:20 PMIt appears I'm going to have to post more of PM the PM's funding sources.
Thanks for the link.
Posted by: Toronto Tory at June 21, 2005 2:02 PM$1,000 dollar donation doesn't get you much pull in federal politics. I'm really not sure why this is even a topic.
Posted by: M.K. Braaten at June 21, 2005 2:44 PM$1000 donation doesn't get one far in federal politics - but 100 of them do.
Same pattern is repeated over and over again - small donations from sources that one would think would steer clear of formal politics, virtually all of them to Liberals. Never enough to trigger a media frenzy....
But start adding them up.
Well, according to recent revelations less than $1000 a year spread over 3 or 4 years gets you a judgeship in Quebec.
Posted by: Samuel Adams at June 21, 2005 3:30 PMBang on...this stuff is ridiculous. You get municipalities, airport authorities, crown corps etc donating.
They should be banned from sending money. The Municipalities and federally regulated entities should all be BANNED from contribuiting hard or soft money.
Bell, Rogers, the airlines, any crown corp and municipal or federal government should all be relieved of the option. It creates too much of potential for conflict AND is just plain stupid. For crying out loud one level of government isnt allowed to tax another, why would they be allowed to make poilitical contributions.
Anyone organization who receives federal money in the form of a loan or grant should be banned from contributing anything to federal politics or politicians.
Posted by: Stephen at June 21, 2005 3:36 PMOf course the biggest donation to the Liberals is delivered via the MSM. The daily assaults we have become all to familiar with demonstrate the political philanthropic journalism of the MSM. No doubt the MSM are recipients of Liberal advertising contracts and other favours in return for such political generosity?
Posted by: freethinca at June 21, 2005 3:42 PMBreaking rumour about the Liberal cabinet shuffle:
I heard something very very strange - but who knows these days.
That the "deal" between the Liberals and NDP is about to become a formal coalition with members of the NDP, specifically Jack Layton, being appointed to cabinet. Hence the cabinet shuffle to make room for the new coaltion members.
If that is true so much for all the years of hard work AGAIN by the Liberal backbenchers. For Cabinet only traitors need apply?
Could THIS really be the nudge nudge wink wink napkin deal in the hotel room between PM and Jack?
Posted by: HappyDaze at June 21, 2005 3:54 PMIf true
1) Kiss NDP support in Quebec good bye
2) You may see some Liberal members defecting to the tories since their chances are totally gone
3) Watch the right wing of the Liberal party turn pale.
4) Watch bay street freak out...dollar will fall...etc etc
Posted by: Stephen at June 21, 2005 4:35 PM"$1,000 dollar donation doesn't get you much .... I'm really not sure why this is even a topic."
Those words speak volumes about the apathy of a great deal of Canadians. First of all, that $1000 wasn't their money, it was yours and I don't know about you but it takes me a while to earn a grand. Ans secondly, just how much of a crime has to be commited before it is a topic?
I am just glad there are still people like Kate that give a **** about their country.
MK Bratten, it was more than $1000 donations, as I detailed on my blog, there are 3 additional donations related to the same director at the GTAA. Those donations total $14,000. With the original $1000, that's $15,000.
.. and, as Kate said, we're talking about a clear pattern of behaviour, not isolated donations.
Posted by: Toronto Tory at June 21, 2005 7:07 PMAnd I thought it was only Calgary Zoo that was dumb enough to use taxpayer dollars to donate to the Lieberal party!
Posted by: Rick at June 21, 2005 7:26 PMJust a quick little snapshot, thanks to Bound by Gravity's great little search tool:
Greater Toronto Airports Authority 2000 Business Liberal Party $7,854.93
Greater Toronto Airports Authority 2003 Business Liberal Party $6,889.00
Greater Toronto Airports Authority 2002 Unincorporated Liberal Party $5,989.10
Greater Toronto Airports Authority 2001 Unincorporated Liberal Party $5,005.20
The Calgary Airport Authority 2002 Business Liberal Party $3,528.70
Vancouver In't Airport Authority 1996 Business Liberal Party $3,453.00
Calgary Airport Authority 2001 Business Reform Party $3,020.00
Vancouver Airport Authority 1995 Business Liberal Party $2,968.20
Calgary Airport Authority 2002 Business Reform Party $2,891.00
The Calgary Airport Authority 2001 Business Liberal Party $2,507.28
Airport Automotive Services Limited 1993 Business Liberal Party $2,500.00
Halifax International Airport Authority 2001 Business Liberal Party $2,459.30
The Calgary Airport Authority 1997 Business Liberal Party $2,287.12
The Calgary Airport Authority 1998 Unincorporated Liberal Party $2,236.80
Calgary Airport Authority 2001 Business Progressive Conservative Party $1,654.56
Calgary Airport Authority 2003 Business Reform Party $1,600.00
Calgary Airport Authority 2002 Business Progressive Conservative Party $1,501.04
Edmonton Airports 2001 Business Liberal Party $1,249.36
Calgary Airport Authority 2000 Business Reform Party $1,204.00
Edmonton Airports 2000 Business Liberal Party $1,157.96
It should also be noted that the former PC and Reform weren't exactly clean in this regard - they just weren't as good as the Liberals at shaking loose the money.
(BTW, Andrew's search tool works better than the one in use at Elections Canada's website - go figure!)
Posted by: BBS at June 21, 2005 7:38 PMI think it's a no-brainer that it should be against the law for anyone who has donated to a federal party to receive government money. Such a restriction would go a long way towards cutting the feedback loop that defines corruption.
Posted by: EBD at June 21, 2005 8:00 PMBoard of Directors
The GTAA is a not-for-profit corporation without share capital and is governed by a 15-member board drawn from nominees from the four regional municipalities of Durham, Halton, Peel, York and the City of Toronto, the Province of Ontario and the Government of Canada and from the Greater Toronto Area business and professional community.
Warren C. Hurren, Chairman of the Board
Warren Hurren is a founding partner of the accounting firm Hurren, Sinclair, MacIntyre and is currently the Ajax Rotary Club’s District Governor’s Representative in Durham.
Nominated by the GTA Boards of Trade/Chambers of Commerce
Gregg Badger
Gregg Badger is Secretary and is in charge of Risk and Asset Management at Ronald A. Chisholm Limited, a Toronto-based international food merchant that trades and transports meat and dairy commodities worldwide.
Nominated by the Province of Ontario
Patrick S. Brigham
Patrick Brigham is Chair of Mad Catz Interactive Inc., a leading provider of innovative peripherals in the interactive entertainment industry.
Nominated by the GTAA Board as a Member-at-Large
Scott R. Cole
Scott Cole is President of Cole Engineering Group Ltd., a multi-disciplined consulting engineering and architectural firm and has extensive experience in several areas such as the transportation industry, environmental assessment, and land development.
Nominated by the Regional Municipality of York
Mac Cosburn
Mac Cosburn is Vice-President of Stantec Consulting, and a current and past member of several professional hospital and charitable boards.
Nominated by the GTA Boards of Trade/Chambers of Commerce
Marilynne E. Day-Linton
Marilynne Day-Linton is a Chartered Accountant with a background in the travel industry.
Nominated by the Chartered Accountants of Ontario
Christine E. Hart
Christine Hart is President and founder of Accord/hart & associates inc., a transportation and environmental lawyer, corporate director, and one of Canada’s pioneers in Alternative Dispute Resolution.
Nominated by the Government of Canada
Benjamin J. Hutzel
Benjamin Hutzel is a partner with the firm of Bennett Jones, and the founding Chairman of the Canadian Lawyers Liability Assurance Society.
Nominated by the Government of Canada
Catherine J. Knipe
Catherine Knipe is a founding partner of Meadow Group Consulting Inc. and has held numerous senior management positions in the healthcare field.
Nominated by the Regional Municipality of Halton
Norman B. Loberg
Norman Loberg is currently president of BrandActive International Inc. (a brand implementation management firm), Chairman of the Credit Valley Hospital Board of Governors and is a director of several boards.
Nominated by the GTAA Board as a Member-at-Large
Louis H. Parsons
Louis Parsons is the President of Lou Parsons & Associates Inc. and the former Chairman of GO Transit and Regional Municipality of Peel.
Nominated by the Regional Municipality of Peel
Dale E. Richmond
Dale Richmond recently retired as the President and Chief Executive Officer of OMERS (Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System) and is a former Chief Administrative Officer (CAO) for the Municipality of Metropolitan Toronto.
Nominated by the GTAA Board as a Member-at-Large
Richard M. Soberman
Richard Soberman is an Associate of Trimap Communications Inc., Professor Emeritus of Civil Engineering, University of Toronto. He is a transportation specialist.
Nominated by the GTA Boards of Trade/Chambers of Commerce & PEO
Lawrence D. Worrall
Lawrence Worrall is currently a Director of several boards. These include the Oshawa General Hospital Foundation, Intier Automotive Incorporated, Tiercon Automotive Incorporated and Van Rob Stamping Incorporated.
Nominated by the Regional Municipality of Durham
President and Chief Executive Officer
John Kaldeway
Mr. Kaldeway began his extensive experience in airport operations with Transport Canada in 1974. He has held the positions of Director, Airport Operations, Vice President, Operations & Maintenance, Vice President, Transition Programs, and, most recently, Chief Operating Officer.
Mr. Kaldeway’s breadth of knowledge and experience in the aviation industry will help guide the GTAA in continuing the improvement of Toronto Pearson.
Librano$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
GTAA is a not-for-profit corporation: oxymoron.
Time for Canadians to point fingers at Canadians.
How did the GTAA find the money for these contributions to political parties if the GTAA is a not-for-profit corporation?
How were the figures entered on the books? Asset or expense? Did you receive a tax-deductible receipt.
Who made the motion to send the contributions? Seconder? Was the motion carried unanimously?
Date of the motion? Results of the vote? Amounts?
Will you continue this policy? Why/not?
We await your answers. Post on this blogspot, please.
Posted by: maz2 at June 21, 2005 8:40 PM37th PARLIAMENT, 2nd SESSION
Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs
EVIDENCE
CONTENTS
Thursday, May 29, 2003
¹ 1535
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish (Mississauga Centre, Lib.))
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew (President, Liberal Party of Canada)
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish)
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V Ms. Paddy Torsney (Burlington, Lib.)
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish)
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish)
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
¹ 1540
V Mr. Jack Graham (Vice-President (English), Liberal Party of Canada)
¹ 1545
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish)
V Mr. Jack Graham
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish)
V Mr. Jack Graham
¹ 1550
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V Mr. Benjamin Hutzel (Chief Financial Officer, Liberal Party of Canada)
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish)
V Mr. Benoît Sauvageau (Repentigny, BQ)
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish)
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V Mr. Benjamin Hutzel
¹ 1555
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish)
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish)
V Mr. Michael Hillman (Vice-President (British Columbia), Liberal Party of Canada)
º 1600
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V Mr. Michael Eizenga (Secretary-Treasurer, Liberal Party of Canada)
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V Mr. Michael Eizenga
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish)
V Mr. Ted White (North Vancouver, Canadian Alliance)
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
º 1605
V Mr. Ted White
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V Mr. Ted White
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V Mr. Ted White
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V Mr. Ted White
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V Mr. Jack Graham
V Mr. Ted White
V Mr. Jack Graham
V The Vice-Chair (Mrs. Carolyn Parrish)
V Mr. Jacques Saada (Brossard—La Prairie, Lib.)
V Mr. Stephen LeDrew
V Mr. Jacques Saada
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Appearing here and on the GTAA Board is one Benjamin Hutzel.
Hutzel shows here as Chief Financial Officer, Liberal Party of Canada. Hutzel, [the same person?], appears on the Board of the GTAA, "Nominated by the Government of Canada".
Is Hutzel one and the same person?
What can one reasonably conclude?
Is there a conflict of interest?
Mmmmmm???
If there's not two Benjamin Hutzel's, that's another fishy detail there. Great work, Maz.
Posted by: EBD at June 21, 2005 9:58 PMNot much money. I'd like to see who else the Airport donated to.
Posted by: Tom Penn at June 21, 2005 11:41 PMUnofficial Canadian Political Contributions Search Tool (Ver: alpha 0.61 - April 27, 2005) (Report a Bug)
Search Criteria:
Choose some or all of the following.
Note: Selecting NONE from a category will select ALL from that category.
Fiscal Year(s):
1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
Political Party(s):
Abolitionist Party Bloc Québécois Canada Party Canadian Action Party Conservative Party (CPC)
Christian Heritage Party Reform Party Communist Party Liberal Party Libertarian Party
Marijuana Party Marxist-Leninist Party National Party Natural Law Party NDP
Commonwealth of Canada Party Progressive Conservative Party Social Credit The Green Party
Contributer Class(es):
Individual Business Government Trade Union Corporation Un-incorporated Org. or Assoc.
Donor Name (partial names accepted):
You specified the following search criteria:
Year(s): All
Party(s): All
Class(es): All
Donor Name: benjamin hutzel
Results:
1
Name of contributor Year Class Name of political party Donation $
Benjamin Hutzel 2000 Individual Liberal Party $4,590.78
Benjamin Hutzel 1998 Individual Liberal Party $3,582.85
Benjamin Hutzel 2003 Individual Liberal Party $995.00
1
2005 - Unofficial Canadian Political Contributions Search Tool - Created by Andrew Anderson of bound by gravity
All content is publically available from: Elections Canada
Ben is the founding Chairman of the Canadian Lawyers Liability Assurance Society, a registered insurer which provides errors and omissions insurance to lawyers across Canada.
Ben is a Director of the Greater Toronto Airports Authority and the Woodbine Entertainment Group.
He is also a director of the Federal Liberal Agency, the financial oversight committee for the Liberal Party of Canada.
Posted by: maz2 at June 22, 2005 12:54 PMThis calls for another post.
These facts, in aggregate, are big news. We have to let people know about this.
http://torontotory.blogspot.com
Posted by: Toronto Tory at June 23, 2005 7:52 PM