Well I guess that explains the staying power of the LPC....you have to suck that hard to produce such power politicians like PET, Cret, Steff and Higgy.
Interestingly, perhaps, if everything goes according to plan, our Saturday night, January 25th, SDA Late Nite Radio Distinguished Talks series will present an hour on the very specific question of the micro-structure of empty space, which we'll begin to touch on in general in next Saturday night's show.
Physicists do not deny the existence of zero-point energy. From a thermodynamic point fo view, however, it does not seem possible to exploit it. People who claim it is possible are on the fringes of science, and many consider them crackpots.
The proof is in the pudding, of course. If these zero-point energy supporters can produce a device that taps zero-point energy then they win the argument. Until then, my money is on the physicists.
Don't know anything about Bearden or his work, but this forum is definitely the place to present science.
Nothing but appreciators, all.
Teach: I suppose the particles that were predicted theoretically before they were discovered don't count in your calculus of what is a 'worthwhile' theoretical entity. Same goes for just about every physical law that was discovered theoretically before it was confirmed; e.g., SR and GR, to name two.
Damn! Fine idea!! I'm goin' right down to the basement and stick my vacuum hose into the main panel...:)
(if there's a power blackout on the West Coast make sure I get the credit, eh!)
Fanny and Freddy applied the energy in a vacuum theory to the financial world and pretty much ended it. New working theory: Money vacuums can't pay loans.
Gore Co. is applying a similar theory to global temperature to save the planet: living humans warm the planet. However, after over ten years of off-trend cooling, stressed economies, explosive growth of nanny state authority and heaps of failed predictions a new working theory is emerging: The sun heats the earth and nothing else in by either nature or man comes within an order of magnitude to matching the effect of changes with the sun output on our climate change. All of man's efforts to affect climate change are futile and worse than useless.
The continuing fraud from so-called "experts" telling us we can get something from nothing has been sold to us over and over. I may be skeptical but the only perpetual motion machines I've seen are the people that sell this snake oil. They're like black holes, sucking up time, space, energy and the big one...money.
Hey, nobody can out-do Midge Michaels. Not only can she propel a ping-pong ball but afterwards she drinks a glass of water! And not through her mouth.
She's quite the entertainer!
Look I can imagine the possibilities just as well as the next guy, but where theoretical physics is concerned, let's be realistic here. The reality is if you tinker with the math long enough you can make anything appear plausible. That's pretty much what they've done with string theory...they're up to what, 12 or 14 theoretical dimensions needing to exist in order for the thing to work? Ummm...Ok...
I have no idea what the "convential" thinking was 200 years ago. I do know man started thing about electricity about the same time he started thinking about alchemy. Cheers.
AHA - Eureka !! (not Electolux either) - So we are just a magnificent idea, the negative manifestation of an electrical force.
Holy mackeral, what one can learn from the internet.
I am going back to the Weblog Awards site to vote for SDA.
M-theory identifies 11 dimensions. There really is nothing strange about dimensions beyond what we perceive. I'm sure everyone laughed at atomic theorists, too. String theories only seem to be outside of our experimental grasp. I'm pretty certain that we'll find a way to either confirm or discount them, maybe in my lifetime. I suspect it will more likely involve astronomers and space telescopes, rather than particle physicists and massive, expensive colliders.
Although I still hold out hope that the LHC will find Higgs.
This is promising stuff indeed. With a plastic bag and a vacuum (both undoubtedly readily at hand), Henry The OrganMauler, newly of the Order of Canada, could explore the outer reaches the Milky Way.
On the other hand, we would need to find a model of Electrolux that can suck and blow at the same time if we are to bestow Jack Talibanana similar astronomical laurels.
And, with the appearance of Shaken, all was calm...for the defenders of womb-boogers had arrived to the thread. And with them came their new, cool nicknames.
"Hey everyone! Check out my new name for this BABY KILLER! Cool, eh? I'm so cool, therefore, by association!"
There was a SciFi story by James Blish that took the idea of using 'fringe' avenues of research and giving them top rank priority for funding. The idea being that the established lines of research were consuming ever increasing resources with ever diminishing results.
So a few hairball research projects that were being run by otherwise credible people were prioritized by the desired results that were expected of them
Makes for good SF but you'd be hard pressed to get that by the establishment.
Back in school I once got sidetracked and took a misstep while showing a proof on a calculus exam.
I applied all correct rules to arrive at completely different result than the one desired.
However the unintentional sidestep was not an incorrect use of the calculus, it was just not THE correct and proven formula.
Years ago while doing some Top Secret work I was mistakenly allowed to watch a few minutes of a timeport halograph in which Columbus presented a similar space vacuum pipe design to power his sea voyage to and from the Indies. Both the pipe and a proposed auxiliary fusion reactor were rejected by Ferdinand and Isabella. It turned out they were deeply indebted to the Sailmakers Guild for war financing. They didn't know or care if Columbus could ever find his way back or not with sails only. I lost a lot of respect for them over that.
"However the unintentional sidestep was not an incorrect use of the calculus, it was just not THE correct and proven formula."
Two possibilities:
1) Your reasoning was faulty
2) You used the correct mathematical reasoning, but did not write out a formula correctly
Which one was it? I only ask since you sound like you're trying to say that many physics theories are just mathematical odd cases. If so, that's wrong. It's not a physics theory if it doesn't represent the physical world in some way. In fact, it's usually nitpicking mathematicians that find odd cases (say, strange solutions) of physical theories that have no physical correspondence or that are not physically realisable, but that nonetheless exist.
Ural; Thanks for the comment. Just thinking we are surely only at the first stages of understanding the potential of vacuum in space. If you are familiar with the Dune series, both of my sons one now an engineer the other a lawyer, convinced me to enjoy and stretch my imagination. The discussions about the untapped potential of the space vacuum makes wonder (imagine?)about the prescience of Captain Nemo and the Nautilius. Maybe the wormholes used by the Enterprise were the result of harnessing space vacuum. ;) Cheers.
Anon @ 4:42 "Don't know anything about Bearden or his work, but this forum is definitely the place to present science.
Nothing but appreciators, all."
So what are you doing here then? If we are all a bunch of inbred rednecks not even worthy of your contempt, why do you insist to keep dazzling us your "intelligence"?
Could none of your other "friends" play outside today?
Kate- Can you help me out? Since what surrounds us is a space-time continuum what is outside this package? Does the emptiness outside space have something to do with the energy proposed from within space-time? Just wonderin!
Wow, this is AWESOME! Tell me where I can buy my Zero Point (tm) generator RIGHT NOW! I've got my checkbook open, yeah baby! I'm going to slap that puppy in the back of my race car and go win the Baja 500. Should be enough juice left over to run my very own aluminum smelter and casting foundry. SWEET!
Violations of conservation of energy will not be tolerated.
As to M-theory, millions of dollars in research grants and hundreds of careers were wasted for the last ~40 years in theoretical physics because of String Theory and its descendents.
Anyone trying to research outside string theory or Super string theory or M theory faced resistance from within the community and likely would not receive research grants.
M-theory is a theory that was developed purely from mathematics and not from observations of reality.
No experimental evidence suggests that this theory is valid and no proposed experiments can be done with any current or even imagined technology.
In short, nearly 40 years of theorizing (Which led to the speculation of zero point energy and this entry) and no results always led by the stringy theorists mantra that in the future experiments will be available to prove this bloated intellectual masturbatory claptrap. /rant off
Well anon with respect to my reasoning and my formula ... that's a fair assessment. Even though a proof is not necessarily arrived at by only one path and that any number of paths may produce a "formula" that gives the desired result.
Like I said I got sidetracked.
I still say that it happens a lot that theories evolve from mistakes. More often than some theorists would care to admit.
Why this blog? Until this moment
I have been forced
to listen while media
and politicians alike
have told me
"what Canadians think".
In all that time they
never once asked.
This is just the voice
of an ordinary Canadian
yelling back at the radio -
"You don't speak for me."
homepage email Kate (goes to a private
mailserver in Europe)
I can't answer or use every
tip, but all are
appreciated!
"I got so much traffic afteryour post my web host asked meto buy a larger traffic allowance."Dr.Ross McKitrick
Holy hell, woman. When you
send someone traffic,
you send someone TRAFFIC.
My hosting provider thought
I was being DDoSed. -
Sean McCormick
"The New York Times link to me yesterday [...] generatedone-fifth of the trafficI normally get from a linkfrom Small Dead Animals."Kathy Shaidle
"Thank you for your link. A wave ofyour Canadian readers came to my blog! Really impressive."Juan Giner -
INNOVATION International Media Consulting Group
I got links from the Weekly Standard,Hot Air and Instapundit yesterday - but SDA was running at least equal to those in visitors clicking through to my blog.Jeff Dobbs
"You may be anasty right winger,but you're not nastyall the time!"Warren Kinsella
"Go back to collectingyour welfare livelihood."Michael E. Zilkowsky
"The scientific community takes a bizarre stance."
? Wide
Comic (cerebral) relief?
A good distraction indeed...
Well I guess that explains the staying power of the LPC....you have to suck that hard to produce such power politicians like PET, Cret, Steff and Higgy.
The Liberal Party of Canada is a vacuum.
Syncro
Kate - are you going for Best Science Blog next year?
Are there any proofs for this or is this just another theoretical circle-jerk like string theory?
Interestingly, perhaps, if everything goes according to plan, our Saturday night, January 25th, SDA Late Nite Radio Distinguished Talks series will present an hour on the very specific question of the micro-structure of empty space, which we'll begin to touch on in general in next Saturday night's show.
Edward Teach: "Are there any proofs for this ... "
I think we have moved away from that archaic notion to the much more enlightened consensus (just the word ... no actual consensus is necessary).
Inane....?
What does this guy think happens .... a big battery charger gets hooked up to the universe every night?
Yin /Yang everything in tension and balance.
Mom's Watching
I saw this stripper once called Anita Tension and her balance was AMAZING!!
Syncro
Physicists do not deny the existence of zero-point energy. From a thermodynamic point fo view, however, it does not seem possible to exploit it. People who claim it is possible are on the fringes of science, and many consider them crackpots.
The proof is in the pudding, of course. If these zero-point energy supporters can produce a device that taps zero-point energy then they win the argument. Until then, my money is on the physicists.
Kate, you've been taken in by pseudo-science.
Don't know anything about Bearden or his work, but this forum is definitely the place to present science.
Nothing but appreciators, all.
Teach: I suppose the particles that were predicted theoretically before they were discovered don't count in your calculus of what is a 'worthwhile' theoretical entity. Same goes for just about every physical law that was discovered theoretically before it was confirmed; e.g., SR and GR, to name two.
Damn! Fine idea!! I'm goin' right down to the basement and stick my vacuum hose into the main panel...:)
(if there's a power blackout on the West Coast make sure I get the credit, eh!)
Anita Tension. ?
in more conventional particle physics Mitzy Dupruis could excite alot of energy at the Beacon with a particle demonstation with a pingpong ball.
It's a great article for those that love the Heaviside of life.
groan
Fanny and Freddy applied the energy in a vacuum theory to the financial world and pretty much ended it. New working theory: Money vacuums can't pay loans.
Gore Co. is applying a similar theory to global temperature to save the planet: living humans warm the planet. However, after over ten years of off-trend cooling, stressed economies, explosive growth of nanny state authority and heaps of failed predictions a new working theory is emerging: The sun heats the earth and nothing else in by either nature or man comes within an order of magnitude to matching the effect of changes with the sun output on our climate change. All of man's efforts to affect climate change are futile and worse than useless.
The continuing fraud from so-called "experts" telling us we can get something from nothing has been sold to us over and over. I may be skeptical but the only perpetual motion machines I've seen are the people that sell this snake oil. They're like black holes, sucking up time, space, energy and the big one...money.
Anyone want a pyramid dog house to tap into some free cosmic energy to make a happier pooch? http://www.ehow.com/how_4476428_use-pyramid-energy.html
Hey, nobody can out-do Midge Michaels. Not only can she propel a ping-pong ball but afterwards she drinks a glass of water! And not through her mouth.
She's quite the entertainer!
How do our Public Schools and Universities turn out this kind of product ??
Popular Science required course reading ? Time magazine science page ? perpetualmotion.com ??
Look I can imagine the possibilities just as well as the next guy, but where theoretical physics is concerned, let's be realistic here. The reality is if you tinker with the math long enough you can make anything appear plausible. That's pretty much what they've done with string theory...they're up to what, 12 or 14 theoretical dimensions needing to exist in order for the thing to work? Ummm...Ok...
'Anita Tension - stripper'
Her body is 99% water but boy, does she have enormous surface tension in all the right places!
I do wonder what the convential thinking in the efficacy of electricity was a couple of centuries ago. Cheers
Cal2
The Misty factor should never be underestimated....
Rockyt
Saw her to eh?
I love physics.
Syncro
MikeSr,
I have no idea what the "convential" thinking was 200 years ago. I do know man started thing about electricity about the same time he started thinking about alchemy. Cheers.
she used to play Frere Jacques on a slide flute, she could drink a glass of water at the same time but didnt. then they shut the act down.
what a shame it was the only multicultural french act in the city at the time.
got me humming the tune and thinking of trudeau.was around that time that he gave us the hand signal that he thought we were number one.
AHA - Eureka !! (not Electolux either) - So we are just a magnificent idea, the negative manifestation of an electrical force.
Holy mackeral, what one can learn from the internet.
I am going back to the Weblog Awards site to vote for SDA.
Teach:
M-theory identifies 11 dimensions. There really is nothing strange about dimensions beyond what we perceive. I'm sure everyone laughed at atomic theorists, too. String theories only seem to be outside of our experimental grasp. I'm pretty certain that we'll find a way to either confirm or discount them, maybe in my lifetime. I suspect it will more likely involve astronomers and space telescopes, rather than particle physicists and massive, expensive colliders.
Although I still hold out hope that the LHC will find Higgs.
Cal2
I must admit to being a fan of Misty's artistic abilities.....Pierre was a bit of an artist himself....
Man that Kaybec has everything!
This is promising stuff indeed. With a plastic bag and a vacuum (both undoubtedly readily at hand), Henry The OrganMauler, newly of the Order of Canada, could explore the outer reaches the Milky Way.
On the other hand, we would need to find a model of Electrolux that can suck and blow at the same time if we are to bestow Jack Talibanana similar astronomical laurels.
And, with the appearance of Shaken, all was calm...for the defenders of womb-boogers had arrived to the thread. And with them came their new, cool nicknames.
"Hey everyone! Check out my new name for this BABY KILLER! Cool, eh? I'm so cool, therefore, by association!"
The first word that comes to mind is 'snopes'
There was a SciFi story by James Blish that took the idea of using 'fringe' avenues of research and giving them top rank priority for funding. The idea being that the established lines of research were consuming ever increasing resources with ever diminishing results.
So a few hairball research projects that were being run by otherwise credible people were prioritized by the desired results that were expected of them
Makes for good SF but you'd be hard pressed to get that by the establishment.
Back in school I once got sidetracked and took a misstep while showing a proof on a calculus exam.
I applied all correct rules to arrive at completely different result than the one desired.
However the unintentional sidestep was not an incorrect use of the calculus, it was just not THE correct and proven formula.
It was of no use other than a topic of interest.
I think my math prof got a kick out of it.
Many theories of physics are like that.
Years ago while doing some Top Secret work I was mistakenly allowed to watch a few minutes of a timeport halograph in which Columbus presented a similar space vacuum pipe design to power his sea voyage to and from the Indies. Both the pipe and a proposed auxiliary fusion reactor were rejected by Ferdinand and Isabella. It turned out they were deeply indebted to the Sailmakers Guild for war financing. They didn't know or care if Columbus could ever find his way back or not with sails only. I lost a lot of respect for them over that.
"However the unintentional sidestep was not an incorrect use of the calculus, it was just not THE correct and proven formula."
Two possibilities:
1) Your reasoning was faulty
2) You used the correct mathematical reasoning, but did not write out a formula correctly
Which one was it? I only ask since you sound like you're trying to say that many physics theories are just mathematical odd cases. If so, that's wrong. It's not a physics theory if it doesn't represent the physical world in some way. In fact, it's usually nitpicking mathematicians that find odd cases (say, strange solutions) of physical theories that have no physical correspondence or that are not physically realisable, but that nonetheless exist.
Ural; Thanks for the comment. Just thinking we are surely only at the first stages of understanding the potential of vacuum in space. If you are familiar with the Dune series, both of my sons one now an engineer the other a lawyer, convinced me to enjoy and stretch my imagination. The discussions about the untapped potential of the space vacuum makes wonder (imagine?)about the prescience of Captain Nemo and the Nautilius. Maybe the wormholes used by the Enterprise were the result of harnessing space vacuum. ;) Cheers.
MikeSr,
The closet I got to Dune was seeing it on a bookshelf. Try out the link below.
http://tinyurl.com/6zvb5r
Sgt Lejaune; well the shoes on the other foot now eh? Sails are from China and the guilds are looking for BIG handouts...
That REALLY sucks.
Anon @ 4:42 "Don't know anything about Bearden or his work, but this forum is definitely the place to present science.
Nothing but appreciators, all."
So what are you doing here then? If we are all a bunch of inbred rednecks not even worthy of your contempt, why do you insist to keep dazzling us your "intelligence"?
Could none of your other "friends" play outside today?
Kate- Can you help me out? Since what surrounds us is a space-time continuum what is outside this package? Does the emptiness outside space have something to do with the energy proposed from within space-time? Just wonderin!
Wow, this is AWESOME! Tell me where I can buy my Zero Point (tm) generator RIGHT NOW! I've got my checkbook open, yeah baby! I'm going to slap that puppy in the back of my race car and go win the Baja 500. Should be enough juice left over to run my very own aluminum smelter and casting foundry. SWEET!
Whaddaya mean I can't buy one?
Violations of conservation of energy will not be tolerated.
As to M-theory, millions of dollars in research grants and hundreds of careers were wasted for the last ~40 years in theoretical physics because of String Theory and its descendents.
Anyone trying to research outside string theory or Super string theory or M theory faced resistance from within the community and likely would not receive research grants.
M-theory is a theory that was developed purely from mathematics and not from observations of reality.
No experimental evidence suggests that this theory is valid and no proposed experiments can be done with any current or even imagined technology.
In short, nearly 40 years of theorizing (Which led to the speculation of zero point energy and this entry) and no results always led by the stringy theorists mantra that in the future experiments will be available to prove this bloated intellectual masturbatory claptrap. /rant off
GeoMetroDynamics?
Would that be the dynamics of a Geo Metro?
Here is a video which demonstrates clearly one manifestation of Geometrodynamics.
http://video.google.ca/videosearch?client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&channel=s&hl=en&q=geo+metro&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=X&oi=video_result_group&resnum=4&ct=title#
Well anon with respect to my reasoning and my formula ... that's a fair assessment. Even though a proof is not necessarily arrived at by only one path and that any number of paths may produce a "formula" that gives the desired result.
Like I said I got sidetracked.
I still say that it happens a lot that theories evolve from mistakes. More often than some theorists would care to admit.
Aside from that .... yeah you're moistly right.
Physicists have a strange charm.